Timing and thermal influence of late orogenic extension in the lower crust: a U-Pb geochronological study from the southwest Grenville orogen, Canada

被引:59
作者
Ketchum, JWF
Heaman, LM
Krogh, TE
Culshaw, NG
Jamieson, RA
机构
[1] Dalhousie Univ, Dept Earth Sci, Halifax, NS B3H 3J5, Canada
[2] Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, ON M5S 2C6, Canada
关键词
Central Gneiss Belt; Grenville Province; pegmatite dykes; titanite; U-Pb geochronology; zircon;
D O I
10.1016/S0301-9268(97)00079-X
中图分类号
P [天文学、地球科学];
学科分类号
07 ;
摘要
In the southwestern Grenville Province, the Central Gneiss Belt consists of a bell of parautochthonous rocks in the north and a collage of allochthonous lithotectonic domains in the south. Near Pointe-au-Baril, Ontario: the allochthon-parautochthon boundary is marked by the Shawanaga shear zone, a northwest-directed thrust zone between the Britt and Shawanaga domains that was reactivated during ductile, top-to-the-southeast extensional shearing. U-Pb ages of 1042 + 4/-2, 1019 +/- 4 and 988 +/- 2 Ma for granitic pegmatite dykes that are pre-kinematic, late syn-kinematic, and post-kinematic with respect to top-side-down displacement constrain major extensional transport on the Shawanaga shear zone to ca. 1020 Ma. However, nearly all the zircons in the dykes are inherited from a pre-Grenvillian, ca. 1460 Ma granitic host rock to the dykes. Recognition of the inherited nature of these grains comes from the multi-dyke dating approach employed here, and illustrates a potential pitfall in dating shear zone movement using only single dykes interpreted as syn-kinematic. U-Pb ages of metamorphic titanite from 14 samples collected in a transect across the Shawanaga shear zone span a 93 m.y. segment of concordia. These ages do not Correlate with titanite grain size or vary systematically from domain to domain. However, when sample microtexture, strain stale, structural position, titanite morphology, and pegmatite U-Pb data are considered together, the titanite ages can be reasonably inferred to date: (1) regional metamorphism (1049-1045 Ma); (2) cooling below the titanite isotopic closure temperature (similar to 600 degrees C) during extensional unroofing (1028-1018 Ma); (3) recrystallization-controlled titanite growth and (or) isotopic resetting in high-strain zones (1008-1000 Ma); (4) post-kinematic recrystallization, most likely in the presence of a late fluid phase (967-956 Ma). Each titanite age group is made lip of samples from both the Britt and Shawanaga domains, indicating that these processes were not restricted to a single domain bur rather occurred within localized regimes, some which were clearly structurally controlled. The 93 m.y. spread of concordant titanite ages within a 20 x 20 km area demonstrates that cooling through isotopic closure is only one of several possibilities to be considered when interpreting metamorphic titanite ages in high-grade orogenic terranes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. In the southwestern Grenville Province, the Central Gneiss Belt consists of a bell of parautochthonous rocks in the north and a collage of allochthonous lithotectonic domains in the south. Near Pointe-au-Baril, Ontario: the allochthon-parautochthon boundary is marked by the Shawanaga shear zone, a northwest-directed thrust zone between the Britt and Shawanaga domains that was reactivated during ductile, top-to-the-southeast extensional shearing. U-Pb ages of 1042 + 4/-2, 1019 +/- 4 and 988 +/- 2 Ma for granitic pegmatite dykes that are pre-kinematic, late syn-kinematic, and post-kinematic with respect to top-side-down displacement constrain major extensional transport on the Shawanaga shear zone to ca. 1020 Ma. However, nearly all the zircons in the dykes are inherited from a pre-Grenvillian, ca. 1460 Ma granitic host rock to the dykes. Recognition of the inherited nature of these grains comes from the multi-dyke dating approach employed here, and illustrates a potential pitfall in dating shear zone movement using only single dykes interpreted as syn-kinematic. U-Pb ages of metamorphic titanite from 14 samples collected in a transect across the Shawanaga shear zone span a 93 m.y. segment of concordia. These ages do not Correlate with titanite grain size or vary systematically from domain to domain. However, when sample microtexture, strain stale, structural position, titanite morphology, and pegmatite U-Pb data are considered together, the titanite ages can be reasonably inferred to date: (1) regional metamorphism (1049-1045 Ma); (2) cooling below the titanite isotopic closure temperature (similar to 600 degrees C) during extensional unroofing (1028-1018 Ma); (3) recrystallization-controlled titanite growth and (or) isotopic resetting in high-strain zones (1008-1000 Ma); (4) post-kinematic recrystallization, most likely in the presence of a late fluid phase (967-956 Ma). Each titanite age group is made lip of samples from both the Britt and Shawanaga domains, indicating that these processes were not restricted to a single domain bur rather occurred within localized regimes, some which were clearly structurally controlled. The 93 m.y. spread of concordant titanite ages within a 20 x 20 km area demonstrates that cooling through isotopic closure is only one of several possibilities to be considered when interpreting metamorphic titanite ages in high-grade orogenic terranes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. In the southwestern Grenville Province, the Central Gneiss Belt consists of a bell of parautochthonous rocks in the north and a collage of allochthonous lithotectonic domains in the south. Near Pointe-au-Baril, Ontario: the allochthon-parautochthon boundary is marked by the Shawanaga shear zone, a northwest-directed thrust zone between the Britt and Shawanaga domains that was reactivated during ductile, top-to-the-southeast extensional shearing. U-Pb ages of 1042 + 4/-2, 1019 +/- 4 and 988 +/- 2 Ma for granitic pegmatite dykes that are pre-kinematic, late syn-kinematic, and post-kinematic with respect to top-side-down displacement constrain major extensional transport on the Shawanaga shear zone to ca. 1020 Ma. However, nearly all the zircons in the dykes are inherited from a pre-Grenvillian, ca. 1460 Ma granitic host rock to the dykes. Recognition of the inherited nature of these grains comes from the multi-dyke dating approach employed here, and illustrates a potential pitfall in dating shear zone movement using only single dykes interpreted as syn-kinematic. U-Pb ages of metamorphic titanite from 14 samples collected in a transect across the Shawanaga shear zone span a 93 m.y. segment of concordia. These ages do not Correlate with titanite grain size or vary systematically from domain to domain. However, when sample microtexture, strain stale, structural position, titanite morphology, and pegmatite U-Pb data are considered together, the titanite ages can be reasonably inferred to date: (1) regional metamorphism (1049-1045 Ma); (2) cooling below the titanite isotopic closure temperature (similar to 600 degrees C) during extensional unroofing (1028-1018 Ma); (3) recrystallization-controlled titanite growth and (or) isotopic resetting in high-strain zones (1008-1000 Ma); (4) post-kinematic recrystallization, most likely in the presence of a late fluid phase (967-956 Ma). Each titanite age group is made lip of samples from both the Britt and Shawanaga domains, indicating that these processes were not restricted to a single domain bur rather occurred within localized regimes, some which were clearly structurally controlled. The 93 m.y. spread of concordant titanite ages within a 20 x 20 km area demonstrates that cooling through isotopic closure is only one of several possibilities to be considered when interpreting metamorphic titanite ages in high-grade orogenic terranes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. In the southwestern Grenville Province, the Central Gneiss Belt consists of a bell of parautochthonous rocks in the north and a collage of allochthonous lithotectonic domains in the south. Near Pointe-au-Baril, Ontario: the allochthon-parautochthon boundary is marked by the Shawanaga shear zone, a northwest-directed thrust zone between the Britt and Shawanaga domains that was reactivated during ductile, top-to-the-southeast extensional shearing. U-Pb ages of 1042 + 4/-2, 1019 +/- 4 and 988 +/- 2 Ma for granitic pegmatite dykes that are pre-kinematic, late syn-kinematic, and post-kinematic with respect to top-side-down displacement constrain major extensional transport on the Shawanaga shear zone to ca. 1020 Ma. However, nearly all the zircons in the dykes are inherited from a pre-Grenvillian, ca. 1460 Ma granitic host rock to the dykes. Recognition of the inherited nature of these grains comes from the multi-dyke dating approach employed here, and illustrates a potential pitfall in dating shear zone movement using only single dykes interpreted as syn-kinematic. U-Pb ages of metamorphic titanite from 14 samples collected in a transect across the Shawanaga shear zone span a 93 m.y. segment of concordia. These ages do not Correlate with titanite grain size or vary systematically from domain to domain. However, when sample microtexture, strain stale, structural position, titanite morphology, and pegmatite U-Pb data are considered together, the titanite ages can be reasonably inferred to date: (1) regional metamorphism (1049-1045 Ma); (2) cooling below the titanite isotopic closure temperature (similar to 600 degrees C) during extensional unroofing (1028-1018 Ma); (3) recrystallization-controlled titanite growth and (or) isotopic resetting in high-strain zones (1008-1000 Ma); (4) post-kinematic recrystallization, most likely in the presence of a late fluid phase (967-956 Ma). Each titanite age group is made lip of samples from both the Britt and Shawanaga domains, indicating that these processes were not restricted to a single domain bur rather occurred within localized regimes, some which were clearly structurally controlled. The 93 m.y. spread of concordant titanite ages within a 20 x 20 km area demonstrates that cooling through isotopic closure is only one of several possibilities to be considered when interpreting metamorphic titanite ages in high-grade orogenic terranes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. In the southwestern Grenville Province, the Central Gneiss Belt consists of a bell of parautochthonous rocks in the north and a collage of allochthonous lithotectonic domains in the south. Near Pointe-au-Baril, Ontario: the allochthon-parautochthon boundary is marked by the Shawanaga shear zone, a northwest-directed thrust zone between the Britt and Shawanaga domains that was reactivated during ductile, top-to-the-southeast extensional shearing. U-Pb ages of 1042 + 4/-2, 1019 +/- 4 and 988 +/- 2 Ma for granitic pegmatite dykes that are pre-kinematic, late syn-kinematic, and post-kinematic with respect to top-side-down displacement constrain major extensional transport on the Shawanaga shear zone to ca. 1020 Ma. However, nearly all the zircons in the dykes are inherited from a pre-Grenvillian, ca. 1460 Ma granitic host rock to the dykes. Recognition of the inherited nature of these grains comes from the multi-dyke dating approach employed here, and illustrates a potential pitfall in dating shear zone movement using only single dykes interpreted as syn-kinematic. U-Pb ages of metamorphic titanite from 14 samples collected in a transect across the Shawanaga shear zone span a 93 m.y. segment of concordia. These ages do not Correlate with titanite grain size or vary systematically from domain to domain. However, when sample microtexture, strain stale, structural position, titanite morphology, and pegmatite U-Pb data are considered together, the titanite ages can be reasonably inferred to date: (1) regional metamorphism (1049-1045 Ma); (2) cooling below the titanite isotopic closure temperature (similar to 600 degrees C) during extensional unroofing (1028-1018 Ma); (3) recrystallization-controlled titanite growth and (or) isotopic resetting in high-strain zones (1008-1000 Ma); (4) post-kinematic recrystallization, most likely in the presence of a late fluid phase (967-956 Ma). Each titanite age group is made lip of samples from both the Britt and Shawanaga domains, indicating that these processes were not restricted to a single domain bur rather occurred within localized regimes, some which were clearly structurally controlled. The 93 m.y. spread of concordant titanite ages within a 20 x 20 km area demonstrates that cooling through isotopic closure is only one of several possibilities to be considered when interpreting metamorphic titanite ages in high-grade orogenic terranes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. In the southwestern Grenville Province, the Central Gneiss Belt consists of a bell of parautochthonous rocks in the north and a collage of allochthonous lithotectonic domains in the south. Near Pointe-au-Baril, Ontario: the allochthon-parautochthon boundary is marked by the Shawanaga shear zone, a northwest-directed thrust zone between the Britt and Shawanaga domains that was reactivated during ductile, top-to-the-southeast extensional shearing. U-Pb ages of 1042 + 4/-2, 1019 +/- 4 and 988 +/- 2 Ma for granitic pegmatite dykes that are pre-kinematic, late syn-kinematic, and post-kinematic with respect to top-side-down displacement constrain major extensional transport on the Shawanaga shear zone to ca. 1020 Ma. However, nearly all the zircons in the dykes are inherited from a pre-Grenvillian, ca. 1460 Ma granitic host rock to the dykes. Recognition of the inherited nature of these grains comes from the multi-dyke dating approach employed here, and illustrates a potential pitfall in dating shear zone movement using only single dykes interpreted as syn-kinematic. U-Pb ages of metamorphic titanite from 14 samples collected in a transect across the Shawanaga shear zone span a 93 m.y. segment of concordia. These ages do not Correlate with titanite grain size or vary systematically from domain to domain. However, when sample microtexture, strain stale, structural position, titanite morphology, and pegmatite U-Pb data are considered together, the titanite ages can be reasonably inferred to date: (1) regional metamorphism (1049-1045 Ma); (2) cooling below the titanite isotopic closure temperature (similar to 600 degrees C) during extensional unroofing (1028-1018 Ma); (3) recrystallization-controlled titanite growth and (or) isotopic resetting in high-strain zones (1008-1000 Ma); (4) post-kinematic recrystallization, most likely in the presence of a late fluid phase (967-956 Ma). Each titanite age group is made lip of samples from both the Britt and Shawanaga domains, indicating that these processes were not restricted to a single domain bur rather occurred within localized regimes, some which were clearly structurally controlled. The 93 m.y. spread of concordant titanite ages within a 20 x 20 km area demonstrates that cooling through isotopic closure is only one of several possibilities to be considered when interpreting metamorphic titanite ages in high-grade orogenic terranes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V. In the southwestern Grenville Province, the Central Gneiss Belt consists of a bell of parautochthonous rocks in the north and a collage of allochthonous lithotectonic domains in the south. Near Pointe-au-Baril, Ontario: the allochthon-parautochthon boundary is marked by the Shawanaga shear zone, a northwest-directed thrust zone between the Britt and Shawanaga domains that was reactivated during ductile, top-to-the-southeast extensional shearing. U-Pb ages of 1042 + 4/-2, 1019 +/- 4 and 988 +/- 2 Ma for granitic pegmatite dykes that are pre-kinematic, late syn-kinematic, and post-kinematic with respect to top-side-down displacement constrain major extensional transport on the Shawanaga shear zone to ca. 1020 Ma. However, nearly all the zircons in the dykes are inherited from a pre-Grenvillian, ca. 1460 Ma granitic host rock to the dykes. Recognition of the inherited nature of these grains comes from the multi-dyke dating approach employed here, and illustrates a potential pitfall in dating shear zone movement using only single dykes interpreted as syn-kinematic. U-Pb ages of metamorphic titanite from 14 samples collected in a transect across the Shawanaga shear zone span a 93 m.y. segment of concordia. These ages do not Correlate with titanite grain size or vary systematically from domain to domain. However, when sample microtexture, strain stale, structural position, titanite morphology, and pegmatite U-Pb data are considered together, the titanite ages can be reasonably inferred to date: (1) regional metamorphism (1049-1045 Ma); (2) cooling below the titanite isotopic closure temperature (similar to 600 degrees C) during extensional unroofing (1028-1018 Ma); (3) recrystallization-controlled titanite growth and (or) isotopic resetting in high-strain zones (1008-1000 Ma); (4) post-kinematic recrystallization, most likely in the presence of a late fluid phase (967-956 Ma). Each titanite age group is made lip of samples from both the Britt and Shawanaga domains, indicating that these processes were not restricted to a single domain bur rather occurred within localized regimes, some which were clearly structurally controlled. The 93 m.y. spread of concordant titanite ages within a 20 x 20 km area demonstrates that cooling through isotopic closure is only one of several possibilities to be considered when interpreting metamorphic titanite ages in high-grade orogenic terranes. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science B.V.
引用
收藏
页码:25 / 45
页数:21
相关论文
共 77 条
[1]   THERMOBAROMETRY AND PRESSURE TEMPERATURE PATHS IN THE GRENVILLE PROVINCE OF ONTARIO [J].
ANOVITZ, LM ;
ESSENE, EJ .
JOURNAL OF PETROLOGY, 1990, 31 (01) :197-241
[2]   Late orogenic, plastic to brittle extension along the Robertson Lake shear zone: Implications for the style of deep-crustal extension in the Grenville orogen, Canada [J].
Busch, JP ;
vanderPluijm, BA .
PRECAMBRIAN RESEARCH, 1996, 77 (1-2) :41-57
[3]   TECTONIC AND METAMORPHIC EVENTS IN THE WESTERNMOST GRENVILLE PROVINCE, CENTRAL ONTARIO - NEW RESULTS FROM HIGH-PRECISION U-PB ZIRCON GEOCHRONOLOGY [J].
BUSSY, F ;
KROGH, TE ;
KLEMENS, WP ;
SCHWERDTNER, WM .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF EARTH SCIENCES, 1995, 32 (05) :660-671
[4]  
CARLSON KA, 1990, GEOL SOC AM BULL, V102, P174, DOI 10.1130/0016-7606(1990)102<0174:MMOTBS>2.3.CO
[5]  
2
[6]   NEOARCHEAN TRONDHJEMITIC AND TONALITIC ORTHOGNEISSES IDENTIFIED WITHIN THE NORTHERN GRENVILLE PROVINCE IN ONTARIO BY PRECISE U-PB DATING AND PETROLOGIC STUDIES [J].
CHEN, YD ;
KROGH, TE ;
LUMBERS, SB .
PRECAMBRIAN RESEARCH, 1995, 72 (3-4) :263-281
[7]   U-PB GEOCHRONOLOGICAL CONSTRAINTS ON THE TECTONIC EVOLUTION OF THE GRENVILLE PROVINCE, WESTERN LABRADOR [J].
CONNELLY, JN ;
HEAMAN, LM .
PRECAMBRIAN RESEARCH, 1993, 63 (1-2) :123-142
[9]   U-Pb age constraints for the lithotectonic evolution of the Grenville province along the Mauricie transect, Quebec [J].
Corrigan, D ;
vanBreemen, O .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF EARTH SCIENCES, 1997, 34 (03) :299-316
[10]   PRE-GRENVILLIAN EVOLUTION AND GRENVILLIAN OVERPRINTING OF THE PARAUTOCHTHONOUS BELT IN KEY-HARBOR, ONTARIO - U-PB AND FIELD CONSTRAINTS [J].
CORRIGAN, D ;
CULSHAW, NG ;
MORTENSEN, JK .
CANADIAN JOURNAL OF EARTH SCIENCES, 1994, 31 (03) :583-596