Safe from what? Understanding environmental non-migration in Chilean Patagonia through ontological security and risk perceptions

被引:35
作者
Wiegel, Hanne [1 ,2 ]
Warner, Jeroen [2 ]
Boas, Ingrid [1 ]
Lamers, Machiel [1 ]
机构
[1] Wageningen Univ, Environm Policy Grp, Hollandseweg 1, NL-6706 KN Wageningen, Netherlands
[2] Wageningen Univ, Sociol Dev & Change Grp, Wageningen, Netherlands
关键词
Environmental change; Non-migration; Ontological security; Risk perception; Chile; CLIMATE-CHANGE; ADAPTATION; RESILIENCE; DISPLACEMENT; IMMOBILITY; MOBILITY; CATEGORY; STRESS; LIFE;
D O I
10.1007/s10113-021-01765-3
中图分类号
X [环境科学、安全科学];
学科分类号
08 ; 0830 ;
摘要
Why do communities prefer to stay in place despite potentially dangerous changes in their environment, even when governmental support for outmigration or resettlement is provided? That is the key question this paper seeks to answer. Voluntary immobility is a burgeoning research topic in environmental change-related migration studies, although the role of local sense-making of perceived risks and migration pressures has received only little attention. In order to examine decisions for non-migration, we argue that we need to consider people's ontological security, or subjective sense of existential safety, which shapes risk perceptions. We apply this to the case of Villa Santa Lucia in Chilean Patagonia, where the local population has rejected relocation policies after the village was severely damaged by a mudslide in December 2017. We show how this rejection is not based on the lack of abilities to move, but on a fundamentally different risk assessment grounded in locally specific social representations of nature and human-nature relations. This alternative understanding of environmental risks allows the local population to uphold their sense of ontological security while remaining in Villa Santa Lucia, and renders relocation to avoid exposure to natural hazards futile or even inconsistent with local identities. We conclude that local sense-making of environmental risks is an important component of a more fine-grained understanding of environmental non-migration decisions.
引用
收藏
页数:13
相关论文
共 54 条
[41]   The Subjective Climate Migrant: Climate Perceptions, Their Determinants, and Relationship to Migration in Cambodia [J].
Parsons, Laurie ;
Nielsen, Jonas Ostergaard .
ANNALS OF THE AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF GEOGRAPHERS, 2021, 111 (04) :971-988
[42]   Mobilising hydrosocial power: Climate perception, migration and the small scale geography of water in Cambodia [J].
Parsons, Laurie ;
Chann, Sopheak .
POLITICAL GEOGRAPHY, 2019, 75
[44]  
Torrent JCR, 2017, REV SAN GREGORIO, P20
[45]   Migration in a changing climate. Towards a translocal social resilience approach [J].
Sakdapolrak, Patrick ;
Naruchaikusol, Sopon ;
Ober, Kayly ;
Peth, Simon ;
Porst, Luise ;
Rockenbauch, Till ;
Tolo, Vera .
ERDE, 2016, 147 (02) :81-94
[46]   Explaining the uncertainty: understanding small-scale farmers' cultural beliefs and reasoning of drought causes in Gaza Province, Southern Mozambique [J].
Salite, Daniela .
AGRICULTURE AND HUMAN VALUES, 2019, 36 (03) :427-441
[48]   Securitization of climate change: How invoking global dangers for instrumental ends can backfire [J].
Warner, Jeroen ;
Boas, Ingrid .
ENVIRONMENT AND PLANNING C-POLITICS AND SPACE, 2019, 37 (08) :1471-1488
[49]   How does nature contribute to human mobility? A conceptual framework and qualitative analysis [J].
Wiederkehr, Charlotte ;
Schroter, Matthias ;
Adams, Helen ;
Seppelt, Ralf ;
Hermans, Kathleen .
ECOLOGY AND SOCIETY, 2019, 24 (04)
[50]   A mobilities perspective on migration in the context of environmental change [J].
Wiegel, Hanne ;
Boas, Ingrid ;
Warner, Jeroen .
WILEY INTERDISCIPLINARY REVIEWS-CLIMATE CHANGE, 2019, 10 (06)