Transient elastography for screening of liver fibrosis: Cost-effectiveness analysis from six prospective cohorts in Europe and Asia

被引:114
作者
Serra-Burriel, Miquel [1 ]
Graupera, Isabel [2 ,3 ]
Toran, Pere [4 ]
Thiele, Maja [5 ,6 ]
Roulot, Dominique [7 ,8 ]
Wong, Vincent Wai-Sun [9 ]
Guha, Indra Neil [10 ,11 ]
Fabrellas, Nuria [12 ]
Arslanow, Anita [13 ,14 ]
Exposito, Carmen [4 ]
Hernandez, Rosario [15 ]
Wong, Grace Lai-Hung [9 ]
Harman, David [10 ,11 ]
Murad, Sarwa Darwish [16 ]
Krag, Aleksander [5 ,6 ]
Pera, Guillem [4 ]
Angeli, Paolo [17 ,18 ]
Galle, Peter [13 ]
Aithal, Guruprasad P. [10 ,11 ]
Caballeria, Llorenc [4 ]
Castera, Laurent [19 ,20 ]
Gines, Pere [2 ,3 ]
Lammert, Frank [1 ,2 ,14 ]
机构
[1] Univ Pompeu Fabra, Ctr Recerca Econ & Salut, Barcelona, Spain
[2] Hosp Clin Barcelona, Ctr Invest Red Enfermedades Hepat & Digest Cibere, Inst Invest Biomed August Pi & Sunyer IDIBAPS, Liver Unit, Barcelona, Spain
[3] Univ Barcelona, Fac Med & Hlth Sci, Barcelona, Spain
[4] ICS Inst Catala Salut, IDIAP Jordi Gol, USR Metropolitana Nord, Barcelona, Spain
[5] Univ Southern Denmark, Odense Univ Hosp, Odense, Denmark
[6] Odense Patient Data Exploratory Network OPEN, Dept Gastroenterol & Hepatol, Odense, Denmark
[7] Hop Avicenne, AP HP, Dept Hepatol, Bobigny, France
[8] Univ Paris 13, Sorbonne Paris Cite, Villetaneuse, France
[9] Chinese Univ Hong Kong, Dept Med & Therapeut, Hong Kong, Peoples R China
[10] Nottingham Univ Hosp NHS Trust, NIHR Nottingham Biomed Res Ctr, Nottingham, England
[11] Univ Nottingham, Nottingham, England
[12] Univ Barcelona, Inst Invest Biomed August Pi & Sunyer IDIBAPS, Ctr Invest Red Enfermedades Hepat & Digest Cibere, Fac Med & Hlth Sci,Sch Nursing, Barcelona, Spain
[13] Johannes Gutenberg Univ Mainz, Univ Med Ctr, Dept Internal Med 1, Mainz, Germany
[14] Saarland Univ, Med Ctr, Dept Med 2, Homburg, Germany
[15] Inst Catala Salut Barcelona, CAP La Marina, Barcelona, Spain
[16] Erasmus MC Univ Med Ctr, Dept Gastroenterol & Hepatol, Rotterdam, Netherlands
[17] Univ Padua, Internal Med & Hepatol, Med Dimed, Padua, Italy
[18] Gen Hosp Padova, Padua, Italy
[19] Hop Beaujon, AP HP, Dept Hepatol, Clichy, France
[20] Univ Paris 07, INSERM, Umr 1149, Ctr Rech Inflammat, Paris, France
基金
欧盟地平线“2020”;
关键词
Alcohol-related liver disease; Liver fibrosis; Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease; Stratified screening; Transient elastography; NONINVASIVE EVALUATION; STIFFNESS MEASUREMENT; GENERAL-POPULATION; DISEASE; IMPLEMENTATION; CIRRHOSIS; BARRIERS; PREVALENCE; MORTALITY; DIAGNOSIS;
D O I
10.1016/j.jhep.2019.08.019
中图分类号
R57 [消化系及腹部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
Background & Aims: Non-alcoholic fatty liver disease and alcohol-related liver disease pose an important challenge to current clinical healthcare pathways because of the large number of at-risk patients. Therefore, we aimed to explore the costeffectiveness of transient elastography (TE) as a screening method to detect liver fibrosis in a primary care pathway. Methods: Cost-effectiveness analysis was performed using reallife individual patient data from 6 independent prospective cohorts (5 from Europe and 1 from Asia). A diagnostic algorithm with conditional inference trees was developed to explore the relationships between liver stiffness, socio-demographics, comorbidities, and hepatic fibrosis, the latter assessed by fibrosis scores (FIB-4, NFS) and liver biopsies in a subset of 352 patients. We compared the incremental cost-effectiveness of a screening strategy against standard of care alongside the numbers needed to screen to diagnose a patient with fibrosis stage >= F2. Results: The data set encompassed 6,295 participants (mean age 55 +/- 12 years, BMI 27 +/- 5 kg/m(2), liver stiffness 5.6 +/- 5.0 kPa). A 9.1 kPa TE cut-off provided the best accuracy for the diagnosis of significant fibrosis (>= F2) in general population settings, whereas a threshold of 9.5 kPa was optimal for populations at-risk of alcohol-related liver disease. TE with the proposed cut-offs outperformed fibrosis scores in terms of accuracy. Screening with TE was cost-effective with mean incremental cost-effectiveness ratios ranging from 2,570 (sic)/QALY (95% CI 2,456-2,683) for a population at-risk of alcohol-related liver disease (age >= 45 years) to 6,217 (sic)/QALY (95% CI 5,832-6,601) in the general population. Overall, there was a 12% chance of TE screening being cost saving across countries and populations. Conclusions: Screening for liver fibrosis with TE in primary care is a cost-effective intervention for European and Asian populations and may even be cost saving. Lay summary: The lack of optimized public health screening strategies for the detection of liver fibrosis in adults without known liver disease presents a major healthcare challenge. Analyses from 6 independent international cohorts, with transient elastography measurements, show that a communitybased risk-stratification strategy for alcohol-related and nonalcoholic fatty liver diseases is cost-effective and potentially cost saving for our healthcare systems, as it leads to earlier identification of patients. (C) 2019 European Association for the Study of the Liver. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:1141 / 1151
页数:11
相关论文
共 53 条
[1]   Liver Fibrosis, but No Other Histologic Features, Is Associated With Long-term Outcomes of Patients With Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease [J].
Angulo, Paul ;
Kleiner, David E. ;
Dam-Larsen, Sanne ;
Adams, Leon A. ;
Bjornsson, Einar S. ;
Charatcharoenwitthaya, Phunchai ;
Mills, Peter R. ;
Keach, Jill C. ;
Lafferty, Heather D. ;
Stahler, Alisha ;
Haflidadottir, Svanhildur ;
Bendtsen, Flemming .
GASTROENTEROLOGY, 2015, 149 (02) :389-+
[2]   Nichtinvasive Früherkennung von Lebererkrankungen im Rahmen der betrieblichen GesundheitsförderungNoninvasive early detection of liver diseases as part of occupational health check-ups [J].
A. Arslanow ;
C. Baum ;
F. Lammert ;
C. S. Stokes .
Zentralblatt für Arbeitsmedizin, Arbeitsschutz und Ergonomie, 2017, 67 (4) :201-210
[3]   Cost-Effectiveness of CT Screening in the National Lung Screening Trial [J].
Black, William C. ;
Gareen, Ilana F. ;
Soneji, Samir S. ;
Sicks, JoRean D. ;
Keeler, Emmett B. ;
Aberle, Denise R. ;
Naeim, Arash ;
Church, Timothy R. ;
Silvestri, Gerard A. ;
Gorelick, Jeremy ;
Gatsonis, Constantine .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2014, 371 (19) :1793-1802
[4]   A stepwise algorithm using an at-a-glance first-line test for the non-invasive diagnosis of advanced liver fibrosis and cirrhosis [J].
Boursier, Jerome ;
de Ledinghen, Victor ;
Leroy, Vincent ;
Anty, Rodolphe ;
Francque, Sven ;
Salmon, Dominique ;
Lannes, Adrien ;
Bertrais, Sandrine ;
Oberti, Frederic ;
Fouchard-Hubert, Isabelle ;
Cales, Paul .
JOURNAL OF HEPATOLOGY, 2017, 66 (06) :1158-1165
[5]   Diagnostic accuracy and prognostic significance of blood fibrosis tests and liver stiffness measurement by FibroScan in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease [J].
Boursier, Jerome ;
Vergniol, Julien ;
Guillet, Anne ;
Hiriart, Jean-Baptiste ;
Lannes, Adrien ;
Le Bail, Brigitte ;
Michalak, Sophie ;
Chermak, Faiza ;
Bertrais, Sandrine ;
Foucher, Juliette ;
Oberti, Frederic ;
Charbonnier, Maude ;
Fouchard-Hubert, Isabelle ;
Rousselet, Marie-Christine ;
Cales, Paul ;
de Ledinghen, Victor .
JOURNAL OF HEPATOLOGY, 2016, 65 (03) :570-578
[6]   What implementation interventions increase cancer screening rates? a systematic review [J].
Brouwers, Melissa C. ;
De Vito, Carol ;
Bahirathan, Lavannya ;
Carol, Angela ;
Carroll, June C. ;
Cotterchio, Michelle ;
Dobbins, Maureen ;
Lent, Barbara ;
Levitt, Cheryl ;
Lewis, Nancy ;
McGregor, S. Elizabeth ;
Paszat, Lawrence ;
Rand, Carol ;
Wathen, Nadine .
IMPLEMENTATION SCIENCE, 2011, 6
[7]   High Prevalence of Liver Fibrosis Among European Adults With Unknown Liver Disease: A Population-Based Study [J].
Caballeria, Llorenc ;
Pera, Guillem ;
Arteaga, Ingrid ;
Rodriguez, Lluis ;
Aluma, Alba ;
Morillas, Rosa Ma ;
de la Ossa, Napoleon ;
Diaz, Alba ;
Exposito, Carmen ;
Miranda, Dolores ;
Sanchez, Carmen ;
Prats, Rosa M. A. ;
Urquizu, Marta ;
Salgado, Angels ;
Alemany, Magda ;
Martinez, Alba ;
Majeed, Irfan ;
Fabrellas, Nuria ;
Graupera, Isabel ;
Planas, Ramon ;
Ojanguren, Isabel ;
Serra, Miquel ;
Toran, Pere ;
Caballeria, Juan ;
Gines, Pere .
CLINICAL GASTROENTEROLOGY AND HEPATOLOGY, 2018, 16 (07) :1138-+
[8]  
Carter-Harris L, 2017, ANN AM THORAC SOC, V14, P1261, DOI [10.1513/annalsats.201703-204ps, 10.1513/AnnalsATS.201703-204PS]
[9]   Liver Stiffness in Nonalcoholic Fatty Liver Disease: A Comparison of Supersonic Shear Imaging, FibroScan, and ARFI With Liver Biopsy [J].
Cassinotto, Christophe ;
Boursier, Jerome ;
de Ledinghen, Victor ;
Lebigot, Jerome ;
Lapuyade, Bruno ;
Cales, Paul ;
Hiriart, Jean-Baptiste ;
Michalak, Sophie ;
Le Bail, Brigitte ;
Cartier, Victoire ;
Mouries, Amaury ;
Oberti, Frederic ;
Fouchard-Hubert, Isabelle ;
Vergniol, Julien ;
Aube, Christophe .
HEPATOLOGY, 2016, 63 (06) :1817-1827
[10]   Non-invasive evaluation of liver fibrosis using transient elastography [J].
Castera, Laurent ;
Forns, Xavier ;
Alberti, Alfredo .
JOURNAL OF HEPATOLOGY, 2008, 48 (05) :835-847