Comments on Castro et al. (2021) "Relative sea-level curve during the Holocene in Rio de Janeiro, Southeastern Brazil: A review of the indicators-RSL, altimetric and geochronological data"

被引：2
作者：
Angulo, Rodolfo J. [1 ]
Giannini, Paulo C. F. [2 ]
De Souza, Maria Cristina [1 ]
Lessa, Guilherme C. [3 ]
机构：
[1] UFPR, Ctr Politecn, Dept Geol, Lab Estudos Costeiros Lecost, Ave Cel Francisco H dos Santos,210,Jardim Amer, BR-81531970 Curitiba, PR, Brazil
[2] Univ Sao Paulo, Inst Geociencias, Rua Lago,562,Cidade Univ, BR-05508080 Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil
[3] Univ Fed Bahia, Grp Oceanog Trop GOAT, LFNA, Travessa Barao de Jeremoabo,s-n,Campus Univ Ondina, BR-40170280 Salvador, BA, Brazil
来源：
JOURNAL OF SOUTH AMERICAN EARTH SCIENCES | 2022年 / 116卷
关键词：
Paleo-sea levels; Paleo-sea level indicator; Homologous indicator; Method to determine paleo-sea level; COAST; FLUCTUATIONS;
D O I：
10.1016/j.jsames.2022.103791
中图分类号：
P [天文学、地球科学];
学科分类号：
07 ;
摘要：
This work presents a few comments on the paper "Relative sea-level curve during the Holocene in Rio de Janeiro, Southeastern Brazil: A review of the indicators - RSL, altimetric and geochronological data". Surprisingly the authors omitted in this review a former discussion on the interpretation of paleo-sea level indicator and paleo-sea level reconstructions on the Rio de Janeiro coast that questions their results. Therefore, at this present work we resume the previous discussion. We conclude that although at the commented paper the altitudes of the paleo-sea level indicators were determined precisely, they did not consider the vertical distance between a given a paleosea level indicator and its current homologous one, and thus do not indicate paleo-sea levels.
引用
收藏
页数：2
相关论文
共 11 条
[1]   A critical review of mid- to late-Holocene sea-level fluctuations on the eastern Brazilian coastline [J].
Angulo, RJ ;
Lessa, GC ;
de Souza, MC .
QUATERNARY SCIENCE REVIEWS, 2006, 25 (5-6) :486-506
[2]   Reply to Castro et al. 2018 on "Holocene paleo-sea level changes along the coast of Rio de Janeiro, southern Brazil" [J].
Angulo, Rodolfo J. ;
Giannini, Paulo C. F. ;
De Souza, Maria Cristina ;
Lessa, Guilherme C. .
ANAIS DA ACADEMIA BRASILEIRA DE CIENCIAS, 2018, 90 (02) :1377-1380
[3]   Holocene paleo-sea level changes along the coast of Rio de Janeiro, southern Brazil: Comment on Castro et al. (2014) [J].
Angulo, Rodolfo J. ;
Giannini, Paulo C. F. ;
De Souza, Maria Cristina ;
Lessa, Guilherme C. .
ANAIS DA ACADEMIA BRASILEIRA DE CIENCIAS, 2016, 88 (04) :2105-2111
[4]  
[Anonymous], 1870, Geology and Physical Geography of Brazil
[5]  
Branner J.C., 1904, B MUS COMP ZOOL HARV, V7
[6]  
Branner JC, 1902, BULL GEOL SOC AM, V13, P41
[7]   Comments to Angulo et al. 2016 on "Sea-level fluctuations and coastal evolution in the state of Rio de Janeiro, southeastern - Brazil" by Castro et al. 2014 [J].
Castro, Joao Wagner A. ;
Seoane, Jose C. S. ;
Da Cunha, Aline M. ;
Malta, Julia V. ;
De Oliveira, Camila A. ;
Vaz, Stella R. ;
Suguio, Kenitiro .
ANAIS DA ACADEMIA BRASILEIRA DE CIENCIAS, 2018, 90 (02) :1369-1375
[8]   Sea-level fluctuations and coastal evolution in the state of Rio de Janeiro, southeastern Brazil [J].
Castro, Joao Wagner A. ;
Suguio, Kenitiro ;
Seoane, Jose C. S. ;
da Cunha, Aline M. ;
Dias, Fabio F. .
ANAIS DA ACADEMIA BRASILEIRA DE CIENCIAS, 2014, 86 (02) :671-683
[9]   Relative sea-level curve during the Holocene in Rio de Janeiro, Southeastern Brazil: A review of the indicators- RSL, altimetric and geochronological data [J].
Castro, Joao Wagner Alencar ;
Seoane, Jose Carlos Sicoli ;
Fernandes, Daniel ;
Cabral, Caique Lima ;
da Cunha, Aline Meneguci ;
Malta, Julia Varella ;
Miguel, Lucas Lavo J. A. ;
de Oliveira, Camila Areia ;
de Oliveira, Paula Spotorno ;
Tamega, Frederico Tapajos de Souza .
JOURNAL OF SOUTH AMERICAN EARTH SCIENCES, 2021, 112
[10]   Modelling Holocene relative sea-level observations from the Caribbean and South America [J].
Milne, GA ;
Long, AJ ;
Bassett, SE .
QUATERNARY SCIENCE REVIEWS, 2005, 24 (10-11) :1183-1202
12