Public opinion surveys about xenotransplantation

被引:57
作者
Hagelin, J [1 ]
机构
[1] Hlth & Safety Lab, Sheffield, S Yorkshire, England
关键词
opinion; public; xenotransplantation;
D O I
10.1111/j.1399-3089.2004.00172.x
中图分类号
R-3 [医学研究方法]; R3 [基础医学];
学科分类号
1001 ;
摘要
Background: Xenotransplantation may eventually provide a solution to the worldwide shortage of human organs for transplantation. Xenotransplantation is surrounded by profound ethical issues, both for the potential recipients and for the society as a whole. Concurrent with increased scientific interest, there has been an increasing number of quantitative public opinion surveys conducted about xenotransplantation in the last decade. The aim of the present study was to elucidate these surveys, and to assess some factors that may affect the outcome of them. Materials and methods: Surveys were identified by web and literature searches using key words in Medline and ISI Web of Knowledge. Reference lists of identified surveys were checked. Data was obtained from Inter-University Consortium for Political and Social Research (ICPSR) and directly from authors whose data were presented in another way than percentages. In total, the present material covered surveys from 35 sources, including 23 countries. Results and discussion: Results showed that almost half of the respondents accept xenotransplantation, whereas the remaining half did either not accept or did not have/state an opinion. Over time, the proportions of acceptance seemed unchanged. The proportion of those who did not accept decreased and the remaining proportion increased. This pattern was evident in Europe and the US, but not in Japan. Gender and education were found to be associated with opinions to xenotransplantation. The influence of religion was not as straightforward. This may partly depend on how religiosity was measured in the polls. Wording of items influenced levels of acceptance. If a xenotransplant was the ''only choice'' proportions of acceptance increased, and if a ''risk for zoonotic diseases'' was stated proportions of acceptance decreased. When wording of survey items was somewhat comparable, there were often, but not always, minor differences in proportions of acceptance between surveys from different sources. Trends in opinions are best measured by the use of the same items. It is however difficult to phrase items that will not be affected by external events.
引用
收藏
页码:551 / 558
页数:8
相关论文
共 51 条
  • [1] *AM BOARD FAM PRAC, 1985, RIGHTS RESP HEALTHC
  • [2] *AM PUBL ATT ORG D, 1993, COND PARTN ORG DON
  • [3] [Anonymous], US BIOTECHNOLOGY STU
  • [4] [Anonymous], 1996, Questions and answers in attitude surveys
  • [5] BABOON-TO-HUMAN CARDIAC XENOTRANSPLANTATION IN A NEONATE
    BAILEY, LL
    NEHLSENCANNARELLA, SL
    CONCEPCION, W
    JOLLEY, WB
    [J]. JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1985, 254 (23): : 3321 - 3329
  • [6] *BET XEN KOMM, 1999, FRAN ART ANN TRANSPL, P485
  • [7] English nursing and medical students' attitudes towards organ donation
    Cantwell, M
    Clifford, C
    [J]. JOURNAL OF ADVANCED NURSING, 2000, 32 (04) : 961 - 968
  • [8] Chapman LE, 2003, CURR TOP MICROBIOL, V278, P23
  • [9] Survey results of transplant patients' attitudes on xenografting
    Coffman, KL
    Sher, L
    Hoffman, A
    Rojter, S
    Folk, P
    Cramer, DV
    Vierling, J
    Villamel, F
    Podesta, L
    Demetriou, A
    Makowka, L
    [J]. PSYCHOSOMATICS, 1998, 39 (04) : 379 - 383
  • [10] Problematic publics: A critical review of surveys of public attitudes to biotechnology
    Davison, A
    Barns, I
    Schibeci, R
    [J]. SCIENCE TECHNOLOGY & HUMAN VALUES, 1997, 22 (03) : 317 - 348