Should editors influence journal impact factors?

被引:28
|
作者
Krell, Frank-Thorsten [1 ]
机构
[1] Denver Museum Nat & Sci, Dept Zool, Denver, CO 80205 USA
关键词
CITATION DATABASES; REFERENCES; MANIPULATION; SCIENCE;
D O I
10.1087/20100110
中图分类号
G25 [图书馆学、图书馆事业]; G35 [情报学、情报工作];
学科分类号
1205 ; 120501 ;
摘要
The journal impact factor is widely used as a performance indicator for single authors (despite its unsuitably in this respect). Hence, authors are increasingly exercised if there is any sign that impact factors are being manipulated. Editors who ask authors to cite relevant papers from their own journal tire accused of acting unethically. This is surprising because, besides publishers, authors are the primary beneficiaries of an increased impact factor of the journal in which they publish, and because the citation process is biased anyway. There is growing evidence that quality and relevance are not always the reasons for choosing references. Authors' biases and personal environments as well (is strategic considerations are major factors. As long (is an editor does not force authors to cite irrelevant papers front their own journal, I consider it as a matter of caretaking for the journal and its authors if an editor brings recent papers to the authors' attention. It would be Unfair to authors and disloyal to the publisher if an editor did not try to increase the impact of his/her own journal. (C) Frank-Thorsten Krell
引用
收藏
页码:59 / 62
页数:4
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [31] Deep impact: unintended consequences of journal rank
    Brembs, Bjoern
    Button, Katherine
    Munafo, Marcus
    FRONTIERS IN HUMAN NEUROSCIENCE, 2013, 7
  • [32] Making an impact: the Journal of Foot and Ankle Research
    Menz, Hylton B.
    Potter, Mike J.
    Borthwick, Alan M.
    Munteanu, Shannon E.
    Landorf, Karl B.
    JOURNAL OF FOOT AND ANKLE RESEARCH, 2012, 5
  • [33] Journal Impact Factor Revised with Focused View
    Nakatoh, Tetsuya
    Nakanishi, Hayato
    Hirokawa, Sachio
    INTELLIGENT DECISION TECHNOLOGIES, 2015, 39 : 471 - 481
  • [34] Games academics play and their consequences: how authorship, h-index and journal impact factors are shaping the future of academia
    Chapman, Colin A.
    Bicca-Marques, Julio Cesar
    Calvignac-Spencer, Sebastien
    Fan, Pengfei
    Fashing, Peter J.
    Gogarten, Jan
    Guo, Songtao
    Hemingway, Claire A.
    Leendertz, Fabian
    Li, Baoguo
    Matsuda, Ikki
    Hou, Rong
    Serio-Silva, Juan Carlos
    Stenseth, Nils Chr
    PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROYAL SOCIETY B-BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES, 2019, 286 (1916)
  • [35] History of the journal impact factor: Contingencies and consequences
    Archambault, Eric
    Lariviere, Vincent
    SCIENTOMETRICS, 2009, 79 (03) : 635 - 649
  • [36] Journal Impact Factor: Mathematical and Statistical Properties
    Elizarova, A. M.
    Pislyakov, V. V.
    UCHENYE ZAPISKI KAZANSKOGO UNIVERSITETA-SERIYA FIZIKO-MATEMATICHESKIE NAUKI, 2024, 166 (04): : 485 - 498
  • [37] Journal Self-Citation V: Coercive Journal Self-Citation - Manipulations to Increase Impact Factors May Do More Harm than Good in the Long Run
    Romano, Nicholas C., Jr.
    COMMUNICATIONS OF THE ASSOCIATION FOR INFORMATION SYSTEMS, 2009, 25 : 41 - 56
  • [38] Shedding light on alternative interdisciplinary accounting research through journal editors' perspectives and an analysis of recent publications
    Maran, Laura
    Bigoni, Michele
    Morrison, Leanne
    CRITICAL PERSPECTIVES ON ACCOUNTING, 2023, 93
  • [39] Global Diversity of Authors, Editors, and Journal Ownership Across Subdisciplines of Psychology: Current State and Policy Implications
    Lin, Zhicheng
    Li, Ningxi
    PERSPECTIVES ON PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE, 2023, 18 (02) : 358 - 377
  • [40] Hypothetical influence of non-indexed Spanish medical journals on the impact factor of the Journal Citation Reports-indexed journals
    Aleixandre-Benavent, Rafael
    Valderrama Zurian, Juan Carlos
    Miguel-Dasit, Alberto
    Alonso Arroyo, Adolfo
    Castellano Gomez, Miguel
    SCIENTOMETRICS, 2007, 70 (01) : 53 - 66