Accuracy of clinical diagnosis of Parkinson disease A systematic review and meta-analysis

被引:550
作者
Rizzo, Giovanni [1 ,2 ]
Copetti, Massimiliano [3 ]
Arcuti, Simona [1 ]
Martino, Davide [4 ,5 ]
Fontana, Andrea [3 ]
Logroscino, Giancarlo [1 ,6 ]
机构
[1] Univ Bari, Dept Clin Res Neurol, Tricase, Italy
[2] Univ Bologna, Dept Biomed & Neuromotor Sci, I-40126 Bologna, Italy
[3] IRCCS Casa Sollievo Sofferenza, Biostat Unit, San Giovanni Rotondo, Italy
[4] Kings Coll NHS Fdn Trust, Dept Neurol, London, England
[5] Lewisham & Greenwich NHS Trust, Queen Elizabeth Hosp, Dept Neurol, London, England
[6] Univ Bari, Neurosci & Sense Organs, Dept Basic Med Sci, Tricase, Italy
关键词
LEWY BODY DISEASE; FOLLOW-UP; DEMENTIA; PATHOLOGY; BRAIN; RISK; DISORDERS;
D O I
10.1212/WNL.0000000000002350
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Objective:To evaluate the diagnostic accuracy of clinical diagnosis of Parkinson disease (PD) reported in the last 25 years by a systematic review and meta-analysis.Methods:We searched for articles published between 1988 and August 2014. Studies were included if reporting diagnostic parameters regarding clinical diagnosis of PD or crude data. The selected studies were subclassified based on different study setting, type of test diagnosis, and gold standard. Bayesian meta-analyses of available data were performed.Results:We selected 20 studies, including 11 using pathologic examination as gold standard. Considering only these 11 studies, the pooled diagnostic accuracy was 80.6% (95% credible interval [CrI] 75.2%-85.3%). Accuracy was 73.8% (95% CrI 67.8%-79.6%) for clinical diagnosis performed mainly by nonexperts. Accuracy of clinical diagnosis performed by movement disorders experts rose from 79.6% (95% CrI 46%-95.1%) of initial assessment to 83.9% (95% CrI 69.7%-92.6%) of refined diagnosis after follow-up. Using UK Parkinson's Disease Society Brain Bank Research Center criteria, the pooled diagnostic accuracy was 82.7% (95% CrI 62.6%-93%).Conclusion:The overall validity of clinical diagnosis of PD is not satisfying. The accuracy did not significantly improve in the last 25 years, particularly in the early stages of disease, where response to dopaminergic treatment is less defined and hallmarks of alternative diagnoses such as atypical parkinsonism may not have emerged. Misclassification rate should be considered to calculate the sample size both in observational studies and randomized controlled trials. Imaging and biomarkers are urgently needed to improve the accuracy of clinical diagnosis in vivo.
引用
收藏
页码:566 / 576
页数:11
相关论文
共 48 条
[1]   Frequency of bowel movements and the future risk of Parkinson's disease [J].
Abbott, RD ;
Petrovitch, H ;
White, LR ;
Masaki, KH ;
Tanner, CM ;
Curb, JD ;
Grandinetti, A ;
Blanchette, PL ;
Popper, JS ;
Ross, GW .
NEUROLOGY, 2001, 57 (03) :456-462
[2]   Low clinical diagnostic accuracy of early vs advanced Parkinson disease Clinicopathologic study [J].
Adler, Charles H. ;
Beach, Thomas G. ;
Hentz, Joseph G. ;
Shill, Holly A. ;
Caviness, John N. ;
Driver-Dunckley, Erika ;
Sabbagh, Marwan N. ;
Sue, Lucia I. ;
Jacobson, Sandra A. ;
Belden, Christine M. ;
Dugger, Brittany N. .
NEUROLOGY, 2014, 83 (05) :406-412
[3]   Incidence of Parkinson's disease in Norway: the Norwegian ParkWest study [J].
Alves, G. ;
Mueller, B. ;
Herlofson, K. ;
HogenEsch, I. ;
Telstad, W. ;
Aarsland, D. ;
Tysnes, O-B ;
Larsen, J. P. .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2009, 80 (08) :851-857
[4]   Accuracy of clinical diagnosis in tremulous parkinsonian patients: a blinded video study [J].
Bajaj, Nin P. S. ;
Gontu, Vamsi ;
Birchall, James ;
Patterson, James ;
Grosset, Donald G. ;
Lees, Andrew J. .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2010, 81 (11) :1223-1228
[5]   EFNS/MDS-ES recommendations for the diagnosis of Parkinson's disease [J].
Berardelli, A. ;
Wenning, G. K. ;
Antonini, A. ;
Berg, D. ;
Bloem, B. R. ;
Bonifati, V. ;
Brooks, D. ;
Burn, D. J. ;
Colosimo, C. ;
Fanciulli, A. ;
Ferreira, J. ;
Gasser, T. ;
Grandas, F. ;
Kanovsky, P. ;
Kostic, V. ;
Kulisevsky, J. ;
Oertel, W. ;
Poewe, W. ;
Reese, J. -P. ;
Relja, M. ;
Ruzicka, E. ;
Schrag, A. ;
Seppi, K. ;
Taba, P. ;
Vidailhet, M. .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY, 2013, 20 (01) :16-+
[6]   Enlarged hyperechogenic substantia nigra as a risk marker for Parkinson's disease [J].
Berg, Daniela ;
Behnke, Stefanie ;
Seppi, Klaus ;
Godau, Jana ;
Lerche, Stefanie ;
Mahlknecht, Philipp ;
Liepelt-Scarfone, Inga ;
Pausch, Christoph ;
Schneider, Niko ;
Gaenslen, Alexandra ;
Brockmann, Kathrin ;
Srulijes, Karin ;
Huber, Heiko ;
Wurster, Isabel ;
Stockner, Heike ;
Kiechl, Stefan ;
Willeit, Johann ;
Gasperi, Arno ;
Fassbender, Klaus ;
Gasser, Thomas ;
Poewe, Werner .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2013, 28 (02) :216-219
[7]   Clinical correlates of the pathology underlying parkinsonism: A population perspective [J].
Bower, JH ;
Dickson, DW ;
Taylor, L ;
Maraganore, DM ;
Rocca, WA .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2002, 17 (05) :910-916
[8]   Staging of brain pathology related to sporadic Parkinson's disease [J].
Braak, H ;
Del Tredici, K ;
Rüb, U ;
de Vos, RAI ;
Steur, ENHJ ;
Braak, E .
NEUROBIOLOGY OF AGING, 2003, 24 (02) :197-211
[9]   Changes in diagnosis with follow-up in an incident cohort of patients with parkinsonism [J].
Caslake, R. ;
Moore, J. N. ;
Gordon, J. C. ;
Harris, C. E. ;
Counsell, C. .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2008, 79 (11) :1202-1207
[10]   Age-, gender-, and socioeconomic status-specific incidence of Parkinson's disease and parkinsonism in North East Scotland: The PINE study [J].
Caslake, Robert ;
Taylor, Kate ;
Scott, Neil ;
Gordon, Joanna ;
Harris, Clare ;
Wilde, Katie ;
Murray, Alison ;
Counsell, Carl .
PARKINSONISM & RELATED DISORDERS, 2013, 19 (05) :515-521