Suitability evaluation on laminar airflow and mixing airflow distribution strategies in operating rooms: A case study at St. Olavs Hospital

被引:19
作者
Fan, Minchao [1 ,2 ,5 ]
Cao, Guangyu [2 ]
Pedersen, Christoffer [2 ]
Lu, Shilei [1 ,3 ,5 ]
Stenstad, Liv-Inger [4 ]
Skogas, Jan Gunnar [4 ]
机构
[1] Tianjin Univ, Sch Civil Engn, Tianjin, Peoples R China
[2] Norwegian Univ Sci & Technol, Dept Energy & Proc Engn, Trondheim, Norway
[3] Tianjin Univ, Sch Environm Sci & Engn, Tianjin, Peoples R China
[4] St Olavs Hosp, Operating Room, Trondheim, Norway
[5] Tianjin Univ, Tianjin Key Lab Built Environm & Energy Applicat, Tianjin, Peoples R China
基金
国家重点研发计划;
关键词
Air distribution strategy; Operating room; Suitability; Evaluation; ENVIRONMENTAL-QUALITY; VENTILATION; CONTAMINATION; PREVENTION; SYSTEMS; HVAC;
D O I
10.1016/j.buildenv.2021.107677
中图分类号
TU [建筑科学];
学科分类号
0813 ;
摘要
Operating room (OR) is an indispensable department in a hospital, while its ventilation system is an important engineering solution to ensure safety for surgical procedures. Suitable ventilation system in the OR should be defined as using the minimum energy consumption and lifecycle cost to meet both the requirements of clean air for safe surgeries and comfort for occupants. Therefore, this study aims to develop a flexible evaluation framework on the suitability evaluation for ventilation system performance in ORs from a holistic view instead of one aspect only. To achieve the objective, we adopted analytic hierarchy process (AHP) and fuzzy comprehensive evaluation (FCE) methods and conducted suitability evaluation for two ORs with laminar airflow (LAF) and mixing ventilation (MV) system in St. Olavs Hospital, Norway. The evaluation includes seven indexes under three main aspects: ventilation effectiveness, energy consumption and users? satisfaction. The comprehensive evaluation results are obtained through site measurements during mock surgeries, data collection and calculation as well as the questionnaire survey. Due to the unsatisfactory performance in energy consumption and thermal comfort indexes, the evaluation result of the suitability performance of the case OR with MV system was ?unsuitable? while the one with LAF system was ?suitable?, which reflects the situation that the energy consumption and thermal environment are sacrificed, although a clean and safe operation environment is guaranteed. The evaluation can provide basis for the commissioning of the ventilation system in the ORs of St. Olavs Hospital and provoke thinking of the ventilation system design and operation in the future.
引用
收藏
页数:15
相关论文
共 35 条
[1]   Impact of surgical lights on the velocity distribution and airborne contamination level in an operating room with laminar airflow system [J].
Aganovic, Amar ;
Cao, Guangyu ;
Stenstad, Liv-Inger ;
Skogas, Jan Gunnar .
BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT, 2017, 126 :42-53
[2]   Temperature-controlled airflow ventilation in operating rooms compared with laminar airflow and turbulent mixed airflow [J].
Alsved, M. ;
Civilis, A. ;
Ekolind, P. ;
Tammelin, A. ;
Andersson, A. Erichsen ;
Jakobsson, J. ;
Svensson, T. ;
Ramstorp, M. ;
Sadrizadeh, S. ;
Larsson, P-A. ;
Bohgard, M. ;
Santl-Temkiv, T. ;
Londahl, J. .
JOURNAL OF HOSPITAL INFECTION, 2018, 98 (02) :181-190
[3]  
Amar A, 2019, AIRFLOW DISTRIBUTION
[4]   Comparison between mixed and laminar airflow systems in operating rooms and the influence of human factors: Experiences from a Swedish orthopedic center [J].
Andersson, Annette Erichsen ;
Petzold, Max ;
Bergh, Ingrid ;
Karlsson, Jon ;
Eriksson, Bengt I. ;
Nilsson, Kerstin .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF INFECTION CONTROL, 2014, 42 (06) :665-669
[5]   HVAC and indoor thermal conditions in hospital operating rooms [J].
Balaras, Constantinos A. ;
Dascalaki, Elena ;
Gaglia, Athina .
ENERGY AND BUILDINGS, 2007, 39 (04) :454-470
[6]   Air contamination for predicting wound contamination in clean surgery: A large multicenter study [J].
Birgand, Gabriel ;
Toupet, Gaelle ;
Rukly, Stephane ;
Antoniotti, Gilles ;
Deschamps, Marie-Noelle ;
Lepelletier, Didier ;
Pornet, Carole ;
Stern, Jean Baptiste ;
Vandamme, Yves-Marie ;
van der Mee-Marquet, Nathalie ;
Timsit, Jean-Francois ;
Lucet, Jean-Christophe .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF INFECTION CONTROL, 2015, 43 (05) :516-521
[7]  
Cacciari P, 2004, Ann Ig, V16, P803
[8]   Laminar airflow and mixing ventilation: Which is better for operating room airflow distribution near an orthopedic surgical patient? [J].
Cao, Guangyu ;
Nilssen, Anders M. ;
Cheng, Zhu ;
Stenstad, Liv-Inger ;
Radtke, Andreas ;
Skogas, Jan Gunnar .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF INFECTION CONTROL, 2019, 47 (07) :737-743
[9]   Do surgeons and surgical facilities disturb the clean air distribution close to a surgical patient in an orthopedic operating room with laminar airflow? [J].
Cao, Guangyu ;
Storas, Madeleine C. A. ;
Aganovic, Amar ;
Stenstad, Liv-Lnger ;
Skogas, Jan Gunnar .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF INFECTION CONTROL, 2018, 46 (10) :1115-1122
[10]   Performance of ventilation system in a non-standard operating room [J].
Chow, TT ;
Yang, XY .
BUILDING AND ENVIRONMENT, 2003, 38 (12) :1401-1411