Proximal urea cycle defects are challenging to detect with newborn screening: Results of a prospective pilot study using post-analytical tools

The purpose of this pilot project was to evaluate the efficacy of the Collaborative Integrated Laboratory Reports (CLIR) postanalytical tools from Mayo Clinic for detection of newborns with proximal urea cycle disorders (PUCD) in the Georgia newborn screening program that uses the underivatized Neobase2 kit (Perkin Elmer). We evaluated 138,560 newborn screening (NBS) samples (between 125,000 and 130,000 children) and used the CLIR result interpretation guidelines to stratify results. Children at higher risk of having a PUCD received follow-up services including confirmatory lab testing (ammonia, plasma amino acids, urine orotic acid) or a repeat NBS sample. We made multiple adjustments to our CLIR PUCD tool and to our follow-up algorithms in order to reduce false positives. Regardless, a high number of NBS samples resulted with false positives in part due to the glutamine peak also containing lysine. No children were diagnosed with a PUCD during our study period, and the Emory Genetics Metabolic Center is unaware of any children diagnosed outside of the NBS system during that time. Based on our experience, PUCD is not suitable for statewide NBS using Neobase2 and CLIR. Other methodologies that can separate glutamine from other amino acids may have better performance.