Blurred Boundaries - A Qualitative Study of How Acts of Self-Harm and Attempted Suicide Are Defined by Mental Health Practitioners

被引:10
作者
James, Karen [1 ,2 ]
Stewart, Duncan
机构
[1] Kingston Univ, Grosvenor Wing,Cranmer Terrace, London SW17 ORE, England
[2] St Georges Univ London, Joint Fac Hlth Social Care & Educ, Grosvenor Wing,Cranmer Terrace, London SW17 ORE, England
关键词
self-harm; nonsuicidal self-injury; suicide; mental health; risk assessment; ACUTE PSYCHIATRIC-WARDS; 5-YEAR FOLLOW-UP; TOWER-OF-BABEL; INJURIOUS-BEHAVIOR; NOMENCLATURE; CARE;
D O I
10.1027/0227-5910/a000491
中图分类号
R749 [精神病学];
学科分类号
100205 ;
摘要
Background: There is no commonly accepted definition of the term self-harm, and there is an ongoing debate about whether or not it should include acts of attempted suicide. The use of this language in clinical practice has not previously been explored. Aims: To investigate if, and how, practitioners distinguish between acts of self-harm and attempted suicide, and present any implications for practice. Method: We conducted semistructured interviews with a random sample of 18 frontline practitioners from 10 mental health wards and completed a thematic analysis of interview data. Results: Most participants described self-harm and attempted suicide as distinct behaviors. Characteristics of the act, disclosures of intent, and the level of distress observed were commonly used to differentiate between self-harm and attempted suicide. Very few participants believed that people who self-harm may also feel suicidal. Practitioners confidently described two different behaviors, yet self-harm and attempted suicide were often conflated, revealing the challenges and complexities associated with the separation of these acts in clinical practice. Limitations: Clinicians working in other settings or disciplines may have different views. Participants' accounts may not be an accurate representation of what happens in practice. Conclusion: This study adds to a body of evidence which argues against the dichotomous separation of these behaviors into acts of suicidal and nonsuicidal self-harm. Our findings suggest there is no common understanding of the boundaries between self-harm and attempted suicide among frontline clinicians. The language currently used, and consequent practice, particularly with regard to risk assessment, is problematic. Efforts should be made to operationalize terms around suicidal behavior and to incorporate these into training for clinical staff.
引用
收藏
页码:247 / 254
页数:8
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   Physical, mental, and social wellbeing and their association with death by suicide and self-harm in older adults: a community-based cohort study [J].
Erlangsen, Annette ;
Banks, Emily ;
Joshy, Grace ;
Calear, Alison L. ;
Welsh, Jennifer ;
Batterham, Philip J. ;
Conwell, Yeates ;
Salvador-Carulla, Luis .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF GERIATRIC PSYCHIATRY, 2021, 36 (05) :647-656
[42]   How do adolescents talk about self-harm: a qualitative study of disclosure in an ethnically diverse urban population in England [J].
Emily Klineberg ;
Moira J Kelly ;
Stephen A Stansfeld ;
Kamaldeep S Bhui .
BMC Public Health, 13
[43]   "When You're in the Hospital, You're in a Sort of Bubble." Understanding the High Risk of Self-Harm and Suicide Following Psychiatric Discharge: A Qualitative Study [J].
Owen-Smith, Amanda ;
Bennewith, Olive ;
Donovan, Jenny ;
Evans, Jonathan ;
Hawton, Keith ;
Kapur, Nav ;
O'Connor, Susan ;
Gunnell, David .
CRISIS-THE JOURNAL OF CRISIS INTERVENTION AND SUICIDE PREVENTION, 2014, 35 (03) :154-160
[44]   Risk of Suicide and Self-harm in Kids: The Development of an Algorithm to Identify High-Risk Individuals Within the Children's Mental Health System [J].
Stewart, Shannon L. ;
Celebre, Angela ;
Hirdes, John P. ;
Poss, Jeffrey W. .
CHILD PSYCHIATRY & HUMAN DEVELOPMENT, 2020, 51 (06) :913-924
[45]   Risk of Suicide and Self-harm in Kids: The Development of an Algorithm to Identify High-Risk Individuals Within the Children’s Mental Health System [J].
Shannon L. Stewart ;
Angela Celebre ;
John P. Hirdes ;
Jeffrey W. Poss .
Child Psychiatry & Human Development, 2020, 51 :913-924
[46]   'A Safe Place Where I Am Welcome to Unwind When I Choose to'-Experiences of Brief Admission by Self-Referral for Adolescents Who Self-Harm at Risk for Suicide: A Qualitative Study [J].
Lindkvist, Rose-Marie ;
Westling, Sofie ;
Eberhard, Sophia ;
Johansson, Bjorn Axel ;
Rask, Olof ;
Landgren, Kajsa .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH, 2022, 19 (01)
[47]   Prevalence of suicide attempt and associations with deliberate self-harm, mental health problems, drug misuse and traumatic experiences - a cross sectional survey of the Norwegian population [J].
TK Grimholt ;
T. Bonsaksen ;
T. Heir ;
I. Schou Bredal ;
L. Skogstad ;
Ø Ekeberg .
BMC Psychiatry, 24
[48]   Prevalence of suicide attempt and associations with deliberate self-harm, mental health problems, drug misuse and traumatic experiences - a cross sectional survey of the Norwegian population [J].
Grimholt, T. K. ;
Bonsaksen, T. ;
Heir, T. ;
Bredal, I. Schou ;
Skogstad, L. ;
Ekeberg, O. .
BMC PSYCHIATRY, 2024, 24 (01)
[49]   Quantitative Evidence for Relational Care Approaches to Assessing and Managing Self-Harm and Suicide Risk in Inpatient Mental Health and Emergency Department Settings: A Scoping Review [J].
Griffiths, Jessica L. ;
Foye, Una ;
Stuart, Ruth ;
Jarvis, Ruby ;
Chipp, Beverley ;
Griffiths, Raza ;
Jeynes, Tamar ;
Mitchell, Lizzie ;
Parker, Jennie ;
Rowan Olive, Rachel ;
Quirke, Kieran ;
Baker, John ;
Brennan, Geoff ;
Lamph, Gary ;
Mckeown, Mick ;
Lloyd-Evans, Brynmor ;
Trevillion, Kylee ;
Simpson, Alan .
ISSUES IN MENTAL HEALTH NURSING, 2025, 46 (06) :529-565
[50]   Mental Health Nurses' Dispositional Decision-Making for People Presenting to the Emergency Department With Deliberate Self-Harm: An Exploratory Study [J].
Phillips, Grant ;
Gerdtz, Marie Frances ;
Elsom, Stephen James ;
Weiland, Tracey J. ;
Castle, David .
PERSPECTIVES IN PSYCHIATRIC CARE, 2015, 51 (02) :148-153