Detection of Mutations in Mycobacterium tuberculosis pncA Gene by Modified High-Resolution Melting Curve Analysis of PCR Products

We developed a protocol for detection of mutations in the pncA gene associated with M. tuberculosis resistance to pyrazinamide by analyzing melting curves of 7 overlapping amplicons with artificial heteroduplex formation (H-HRM) formed by co-amplification of wild-type DNA and test DNA and compared its efficiency and robustness with those of classical HRM analysis. Using HRM and H-HRM, we analyzed 35 PZA (R) DNA isolates carrying mutations in the pncA gene, 3 PZA (R) isolates without mutations in the pncA gene, and 20 PZA(s) isolates without mutations in the pncA gene were analyzed. The sensitivity and specificity of HRM for detection of mutations in the pncA gene were moderate: 88.57% (CI 73.26%-96.80%) and 82.61% (CI 61.22%-95.05%), respectively. The sensitivity of the H-HRM test was 97.14% (CI 85.08%-99.93%) and specificity was 95.65% (CI 78.05%-99.89%), with a significant improvement in accuracy - 96.55% vs. 93.85% for HRM. In general, despite addition stage of equalizing the concentrations of the test and control mycobacterial DNA, H-HRM showed greater stability and reproducibility at standard settings of the melting curve analysis software.