Does the Skeletal Phenotype of Osteogenesis Imperfecta Differ for Patients With Non-COL1A1/2 Mutations? A Retrospective Study in 113 Patients

Background: Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a heritable disease characterized by bone fragility and other extra skeletal manifestations. Most patients with OI have mutations in the COL1A1 or COL1A2 genes. However, a significant minority of patients with clinical OI have non-COL1A1/2 mutations, which have become easier to detect with the use of genetic panels. Traditional understanding of OI pathogenesis was expanded because of these new mutations, and their phenotypic-genotypic relationship is largely unknown. We hypothesized that patients with non-COL1A1/2 mutations have different skeletal clinical presentations from those with OI caused by COL1A1/2 mutations. Methods: Patients were categorized into 4 groups according to our modified functional classification, namely, quantitative COL1A1/2 haploinsufficiency (group 1), qualitative COL1A1/2 dominant negative mutations (group 2), mutations indirectly affecting type I collagen synthesis, processing and posttranslational modification (group 3) and mutations altering osteoblast differentiation and function (group 4). Both group 3 and 4 were classified as non-COL1A1/2 mutation group. Results: Of 113 OI patients included, 51 had COL1A1/2 quantitative haploinsufficiency mutations (group 1), 39 had COL1A1/2 qualitative dominant negative mutations (group 2), and 23 patients had OI caused by mutations in 1 of 9 other noncollagen genes (groups 3/4). Patients with non-COL1A1/2 mutations (groups 3 and 4) have severe skeletal presentations. Specifically, OI patients with non-COL1A1/2 mutations experienced more perinatal fractures, vertebral compression fractures and had more long bone deformities. Although the occurrence of scoliosis was similar, the cobb angle was larger in the non-COL1A1/2 mutation group. Radial head dislocations, ossification of interosseous membrane, extraskeletal ossification, cervical kyphosis, and champagne glass deformity of the pelvis were more frequent in this group. Conclusions: The clinical phenotype of OI in patients with non-COL1A1/2 is severe and has unique features. This information is useful for clinical diagnosis and prognosis.