Adenoma detection by Endocuff-assisted versus standard colonoscopy in an organized screening program: the "ItaVision" randomized controlled trial

被引:26
作者
Zorzi, Manuel [1 ]
Hassan, Cesare [2 ]
Battagello, Jessica [1 ]
Antonelli, Giulio [2 ,3 ,4 ]
Pantalena, Maurizio [5 ]
Bulighin, Gianmarco [6 ]
Alicante, Saverio [7 ]
Meggiato, Tamara [8 ]
Rosa-Rizzotto, Erik [9 ]
Iacopini, Federico [4 ]
Luigiano, Carmelo [10 ]
Monica, Fabio [11 ]
Arrigoni, Arrigo [12 ]
Germana, Bastianello [13 ]
Valiante, Flavio [14 ]
Mallardi, Beatrice [15 ]
Senore, Carlo [16 ]
Grazzini, Grazia [15 ]
Mantellini, Paola [15 ]
机构
[1] Azienda Zero, Veneto Tumor Registry, Via Jacopo Avanzo 35, I-35132 Padua, Italy
[2] Nuovo Regina Margherita Hosp, Gastroenterol Unit, Rome, Italy
[3] Sapienza Univ Rome, Dept Translat & Precis Med, Rome, Italy
[4] ASL Roma 6, Osped Castelli NOC, Gastroenterol & Digest Endoscopy Unit, Rome, Italy
[5] ULSS 8 Berica, Cazzavillan Hosp, Gastroenterol Unit, Arzignano, Italy
[6] ULSS 9 Scaligera, Fracastoro Hosp, Gastroenterol & Digest Endoscopy Unit, San Bonifacio, Italy
[7] Maggiore Hosp, ASST Crema, Gastroenterol Dept, Crema, Italy
[8] ULSS 5 Polesana, Rovigo Gen Hosp, Dept Gastroenterol, Rovigo, Italy
[9] Azienda Osped Univ, St Anthony Hosp, Gastroenterol Unit, Padua, Italy
[10] ASST St Paolo & Carlo, Unit Digest Endoscopy, Milan, Italy
[11] Cattinara Univ Hosp, Gastroenterol & Digest Endoscopy Unit, Trieste, Italy
[12] Univ Hosp Citta Salute & Sci, Gastroenterol Unit, Turin, Italy
[13] ULSS 1 Dolomiti, San Martino Hosp, Gastroenterol & Digest Endoscopy Unit, Belluno, Italy
[14] ULSS 1 Dolomiti, Santa Maria del Prato Hosp, Gastroenterol & Digest Endoscopy Unit, Feltre, Italy
[15] Inst Canc Res Prevent & Oncol Network ISPRO, Screening Unit, Florence, Italy
[16] Univ Hosp Citta Salute & Sci, Epidemiol & Screening Unit CPO, Turin, Italy
关键词
OCCULT BLOOD-TEST; COLORECTAL-CANCER; QUALITY INDICATORS; EUROPEAN GUIDELINES; PERFORMANCE; SURVEILLANCE; ASSURANCE; NEOPLASIA; RISK;
D O I
10.1055/a-1379-6868
中图分类号
R57 [消化系及腹部疾病];
学科分类号
摘要
Background The Endocuff Vision device (Arc Medical Design Ltd., Leeds, UK) has been shown to increase mucosal exposure, and consequently adenoma detection rate (ADR), during colonoscopy. This nationwide multicenter study assessed possible benefits and harms of using Endocuff Vision in a fecal immunochemical test (FIT)-based screening program. Methods Patients undergoing colonoscopy after a FIT-positive test were randomized 1:1 to undergo Endocuff-assisted colonoscopy or standard colonoscopy, stratified by sex, age, and screening history. Primary outcome was ADR. Secondary outcomes were ADR stratified by endoscopists' ADR, advanced ADR (AADR), adenomas per colonoscopy (APC), withdrawal time, and adverse events. Results 1866 patients were enrolled across 13 centers. After exclusions, 1813 (mean age 60.1 years; male 53.8%) were randomized (908 Endocuff Vision, 905 standard colonoscopy). ADR was significantly higher in the Endocuff Vision arm (47.8% vs. 40.8%; relative risk [RR] 1.17, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.06-1.30), with no differences between arms regarding size or morphology. When stratifying for endoscopists' ADR, only low detectors (ADR<33.3%) showed a statistically significant ADR increase (Endocuff Vision 41.1% [95%CI 35.7-46.7] vs. standard colonoscopy 26.0% [95%CI 21.3-31.4]). AADR (24.8% vs. 20.5%, RR 1.21, 95%CI 1.02-1.43) and APC (0.94 vs. 0.77; P =0.001) were higher in the Endocuff Vision arm. Withdrawal time and adverse events were similar between arms. Conclusion Endocuff Vision increased ADR in a FIT-based screening program by improvingexamination of the whole colonic mucosa. Utility was highest among endoscopists with a low ADR.
引用
收藏
页码:138 / 147
页数:10
相关论文
共 37 条
[1]   European guidelines for quality assurance in colorectal cancer screening and diagnosis. First Edition Colonoscopic surveillance following adenoma removal [J].
Atkin, W. S. ;
Valori, R. ;
Kuipers, E. J. ;
Hoff, G. ;
Senore, C. ;
Segnan, N. ;
Jover, R. ;
Schmiegel, W. ;
Lambert, R. ;
Pox, C. .
ENDOSCOPY, 2012, 44 :SE151-SE163
[2]   Faecal immunochemical tests versus colonoscopy for post-polypectomy surveillance: an accuracy, acceptability and economic study [J].
Atkin, Wendy ;
Cross, Amanda J. ;
Kralj-Hans, Ines ;
MacRae, Eilidh ;
Piggott, Carolyn ;
Pearson, Sheena ;
Wooldrage, Kate ;
Brown, Jeremy ;
Lucas, Fiona ;
Prendergast, Aaron ;
Marcheysky, Natalil ;
Patel, Bhavita ;
Pack, Kevin ;
Howe, Rosemary ;
Skrobanski, Hanna ;
Kerrison, Robert ;
Swart, Nicholas ;
Snowball, Julia ;
Duffy, Stephen W. ;
Morris, Stephen ;
von Wagner, Christian ;
Halloran, Stephen .
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT, 2019, 23 (01) :XXVII-+
[3]   Endocuff-assisted vs. standard colonoscopy in the fecal occult blood test-based UK Bowel Cancer Screening Programme (E-cap study): a randomized trial [J].
Bhattacharyya, Rupam ;
Chedgy, Fergus ;
Kandiah, Kesavan ;
Fogg, Carole ;
Higgins, Bernard ;
Haysom-Newport, Ben ;
Gadeke, Lisa ;
Thursby-Pelham, Fergus ;
Ellis, Richard ;
Goggin, Patrick ;
Longcroft-Wheaton, Gaius ;
Bhandari, Pradeep .
ENDOSCOPY, 2017, 49 (11) :1043-1050
[4]  
Corley DA, 2014, NEW ENGL J MED, V370, P2541, DOI [10.1056/NEJMoa1309086, 10.1056/NEJMc1405329]
[5]   A lexicon for endoscopic adverse events: report of an ASGE workshop [J].
Cotton, Peter B. ;
Eisen, Glenn M. ;
Aabakken, Lars ;
Baron, Todd H. ;
Hutter, Matt M. ;
Jacobson, Brian C. ;
Mergener, Klaus ;
Nemcek, Albert, Jr. ;
Petersen, Bret T. ;
Petrini, John L. ;
Pike, Irving M. ;
Rabeneck, Linda ;
Romagnuolo, Joseph ;
Vargo, John J. .
GASTROINTESTINAL ENDOSCOPY, 2010, 71 (03) :446-454
[6]   Correlation between adenoma detection rate in colonoscopy- and fecal immunochemical testing-based colorectal cancer screening programs [J].
Cubiella, Joaquin ;
Castells, Antoni ;
Andreu, Montserrat ;
Bujanda, Luis ;
Carballo, Fernando ;
Jover, Rodrigo ;
Lanas, Angel ;
Diego Morillas, Juan ;
Salas, Dolores ;
Quintero, Enrique .
UNITED EUROPEAN GASTROENTEROLOGY JOURNAL, 2017, 5 (02) :255-260
[7]   Compared Abilities of Endoscopic Techniques to Increase Colon Adenoma Detection Rates: A Network Meta-analysis [J].
Facciorusso, Antonio ;
Triantafyllou, Konstantinos ;
Murad, Mohammad Hassan ;
Prokop, Larry J. ;
Tziatzios, Georgios ;
Muscatiello, Nicola ;
Singh, Siddharth .
CLINICAL GASTROENTEROLOGY AND HEPATOLOGY, 2019, 17 (12) :2439-+
[8]   Screening for Colorectal Cancer With Fecal Immunochemical Testing With and Without Postpolypectomy Surveillance Colonoscopy A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis [J].
Greuter, Marjolein J. E. ;
de Klerk, Clasine M. ;
Meijer, Gerrit A. ;
Dekker, Evelien ;
Coupe, Veerle M. H. .
ANNALS OF INTERNAL MEDICINE, 2017, 167 (08) :544-+
[9]   Performance of artificial intelligence in colonoscopy for adenoma and polyp detection: a systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Hassan, Cesare ;
Spadaccini, Marco ;
Iannone, Andrea ;
Maselli, Roberta ;
Jovani, Manol ;
Chandrasekar, Viveksandeep Thoguluva ;
Antonelli, Giulio ;
Yu, Honggang ;
Areia, Miguel ;
Dinis-Ribeiro, Mario ;
Bhandari, Pradeep ;
Sharma, Prateek ;
Rex, Douglas K. ;
Roesch, Thomas ;
Wallace, Michael ;
Repici, Alessandro .
GASTROINTESTINAL ENDOSCOPY, 2021, 93 (01) :77-+
[10]   Longitudinal assessment of colonoscopy quality indicators: a report from the Gastroenterology Practice Management Group [J].
Hernandez, Lyndon V. ;
Deas, Thomas M. ;
Catalano, Marc F. ;
Guda, Nalini M. ;
Huang, Lin ;
Ketover, Scott R. ;
Etzkorn, Kyle P. ;
Gutta, Kumar G. ;
Morris, Steve J. ;
Schmalz, Michael J. ;
Klyve, Dominic ;
Allen, John I. .
GASTROINTESTINAL ENDOSCOPY, 2014, 80 (05) :835-841