A realistic approach to the evaluation of the quality management movement in health care systems: a comparison between European and African contexts based on Mintzberg's organizational models

被引:40
作者
Blaise, P [1 ]
Kegels, G [1 ]
机构
[1] Inst Trop Med, Dept Publ Hlth, B-2000 Antwerp, Belgium
关键词
health services research; quality assurance; health care; organizational culture; Europe; Africa;
D O I
10.1002/hpm.769
中图分类号
R19 [保健组织与事业(卫生事业管理)];
学科分类号
摘要
The quality movement is gaining momentum worldwide in the field of health care. Initiated in industrialized countries, it steadily grows in Africa. However, there is no evidence that approaches designed to address issues in a given organizational context have the same effect in another one where issues present differently. Along the epistemological paradigm of realistic evaluation proposed by Pawson and Tilley, we use Mintzberg's organizational models to compare the configurations of European and African health care organizations and the trends followed by the quality management movement in both contexts. We illustrate how European health systems traditionally emphasize professional autonomy while African health systems are structured as command and control hierarchical systems. We illustrate how the quality movement in Europe emphasizes standardization of procedures, a characteristic of a mechanistic organization, while excessive standardization is part of the quality problem in Africa. We suggest that instilling professionalism may be a way forward for the quality movement in Africa to improve patient focus and responsiveness of responsible professionals. We also suggest that our interpretation of broad trends and contrasts may be used as a useful departure point to study the wide contextual diversity of the African experience with quality management. Copyright (C) 2004 John Wiley Sons, Ltd.
引用
收藏
页码:337 / 364
页数:28
相关论文
共 119 条
[1]   A model for clinical governance in primary care groups [J].
Baker, R ;
Lakhani, M ;
Fraser, R ;
Cheater, F .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1999, 318 (7186) :779-783
[2]   Perceived quality of care of primary health care services in Burkina Faso [J].
Baltussen, RMPM ;
Yé, Y ;
Haddad, S ;
Sauerborn, RS .
HEALTH POLICY AND PLANNING, 2002, 17 (01) :42-48
[3]  
Beecham L, 2001, BRIT MED J, V323, P70
[4]  
Blaise P., 2002, QUALITY HIGHER ED HL
[5]  
*BMA, 2002, NEW GEN MED SERV CON
[6]   Methods for external evaluation of health care institutions [J].
Bohigas, L ;
Heaton, C .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR QUALITY IN HEALTH CARE, 2000, 12 (03) :231-238
[7]   The Zambia Quality Assurance Program: successes and challenges [J].
Bouchet, B ;
Francisco, M ;
Ovretveit, J .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL FOR QUALITY IN HEALTH CARE, 2002, 14 :89-95
[8]  
BOUCHET B, 2002, 19 INT C INT SOC QUA
[9]   Clinical governance: bridging the gap between managerial and clinical approaches to quality of care [J].
Buetow, SA ;
Roland, M .
QUALITY IN HEALTH CARE, 1999, 8 (03) :184-190
[10]   Primary care groups - Improving the quality of care through clinical governance [J].
Campbell, S ;
Roland, M ;
Wilkin, D .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2001, 322 (7302) :1580-1582