Comparison of topical honey and povidone iodine-based dressings for wound healing: a systematic review and meta-analysis

被引：10
作者：
Zhang, Fujie [1 ]
Chen, Zongnan [2 ]
Su, Feng [2 ]
Zhang, Taijuan [1 ]
机构：
[1] Tianjin Fifth Cent Hosp, Wound Treatment Ctr, Tianjin 300450, Peoples R China
[2] Tianjin Fifth Cent Hosp, Dept Gen Surg, Tianjin 300450, Peoples R China
来源：
JOURNAL OF WOUND CARE | 2021年 / 30卷
关键词：
antimicrobial; antisepsis; dressing; honey; infection; povidone iodine; ulcer; wounds; wound-healing; HEALTH; HETEROGENEITY; PREVENTION; CARE;
D O I：
10.12968/jowc.2021.30.Sup4.S28
中图分类号：
R75 [皮肤病学与性病学];
学科分类号：
100206 ;
摘要：
Objectives: In this review and meta-analysis, we analyse the evidence to compare the efficacy of honey and povidone iodine-based dressings on the outcome of wound healing. Method: A systematic literature search was performed using PRISMA guidelines in academic databases including MEDLINE, Scopus, Embase and CENTRAL. A meta-analysis was carried out to assess the effect of honey and povidone iodine-based dressings on mean healing duration, mean hospital stay duration and visual analogue scale (VAS) score of pain. Results: From the search, 12 manuscripts with a total of 1236 participants (mean age: 40.7 +/- 11.7 years) were included. The honey-based dressings demonstrated a medium-to-large effect in reduction of mean healing duration (Hedge's g: -0.81), length of hospital stay (-3.1) and VAS score (-1.2) as compared with the povidone iodine-based dressings. We present evidence (level 1b) in favour of using honey for improvement of wound recovery as compared with povidone iodine. Conclusion: This review and meta-analysis demonstrate beneficial effects of honey-based dressings over povidone iodine-based dressings for wound recovery.
引用
收藏
页码：S28 / S36
页数：9
相关论文
共 53 条
[41]  
Samee MU, 2019, PAK J MED HEALTH SCI, V13, P102
[42]   Human skin wounds: A major and snowballing threat to public health and the economy [J].
Sen, Chandan K. ;
Gordillo, Gayle M. ;
Roy, Sashwati ;
Kirsner, Robert ;
Lambert, Lynn ;
Hunt, Thomas K. ;
Gottrup, Finn ;
Gurtner, Geoffrey C. ;
Longaker, Michael T. .
WOUND REPAIR AND REGENERATION, 2009, 17 (06) :763-771
[43]  
Shukrimi A, 2008, Med J Malaysia, V63, P44
[44]   Medical Honey for Wound Care - Still the Latest Resort [J].
Simon, Arne ;
Traynor, Kirsten ;
Santos, Kai ;
Blaser, Gisela ;
Bode, Udo ;
Molan, Peter .
EVIDENCE-BASED COMPLEMENTARY AND ALTERNATIVE MEDICINE, 2009, 6 (02) :165-173
[45]  
Stephen-Haynes Jackie, 2004, Br J Community Nurs, VSuppl, pS21
[46]   ROBINS-I: a tool for assessing risk of bias in non-randomised studies of interventions [J].
Sterne, Jonathan A. C. ;
Hernan, Miguel A. ;
Reeves, Barnaby C. ;
Savovic, Jelena ;
Berkman, Nancy D. ;
Viswanathan, Meera ;
Henry, David ;
Altman, Douglas G. ;
Ansari, Mohammed T. ;
Boutron, Isabelle ;
Carpenter, James R. ;
Chan, An-Wen ;
Churchill, Rachel ;
Deeks, Jonathan J. ;
Hrobjartsson, Asbjorn ;
Kirkham, Jamie ;
Juni, Peter ;
Loke, Yoon K. ;
Pigott, Theresa D. ;
Ramsay, Craig R. ;
Regidor, Deborah ;
Rothstein, Hannah R. ;
Sandhu, Lakhbir ;
Santaguida, Pasqualina L. ;
Schunemann, Holger J. ;
Shea, Beverly ;
Shrier, Ian ;
Tugwell, Peter ;
Turner, Lucy ;
Valentine, Jeffrey C. ;
Waddington, Hugh ;
Waters, Elizabeth ;
Wells, George A. ;
Whiting, Penny F. ;
Higgins, Julian P. T. .
BMJ-BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 2016, 355
[47]  
Vardi A, 1998, ACTA PAEDIATR, V87, P429
[48]   Benefit and harm of iodine in wound care: a systematic review [J].
Vermeulen, H. ;
Westerbos, S. J. ;
Ubbink, D. T. .
JOURNAL OF HOSPITAL INFECTION, 2010, 76 (03) :191-199
[49]   VAGINAL ABSORPTION OF POVIDONE-IODINE [J].
VORHERR, H ;
VORHERR, UF ;
MEHTA, P ;
ULRICH, JA ;
MESSER, RH .
JAMA-JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION, 1980, 244 (23) :2628-2629
[50]   Effectiveness of honey dressing in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers: A systematic review and meta-analysis [J].
Wang, Cui ;
Guo, Min ;
Zhang, Nan ;
Wang, Gongchao .
COMPLEMENTARY THERAPIES IN CLINICAL PRACTICE, 2019, 34 :123-131
123456