Epidemiological risk factors of coronary heart disease are not causal in atherosclerosis

被引:7
作者
Stehbens, WE [1 ]
机构
[1] Wellington Sch Med, Dept Pathol & Mol Med, Wellington, New Zealand
关键词
coronary heart disease; atherosclerosis; risk factors; causality;
D O I
10.1081/CEH-100100083
中图分类号
R9 [药学];
学科分类号
1007 ;
摘要
Logic dictates that for scientific progress in atherogenesis "cause" must be the sole prequisite without which the disease cannot occur. Nor can it be assumed that statistical associations (risk factors) with coronary heart disease (CHD) are causal for atherosclerosis and extrapolations from correlations with CHD incidence to atherosclerosis are invalid. Any factor considered to play a role in atherogenesis requires pathological and experimental evidence consistent with the logic of Koch's specificity of cause and effect. Current epidemiological misuse and manipulation of cause and risk factors are contrary to the basic precepts of scientific logic and the fundamental need for precision in word usage. The term "risk factor", because of the current deeply entrenched false concept of causality has retarded medical progress and should be abandoned. Its adherents, guilty of a disservice to the tenets of their discipline, have also sullied the scientific integrity of medicine as a whole.
引用
收藏
页码:445 / 453
页数:9
相关论文
共 42 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], EPIDEMIOLOGY MED ECO
[2]  
Bahn, 1974, EPIDEMIOLOGY INTRO T
[3]   DOES PASSIVE SMOKING CAUSE HEART-DISEASE [J].
BEAGLEHOLE, R .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1990, 301 (6765) :1343-1344
[4]  
BERNARD C, 1957, INTRO STUDY EXPT MED, P164
[5]  
Bernard Claude, 1974, LECT PHENOMENA LIFE, V1
[6]  
Bunge M.A., 1959, Causality. the Place of the Causal Principle in Modern Science
[7]   KOCH POSTULATES IN RELATION TO THE WORK OF HENLE,JACOB AND KLEBS,EDWIN [J].
CARTER, KC .
MEDICAL HISTORY, 1985, 29 (04) :353-374
[8]  
COTRAN RS, 1989, ROBBINS PATHOLOGIC B, P553
[9]  
Dawber ThomasR., 1980, FRAMINGHAM STUDY EPI
[10]  
DAWBER TR, 1963, ANN NY ACAD SCI, V107, P9