Gender inequalities in COPD decision-making in primary care

被引:20
作者
Delgado, Ana [1 ]
Saletti-Cuesta, Lorena [2 ]
Andres Lopez-Fernandez, Luis [1 ]
Gil-Garrido, Natalia [3 ]
Luna del Castillo, Juan de Dios [4 ]
机构
[1] Andalusian Sch Publ Hlth, Cuesta Observ, Granada 4, Spain
[2] Natl Sci & Tech Res Council CONICET, Culture & Soc Res & Study Ctr CIECS, Rondeau 467, RA-5000 Cordoba, Argentina
[3] Lavapies Healthcare Ctr, Calle Embajadores 41, Madrid 28012, Spain
[4] Univ Granada, Fac Med, Dept Biostat, Avda Hosp S-N, Granada 18071, Spain
关键词
Sexism; Gender bias; COPD; Primary health care; Physicians; Primary care; OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY-DISEASE; CORONARY-HEART-DISEASE; WOMEN; DIAGNOSIS; PATIENT; SPIROMETRY; MANAGEMENT; PHYSICIANS; SYMPTOMS; BIAS;
D O I
10.1016/j.rmed.2016.03.017
中图分类号
R5 [内科学];
学科分类号
1002 ; 100201 ;
摘要
Background: COPD is a frequent severe illness that increasingly affects females. Gender inequalities have been reported in COPD care. Objective: To analyze decision-making in primary care for men and women with identical COPD as a function of the gender of the family physician (FP). Methods: Cross-sectional, multicenter study in 457 Andalusian FPs, using a self-administered vignette-based questionnaire on COPD featuring a male or female patient, with four variables on clinical reasoning: "tobacco as most important risk factor (RF)", "ordering of spirometry", "COPD as most likely diagnosis", and "referral". Multilevel logistic regression analysis. Results: Response rate was 67.4% (308/457). In analysis of the four FP gender-patient gender dyads, tobacco was more frequently considered as priority RF for the man than for the woman in the vignette by female (95.6% vs. 67.1%) and male (79.8% vs. 62.5%) FPs. COPD was more frequently the most likely diagnosis for the man versus woman by female (84.4% vs. 49.9%) and male (78.5% vs. 57.8%) FPs. Male FPs more frequently ordered spirometry for the man versus woman (68.1% vs. 46.8%). There were no differences in referral between male and female patients. Male FPs were more likely than female FPs to consider tobacco as priority RF for the man (p = 002). Female FPs were more likely than male FPs to refer the man (22.5% vs. 8%). Conclusions: There may be gender inequalities in primary care for COPD in our setting. Diagnostic and therapeutic efforts appear lower in female patients. Male and female FPs only differed in care of the male patient, indicating FP gender-patient gender interaction. (C) 2016 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
引用
收藏
页码:91 / 96
页数:6
相关论文
共 31 条
[1]   The influence of patient and doctor gender on diagnosing coronary heart disease [J].
Adams, Ann ;
Buckingham, Christopher D. ;
Lindenmeyer, Antje ;
McKinlay, John B. ;
Link, Carol ;
Marceau, Lisa ;
Arber, Sara .
SOCIOLOGY OF HEALTH & ILLNESS, 2008, 30 (01) :1-18
[2]   Underdiagnosis of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease in Women: Quantification of the Problem, Determinants and Proposed Actions [J].
Ancochea, Julio ;
Miravitlles, Marc ;
Garcia-Rio, Francisco ;
Munoz, Luis ;
Sanchez, Guadalupe ;
Sobradillo, Victor ;
Duran-Tauleria, Enric ;
Soriano, Joan B. .
ARCHIVOS DE BRONCONEUMOLOGIA, 2013, 49 (06) :223-229
[3]   Patient characteristics and inequalities in doctors' diagnostic and management strategies relating to CHD: A video-simulation experiment [J].
Arber, S ;
McKinlay, J ;
Adams, A ;
Marceau, L ;
Link, C ;
O'Donnell, A .
SOCIAL SCIENCE & MEDICINE, 2006, 62 (01) :103-115
[4]   How often is diagnosis of COPD confirmed with spirometry? [J].
Arne, Mats ;
Lisspers, Karin ;
Stallberg, Bjorn ;
Boman, Gunnar ;
Hedenstrom, Hans ;
Janson, Christer ;
Emtner, Margareta .
RESPIRATORY MEDICINE, 2010, 104 (04) :550-556
[5]   Influence of sex on chronic obstructive pulmonary disease risk and treatment outcomes [J].
Aryal, Shambhu ;
Diaz-Guzman, Enrique ;
Mannino, David M. .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CHRONIC OBSTRUCTIVE PULMONARY DISEASE, 2014, 9 :1145-1154
[6]   COPD and gender differences: an update [J].
Aryal, Shambhu ;
Diaz-Guzman, Enrique ;
Mannino, David M. .
TRANSLATIONAL RESEARCH, 2013, 162 (04) :208-218
[7]   PHYSICIANS ATTITUDES TOWARD FEMALE PATIENTS [J].
BERNSTEIN, B ;
KANE, R .
MEDICAL CARE, 1981, 19 (06) :600-608
[8]  
Cantero Maria Teresa Ruiz, 2007, J EPIDEMIOL COMMUNIT, V61, pii46, DOI DOI 10.1136/JECH.2007.062034
[9]  
Cantero Maria Teresa Ruiz, 2009, SERIE NUEVA SALUD PU, V4
[10]   Gender bias in the diagnosis of COPD [J].
Chapman, KR ;
Tashkin, DP ;
Pye, DJ .
CHEST, 2001, 119 (06) :1691-1695