Comparison of DNA Quantification Methods for Next Generation Sequencing

被引:88
作者
Robin, Jerome D. [1 ,3 ]
Ludlow, Andrew T. [1 ]
LaRanger, Ryan [1 ]
Wright, Woodring E. [1 ]
Shay, Jerry W. [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Texas SW Med Ctr Dallas, Dept Cell Biol, 5323 Harry Hines Blvd, Dallas, TX 75390 USA
[2] King Abdulaziz Univ, Ctr Excellence Genom Med Res, Jeddah 21413, Saudi Arabia
[3] IRCAN, CNRS, Fac Med, UMR INSERM U1081 7284, 28 Ave Valombrose, F-06107 Nice 2, France
关键词
PCR AMPLIFICATION; MUTATIONS; IDENTIFICATION; LIBRARIES; BIAS;
D O I
10.1038/srep24067
中图分类号
O [数理科学和化学]; P [天文学、地球科学]; Q [生物科学]; N [自然科学总论];
学科分类号
07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;
摘要
Next Generation Sequencing (NGS) is a powerful tool that depends on loading a precise amount of DNA onto a flowcell. NGS strategies have expanded our ability to investigate genomic phenomena by referencing mutations in cancer and diseases through large-scale genotyping, developing methods to map rare chromatin interactions (4C; 5C and Hi-C) and identifying chromatin features associated with regulatory elements (ChIP-seq, Bis-Seq, ChiA-PET). While many methods are available for DNA library quantification, there is no unambiguous gold standard. Most techniques use PCR to amplify DNA libraries to obtain sufficient quantities for optical density measurement. However, increased PCR cycles can distort the library's heterogeneity and prevent the detection of rare variants. In this analysis, we compared new digital PCR technologies (droplet digital PCR; ddPCR, ddPCR-Tail) with standard methods for the titration of NGS libraries. DdPCR-Tail is comparable to qPCR and fluorometry (QuBit) and allows sensitive quantification by analysis of barcode repartition after sequencing of multiplexed samples. This study provides a direct comparison between quantification methods throughout a complete sequencing experiment and provides the impetus to use ddPCR-based quantification for improvement of NGS quality.
引用
收藏
页数:10
相关论文
共 27 条
[1]   Rapid, low-input, low-bias construction of shotgun fragment libraries by high-density in vitro transposition [J].
Adey, Andrew ;
Morrison, Hilary G. ;
Asan ;
Xun, Xu ;
Kitzman, Jacob O. ;
Turner, Emily H. ;
Stackhouse, Bethany ;
MacKenzie, Alexandra P. ;
Caruccio, Nicholas C. ;
Zhang, Xiuqing ;
Shendure, Jay .
GENOME BIOLOGY, 2010, 11 (12)
[2]   Analyzing and minimizing PCR amplification bias in Illumina sequencing libraries [J].
Aird, Daniel ;
Ross, Michael G. ;
Chen, Wei-Sheng ;
Danielsson, Maxwell ;
Fennell, Timothy ;
Russ, Carsten ;
Jaffe, David B. ;
Nusbaum, Chad ;
Gnirke, Andreas .
GENOME BIOLOGY, 2011, 12 (02)
[3]   Integrated genomic analyses of ovarian carcinoma [J].
Bell, D. ;
Berchuck, A. ;
Birrer, M. ;
Chien, J. ;
Cramer, D. W. ;
Dao, F. ;
Dhir, R. ;
DiSaia, P. ;
Gabra, H. ;
Glenn, P. ;
Godwin, A. K. ;
Gross, J. ;
Hartmann, L. ;
Huang, M. ;
Huntsman, D. G. ;
Iacocca, M. ;
Imielinski, M. ;
Kalloger, S. ;
Karlan, B. Y. ;
Levine, D. A. ;
Mills, G. B. ;
Morrison, C. ;
Mutch, D. ;
Olvera, N. ;
Orsulic, S. ;
Park, K. ;
Petrelli, N. ;
Rabeno, B. ;
Rader, J. S. ;
Sikic, B. I. ;
Smith-McCune, K. ;
Sood, A. K. ;
Bowtell, D. ;
Penny, R. ;
Testa, J. R. ;
Chang, K. ;
Dinh, H. H. ;
Drummond, J. A. ;
Fowler, G. ;
Gunaratne, P. ;
Hawes, A. C. ;
Kovar, C. L. ;
Lewis, L. R. ;
Morgan, M. B. ;
Newsham, I. F. ;
Santibanez, J. ;
Reid, J. G. ;
Trevino, L. R. ;
Wu, Y. -Q. ;
Wang, M. .
NATURE, 2011, 474 (7353) :609-615
[4]   Discovery of Mutations in Saccharomyces cerevisiae by Pooled Linkage Analysis and Whole-Genome Sequencing [J].
Birkeland, Shanda R. ;
Jin, Natsuko ;
Ozdemir, Alev Cagla ;
Lyons, Robert H., Jr. ;
Weisman, Lois S. ;
Wilson, Thomas E. .
GENETICS, 2010, 186 (04) :1127-U132
[5]   Identification of EMS-Induced Mutations in Drosophila melanogaster by Whole-Genome Sequencing [J].
Blumenstiel, Justin P. ;
Noll, Aaron C. ;
Griffiths, Jennifer A. ;
Perera, Anoja G. ;
Walton, Kendra N. ;
Gilliland, William D. ;
Hawley, R. Scott ;
Staehling-Hampton, Karen .
GENETICS, 2009, 182 (01) :25-32
[6]  
Cancer Genome Atlas Research N., 2013, NAT GENET, V45, P1113, DOI DOI 10.1038/NG.2764
[7]   The Sanger FASTQ file format for sequences with quality scores, and the Solexa/Illumina FASTQ variants [J].
Cock, Peter J. A. ;
Fields, Christopher J. ;
Goto, Naohisa ;
Heuer, Michael L. ;
Rice, Peter M. .
NUCLEIC ACIDS RESEARCH, 2010, 38 (06) :1767-1771
[8]   An integrated encyclopedia of DNA elements in the human genome [J].
Dunham, Ian ;
Kundaje, Anshul ;
Aldred, Shelley F. ;
Collins, Patrick J. ;
Davis, CarrieA. ;
Doyle, Francis ;
Epstein, Charles B. ;
Frietze, Seth ;
Harrow, Jennifer ;
Kaul, Rajinder ;
Khatun, Jainab ;
Lajoie, Bryan R. ;
Landt, Stephen G. ;
Lee, Bum-Kyu ;
Pauli, Florencia ;
Rosenbloom, Kate R. ;
Sabo, Peter ;
Safi, Alexias ;
Sanyal, Amartya ;
Shoresh, Noam ;
Simon, Jeremy M. ;
Song, Lingyun ;
Trinklein, Nathan D. ;
Altshuler, Robert C. ;
Birney, Ewan ;
Brown, James B. ;
Cheng, Chao ;
Djebali, Sarah ;
Dong, Xianjun ;
Dunham, Ian ;
Ernst, Jason ;
Furey, Terrence S. ;
Gerstein, Mark ;
Giardine, Belinda ;
Greven, Melissa ;
Hardison, Ross C. ;
Harris, Robert S. ;
Herrero, Javier ;
Hoffman, Michael M. ;
Iyer, Sowmya ;
Kellis, Manolis ;
Khatun, Jainab ;
Kheradpour, Pouya ;
Kundaje, Anshul ;
Lassmann, Timo ;
Li, Qunhua ;
Lin, Xinying ;
Marinov, Georgi K. ;
Merkel, Angelika ;
Mortazavi, Ali .
NATURE, 2012, 489 (7414) :57-74
[9]   International network of cancer genome projects [J].
Hudson, Thomas J. ;
Anderson, Warwick ;
Aretz, Axel ;
Barker, Anna D. ;
Bell, Cindy ;
Bernabe, Rosa R. ;
Bhan, M. K. ;
Calvo, Fabien ;
Eerola, Iiro ;
Gerhard, Daniela S. ;
Guttmacher, Alan ;
Guyer, Mark ;
Hemsley, Fiona M. ;
Jennings, Jennifer L. ;
Kerr, David ;
Klatt, Peter ;
Kolar, Patrik ;
Kusuda, Jun ;
Lane, David P. ;
Laplace, Frank ;
Lu, Youyong ;
Nettekoven, Gerd ;
Ozenberger, Brad ;
Peterson, Jane ;
Rao, T. S. ;
Remacle, Jacques ;
Schafer, Alan J. ;
Shibata, Tatsuhiro ;
Stratton, Michael R. ;
Vockley, Joseph G. ;
Watanabe, Koichi ;
Yang, Huanming ;
Yuen, Matthew M. F. ;
Knoppers, M. ;
Bobrow, Martin ;
Cambon-Thomsen, Anne ;
Dressler, Lynn G. ;
Dyke, Stephanie O. M. ;
Joly, Yann ;
Kato, Kazuto ;
Kennedy, Karen L. ;
Nicolas, Pilar ;
Parker, Michael J. ;
Rial-Sebbag, Emmanuelle ;
Romeo-Casabona, Carlos M. ;
Shaw, Kenna M. ;
Wallace, Susan ;
Wiesner, Georgia L. ;
Zeps, Nikolajs ;
Lichter, Peter .
NATURE, 2010, 464 (7291) :993-998
[10]   Simultaneous digital quantification and fluorescence-based size characterization of massively parallel sequencing libraries [J].
Laurie, Matthew T. ;
Bertout, Jessica A. ;
Taylor, Sean D. ;
Burton, Joshua N. ;
Shendure, Jay A. ;
Bielas, Jason H. .
BIOTECHNIQUES, 2013, 55 (02) :61-67