Evaluating the Role of Water Availability in Determining the Yield-Plant Population Density Relationship

Thirty-eight yield-plant population density (Y-PPD) data sets were collected from the literature and analyzed statistically to yield, inter alia, a single "universal" relationship that realistically describes the Y-PPD data obtained with various plants under various agricultural and environmental conditions. This study aimed to evaluate the dependence of water availability to plant root systems on plant population density, plant arrangement geometry, active-root-system size, and soil texture. The outlined evaluation of the relative water uptake rate-plant population density (RWUR-PPD) relationship can quantify the roles of water availability and competition among neighboring root systems in determining the Y-PPD relationship. In particular, this methodology quantifies the effects of root system size, soil capillary length, and planting rectangularity on the Y-PPD relationship. Overall, the proposed RWUR evaluation shows, in reasonable qualitative agreement with experimental findings, that the Y-PPD relationship increases with increasing root system radius and soil capillary length and with decreasing rectangularity. The RWUR evaluation shows that interplant competition for water increases approximately linearly with the product of (root-system radius) x (soil capillary length). The water-competition factor is approximately 4 pi r(0)(1)alpha(-1), i.e., the surface area of a sphere with a radius equal to the geometric mean of the radius of the root system (r(0)) and the soil capillary length (alpha(-1)). Plant roots and shoots compete also for resources other than water, e.g., soil nutrients, O-2, and solar radiation. Thus, the agronomically important Y-PPD relationship depends on genetic, agricultural, and environmental factors that affect the availability of other resources differently from their effects on water availability; and these differences render it virtually impossible to define and quantify the roles of the various essential resources and the effects of diverse factors in determining the Y-PPD relationship. This is why practical agronomists use empirical mathematical expressions to describe Y-PPD.