Organ conscription in the light of the constitutional right to health protection

被引:1
作者
Moya Guillem, Clara [1 ]
Rodriguez-Arias, David [2 ]
Morla Gonzalez, Marina [3 ]
De Miguel Beriain, Inigo [4 ]
Molina Perez, Alberto [5 ]
Ortega-Deballon, Ivan [6 ]
机构
[1] Univ Alicante, Alicante, Spain
[2] Univ Granada, Granada, Spain
[3] Univ Leon, Leon, Spain
[4] Univ Basque Country, Leioa, Spain
[5] IESA CSIC, Cordoba, Spain
[6] Univ Alcala, Madrid, Spain
来源
REVISTA ESPANOLA DE DERECHO CONSTITUCIONAL | 2021年 / 41卷 / 122期
关键词
Donation; transplantation; confiscatory model; post mortem interests; conscientious objection; autonomy of will; quality of life; commodification; CADAVERIC ORGANS; TRANSPLANTATION; ATTITUDES; ALTRUISM; DONATION; KIDNEY; MARKET; DEATH; MODEL;
D O I
10.18042/cepc/redc.122.06
中图分类号
D9 [法律]; DF [法律];
学科分类号
0301 ;
摘要
This paper analyses the arguments for and against what we have called automatic organ procurement model in relation to the organs of the deceased. For this purpose, this work provides empirical evidence to assess the potential impact of this model on donation rates and on public opinion. Specifically, we examine first the reasons supporting this model, with special reference to utilitarian and justice arguments. On the other hand, we analyse both the approaches based on the violation of pre mortem and post mortem interests opposing this theoretical model and the rejection the model would generate in the population. Finally, we point out the aspects that, in our opinion, should be exhaustively regulated if this model were implemented. In particular, we refer to the legal status of the human body, the treatments for end-of-life patients, the incentives for health professionals and the recognition of the right to conscientious objection
引用
收藏
页码:183 / 213
页数:31
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   PRISONERS ARE PEOPLE: THE RIGHT OF DEATH-ROW INMATES TO RECEIVE LIFESAVING ORGAN DONATIONS [J].
Kilkenny, Ryan .
RUTGERS UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW, 2020, 72 (03) :837-866
[42]   Reply to "The right to become an organ and tissue donor at the end of life of critically ill patient" [J].
Estella, A. .
MEDICINA INTENSIVA, 2020, 44 (01) :60-60
[43]   The public debate on organ donation and presumed consent in Denmark: Are the right issues being addressed? [J].
Jensen, Anja M. B. ;
Larsen, Johanne Bjorg .
SCANDINAVIAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2020, 48 (05) :480-485
[44]   THE INFLUENCE OF LONG-TERM MORBIDITY ON HEALTH-STATUS AND REHABILITATION FOLLOWING PEDIATRIC ORGAN-TRANSPLANTATION [J].
KEOWN, PA ;
SHACKLETON, CR ;
FERGUSON, BM .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PEDIATRICS, 1992, 151 :S70-S75
[45]   Critical analysis of communication strategies in public health promotion: An empirical-ethical study on organ donation in Germany [J].
Hansen, Solveig Lena ;
Pfaller, Larissa ;
Schicktanz, Silke .
BIOETHICS, 2021, 35 (02) :161-172
[46]   Protection behaviour: a phenomenon affecting organ and tissue donation in the 21st century? [J].
Kent, BC .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF NURSING STUDIES, 2004, 41 (03) :273-284
[47]   Health care-related infections in solid organ transplants [J].
Sola, A. F. ;
Bittencourt, A. R. C. ;
Guerra, C. M. ;
Godoy, H. L. ;
Medeiros, E. A. S. .
BRAZILIAN JOURNAL OF INFECTIOUS DISEASES, 2007, 11 (06) :567-570
[48]   Peculiarities of consideration of cases in the ECtHR regarding the protection of constitutional human rights related to the fourth generation of somatic rights [J].
Tarasevych, Tetiana ;
Yuzko, Tetiana ;
Hrabovska, Oksana ;
Romanova, Olena ;
Lisova, Kateryna .
JURIDICAL TRIBUNE-TRIBUNA JURIDICA, 2023, 13 (04) :644-667
[49]   CHANGES IN THE LEGAL PROTECTION OF THE RIGHT TO CONSCIENTIOUS OBJECTION [J].
Navarro Floria, Juan G. .
REVISTA GENERAL DE DERECHO CANONICO Y DERECHO ECLESIASTICO DEL ESTADO, 2016, (42)
[50]   Organ donation: reducing the risk of health care-associated infection [J].
Bleakley, Greg ;
Cole, Mark .
NURSING IN CRITICAL CARE, 2019, 24 (03) :149-152