Mobile health strategies for blood pressure self-management in urban populations with digital barriers: systematic review and meta-analyses

被引:39
作者
Khoong, Elaine C. [1 ,2 ]
Olazo, Kristan [1 ,2 ]
Rivadeneira, Natalie A. [1 ,2 ]
Thatipelli, Sneha [3 ]
Barr-Walker, Jill [4 ]
Fontil, Valy [1 ,2 ]
Lyles, Courtney R. [1 ,2 ]
Sarkar, Urmimala [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Calif San Francisco, Dept Med, Div Gen Internal Med, Zuckerberg San Francisco Gen Hosp, San Francisco, CA 94143 USA
[2] Zuckerberg San Francisco Gen Hosp, UCSF Ctr Vulnerable Populat, San Francisco, CA 94110 USA
[3] Northwestern Univ, Dept Med, Evanston, IL USA
[4] Univ Calif San Francisco, Zuckerberg San Francisco Gen Hosp Lib, San Francisco, CA 94143 USA
关键词
HOME TELEHEALTH; UNITED-STATES; HYPERTENSION; CARE; DISEASE; INTERVENTION; DISPARITIES; ADHERENCE; OUTCOMES; DIVERSE;
D O I
10.1038/s41746-021-00486-5
中图分类号
R19 [保健组织与事业(卫生事业管理)];
学科分类号
摘要
Mobile health (mHealth) technologies improve hypertension outcomes, but it is unknown if this benefit applies to all populations. This review aimed to describe the impact of mHealth interventions on blood pressure outcomes in populations with disparities in digital health use. We conducted a systematic search to identify studies with systolic blood pressure (SBP) outcomes located in urban settings in high-income countries that included a digital health disparity population, defined as mean age >= 65 years; lower educational attainment (>= 60% <= high school education); and/or racial/ethnic minority (<50% non-Hispanic White for US studies). Interventions were categorized using an established self-management taxonomy. We conducted a narrative synthesis; among randomized clinical trials (RCTs) with a six-month SBP outcome, we conducted random-effects meta-analyses. Twenty-nine articles (representing 25 studies) were included, of which 15 were RCTs. Fifteen studies used text messaging; twelve used mobile applications. Studies were included based on race/ethnicity (14), education (10), and/or age (6). Common intervention components were: lifestyle advice (20); provision of self-monitoring equipment (17); and training on digital device use (15). In the meta-analyses of seven RCTs, SBP reduction at 6-months in the intervention group (mean SBP difference = -4.10, 95% CI: [-6.38, -1.83]) was significant, but there was no significant difference in SBP change between the intervention and control groups (p = 0.48). The use of mHealth tools has shown promise for chronic disease management but few studies have included older, limited educational attainment, or minority populations. Additional robust studies with these populations are needed to determine what interventions work best for diverse hypertensive patients.
引用
收藏
页数:12
相关论文
共 80 条
[71]   Self-monitoring of blood pressure in hypertension: A systematic review and individual patient data meta-analysis [J].
Tucker, Katherine L. ;
Sheppard, James P. ;
Stevens, Richard ;
Bosworth, Hayden B. ;
Bove, Alfred ;
Bray, Emma P. ;
Earley, Kenneth ;
George, Johnson ;
Godwin, Marshall ;
Greee, Beverly B. ;
Hebert, Paul ;
Hobbs, F. D. Richard ;
Kantola, Ilkka ;
Kerry, Sally M. ;
Leiva, Alfonso ;
Magid, David J. ;
Mant, Jonathan ;
Margolis, Karen L. ;
McKinstry, Brian ;
McLaughlin, Mary Ann ;
Omboni, Stefano ;
Ogedegbe, Olugbenga ;
Parati, Gianfranco ;
Qamar, Nashat ;
Tabaei, Bahman P. ;
Varis, Juha ;
Verberk, Willem J. ;
Wakefield, Bonnie J. ;
McManus, Richard J. .
PLOS MEDICINE, 2017, 14 (09)
[72]  
Valderrama AL, 2013, MMWR-MORBID MORTAL W, V62, P351
[73]   Mobile phone text messaging improves antihypertensive drug adherence in the community [J].
Varleta, Paola ;
Acevedo, Monica ;
Akel, Carlos ;
Salinas, Claudia ;
Navarrete, Carlos ;
Garcia, Ana ;
Echegoyen, Carolina ;
Rodriguez, Daniel ;
Gramusset, Lissette ;
Leon, Sandra ;
Cofre, Pedro ;
Retamal, Raquel ;
Romero, Katerine .
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL HYPERTENSION, 2017, 19 (12) :1276-1284
[74]   Outcomes of a Home Telehealth Intervention for Patients with Diabetes and Hypertension [J].
Wakefield, Bonnie J. ;
Holman, John E. ;
Ray, Annette ;
Scherubel, Melody ;
Adams, Margaret R. ;
Hills, Stephen L. ;
Rosenthal, Gary E. .
TELEMEDICINE AND E-HEALTH, 2012, 18 (08) :575-579
[75]   Effectiveness of Home Telehealth in Comorbid Diabetes and Hypertension: A Randomized, Controlled Trial [J].
Wakefield, Bonnie J. ;
Holman, John E. ;
Ray, Annette ;
Scherubel, Melody ;
Adams, Margaret R. ;
Hillis, Stephen L. ;
Rosenthal, Gary E. .
TELEMEDICINE AND E-HEALTH, 2011, 17 (04) :254-261
[76]   Relation of socioeconomic status to hypertension occurrence [J].
Wang, Zhida ;
Yue, Xiaofei ;
Wang, Huili ;
Bao, Cuiping ;
Xu, Weili ;
Chen, Liming ;
Qi, Xiuying .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CARDIOLOGY, 2014, 173 (03) :544-545
[77]   SMARTWOMAN™: Feasibility assessment of a smartphone app to control cardiovascular risk factors in vulnerable diabetic women [J].
Wenger, Nanette K. ;
Williams, Olubunmi O. ;
Parashar, Susmita .
CLINICAL CARDIOLOGY, 2019, 42 (02) :217-221
[78]  
WHO Global Observatory for eHealth World Health Organization, 2011, MHEALTH NEW HORIZONS
[79]   Digital Health Interventions for the Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis [J].
Widmer, R. Jay ;
Collins, Nerissa M. ;
Collins, C. Scott ;
West, Colin P. ;
Lerman, Lilach O. ;
Lerman, Amir .
MAYO CLINIC PROCEEDINGS, 2015, 90 (04) :469-480
[80]   Utilizing a Mobile Health Intervention to Manage Hypertension in an Underserved Community [J].
Zha, Peijia ;
Qureshi, Rubab ;
Porter, Sallie ;
Chao, Ying-Yu ;
Pacquiao, Dula ;
Chase, Sabrina ;
O'Brien-Richardson, Patricia .
WESTERN JOURNAL OF NURSING RESEARCH, 2020, 42 (03) :201-209