In the debate over how to respond to crime and criminal justice problems, positions have often been framed along a political versus ethical or principled continuum. In this article, the author argues that this framework does not adequately capture the complexity of the current debate. The author suggests several reasons why this is so, and how the political, public, and public service environments have changed in unique ways. Selected key current issues. are reviewed against those environmental factors, and steps leading out of this discouraging state are suggested.