God's Necessity on Anselmian Theistic Genuine Modal Realism

被引:7
作者
Collier, Matthew James [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Oxford, Oriel Coll, Oriel Sq, Oxford OX1 4EW, England
关键词
Genuine modal realism; Anselmian theism; Necessary being; Counterpart theory; Transworld identity;
D O I
10.1007/s11841-018-0659-4
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
On Anselmian theism (AT), God is, amongst other things, a necessary being. On genuine modal realism (GMR), possible worlds are maximal mereological sums of spatiotemporally connected individuals. I argue in this paper that AT and GMR are either incompatible or their conjunction leads to-amongst other things-modal collapse. Specifically, I argue: regardless of whether God is concrete or abstract, His necessary existence either is inconsistent with AT-GMR or it leads to, amongst other things, modal collapse for AT-GMR. I conclude the paper by contending that, if I am correct, the ATist will have an argument against the truth of GMR, and the GMRist will have an argument against the truth of AT.
引用
收藏
页码:331 / 348
页数:18
相关论文
共 30 条
  • [1] Theistic Modal Realism II: Theoretical Benefits
    Almeida, Michael
    [J]. PHILOSOPHY COMPASS, 2017, 12 (07):
  • [2] Almeida MichaelJ., 2011, OXFORD STUDIES PHILO, V3
  • [3] Almeida MJ, 2008, ROUT STUD PHILOS REL, V5, P1
  • [4] [Anonymous], GOD NECESSITY
  • [5] [Anonymous], STANFORD ENCY PHILOS
  • [6] God exists at every (modal realist) world: response to Sheehy
    Cameron, Ross P.
    [J]. RELIGIOUS STUDIES, 2009, 45 (01) : 95 - 100
  • [7] Cowling S, 2017, AM PHILOS QUART, V54, P223
  • [8] Davis, 2008, PHILOS CHRISTI, V10, P57, DOI [10.5840/pc20081014, DOI 10.5840/pc20081014]
  • [9] Davis, 2009, PHILOS CHRISTI, V11, P437, DOI [10.5840/pc200911238, DOI 10.5840/PC200911238]
  • [10] Divers John., 2002, Possible Worlds