Intergenerational approach of the Shoah memory: A differentiated transmission in the bosom of the family

被引:2
|
作者
Drezdner, Rachel [1 ]
Anaut, Marie [1 ]
Cyrulnik, Boris [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Lyon 2, Lab CRPPC, F-69000 Lyon, France
[2] Univ Toulon & Var, F-83000 Toulon, France
来源
ANNALES MEDICO-PSYCHOLOGIQUES | 2016年 / 174卷 / 05期
关键词
Family; Filiation; Intergenerational relation; Memory; Psychological trauma; Intergenerational relationships; Shoah;
D O I
10.1016/j.amp.2015.09.016
中图分类号
R9 [药学];
学科分类号
1007 ;
摘要
In more of 80% of the cases seen in my thesis research, we see a strong wish not to transmit stories about the Shoah: transmitting this equals transmitting death. I speak about "un axe de l'entente transgenerationnelle". Sometimes, transmission is late. The "children" are front of aged parents (more than 80) when a dialogue begins. Our research focuses on the complex dynamics of the intergenerational relationships, within the framework of the transmission of the memory of the Shoah and particularly in one very special family. The conclusions cannot be generalized, but make us think about the complexity of transmission of Shoah. The transmission of the Shoah in between two successive generations is not only influenced by the history and the emotions described, but it also involves specificities in the modes of transmission within the family. What are we saying to each of our children? How is the message being received? The transmission clearly depends on the level of the trauma in personal stories, though not exclusively so. Parent's discourse varies, sometimes considerably, from one child to another. What is passed on from parents' story to children can differ from one sibling to another. In this article, we choose to analysis a complex family situation, which highlights the differences in the intergenerational transmissions between a mother and her two sons. In this article, the mother in question is about 99, and her two children are 70 and 68. She began to speak when she was 85. Two films are issued from her story. Objectives.-The aim of this research is to study two modes of transmission of the experience of the Shoah, from the generation who lived it to the next and to try to understand the complexity of this transmission within a family. We more particularly centered on the analysis of the modes of exchanges between both dyads "mother elder son" and "mother younger son". Method.-This research is supported on some complementary data collections: the study shows that the transmission between the mother and her children is very differentiated with each son. Cross-referencing the data shows very specifically interactions in the two dyads and real differences in the way of relating between the mother and each child. They attest about the complexity of the intergenerational transmission about the Shoah within a family. Results.-(1) The mother orientates her discourse: the oldest specially receives negative words without nuances. For the youngest transmission it is more complex because more nuanced, and sometimes positive. (2) The oldest makes himself as a recipient of his mother words, as well as the second takes more distances with his mother's chosen words. Conclusions.-Transmission is not monolithic. The mother orientates her discourse. She chose to transmit to the oldest (in this story) the dark and mortifying side from her experience of the Shoah. This child became the recipient of her anxiety and her nightmares. On the contrary, she speaks with a lot of humor and nuances of her adventures in the Resistance to the second child, and he knows in his analysis of her discourse, how to take distances. (C) 2015 Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:352 / 358
页数:7
相关论文
共 32 条
  • [1] Transition to parenthood and intergenerational relationships: the ethical value of family memory
    Amadini, Monica
    ETHICS AND EDUCATION, 2015, 10 (01) : 36 - 48
  • [3] Co-constructing Family Memory: Understanding the Intergenerational Practices of Passing on Family Stories
    Jones, Jasmine
    Ackerman, Mark S.
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2018 CHI CONFERENCE ON HUMAN FACTORS IN COMPUTING SYSTEMS (CHI 2018), 2018,
  • [4] Stability and change in the intergenerational family: a convoy approach
    Antonucci, Toni C.
    Birditt, Kira S.
    Sherman, Carey W.
    Trinh, Sarah
    AGEING & SOCIETY, 2011, 31 : 1084 - 1106
  • [5] Intergenerational transmission of social memory: a narrative review1
    Rojas-Granada, Cristian
    FAMILIES RELATIONSHIPS AND SOCIETIES, 2024,
  • [6] Running in the FAMILY: understanding and predicting the intergenerational transmission of mental illness
    van Houtum, Lisanne A. E. M.
    Baare, William F. C.
    Beckmann, Christian F.
    Castro-Fornieles, Josefina
    Cecil, Charlotte A. M.
    Dittrich, Juliane
    Ebdrup, Bjrn H.
    Fegert, Joerg M.
    Havdahl, Alexandra
    Hillegers, Manon H. J.
    Kalisch, Raffael
    Kushner, Steven A.
    Mansuy, Isabelle M.
    Mezinska, Signe
    Moreno, Carmen
    Muetzel, Ryan L.
    Neumann, Alexander
    Nordentoft, Merete
    Pingault, Jean-Baptiste
    Preisig, Martin
    Raballo, Andrea
    Saunders, John
    Sprooten, Emma
    Sugranyes, Gisela
    Tiemeier, Henning
    van Woerden, Geeske M.
    Vandeleur, Caroline L.
    van Haren, Neeltje E. M.
    EUROPEAN CHILD & ADOLESCENT PSYCHIATRY, 2024, 33 (11) : 3885 - 3898
  • [7] Transfilial negotiations and palimpsestuous traces: queering postcolonial memory and intergenerational transmission
    Quinan, C. L.
    SUBJECTIVITY, 2021, 14 (03) : 104 - 118
  • [8] The Role of Family as a Channel of Intergenerational Transmission of Volunteer Traditions in Contemporary Russia
    Mersianova, Irina
    Malakhov, Dmitry
    Ivanova, Natalya
    JOURNAL OF ECONOMIC SOCIOLOGY-EKONOMICHESKAYA SOTSIOLOGIYA, 2019, 20 (03): : 66 - 89
  • [9] The Spanish Civil War and Intergenerational Transmission of Political Identity through the Family
    Castilla-Estevez, David
    REVISTA ESPANOLA DE INVESTIGACIONES SOCIOLOGICAS, 2021, (176): : 21 - 33
  • [10] Transfilial negotiations and palimpsestuous traces: queering postcolonial memory and intergenerational transmission
    C. L. Quinan
    Subjectivity, 2021, 14 : 104 - 118