More expansive horizons: a review of endovascular therapy for patients with low NIHSS scores

被引:33
作者
McCarthy, David J. [1 ]
Tonetti, Daniel A. [1 ]
Stone, Jeremy [1 ]
Starke, Robert M. [2 ,3 ]
Narayanan, Sandra [4 ]
Lang, Michael J. [1 ]
Jadhav, Ashutosh P. [4 ]
Gross, Bradley A. [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Pittsburgh, Dept Neurosurg, Pittsburgh, PA 15213 USA
[2] Univ Miami, MILLER Sch Med, Dept Neurol Surg, Miami Beach, FL USA
[3] Univ Miami, Sch Med, Dept Neurosurg, Miami, FL USA
[4] Univ Pittsburgh, Dept Neurol, Pittsburgh, PA 15213 USA
关键词
thrombolysis; thrombectomy; stroke;
D O I
10.1136/neurintsurg-2020-016583
中图分类号
R445 [影像诊断学];
学科分类号
100207 ;
摘要
While the landmark 2015 stroke trials demonstrated that endovascular therapy (EVT) was superior to medical management for the treatment of acute ischemic stroke due to large vessel occlusion, the efficacy of EVT for patients presenting with a low NIHSS score remains undetermined. We conducted a review of the EVT low National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS) stroke literature, identifying 24 quantitative and six qualitative publications. Details of study designs and outcome were extracted and critically discussed. All identified qualitative studies were retrospective. There was significant study design heterogeneity, with 18 unique study designs between the 24 identified quantitative manuscripts. Study investigations included low NIHSS EVT feasibility (n=6), EVT versus best medical management (BMM; n=10), EVT versus intravenous therapy (IVT, n=3), and low NIHSS score versus high NIHSS score (n=3). From single-arm EVT feasibility studies, the reported ranges of modified Thrombolysis in Cerebral Infarction and symptomatic intracranial hemorrhage were 78-97% and 0-10%, respectively. The EVT versus BMM literature had heterogeneous results with 40% reporting benefit with EVT and 60% reporting neutral findings. None of the studies comparing EVT with IVT reported a difference between the two revascularization therapies. The four identified meta-analyses had incongruent inclusion criteria and conflicting results. Two randomized trials are currently investigating EVT in patients with a low NIHSS score. Selected meta-analyses do suggest a potential benefit of EVT over BMM; however, current and future randomized clinical trials will better elucidate the efficacy of EVT in this patient population.
引用
收藏
页码:146 / 151
页数:7
相关论文
共 60 条
[1]   Baseline NIH Stroke Scale score strongly predicts outcome after stroke - A report of the Trial of Org 10172 in Acute Stroke Treatment (TOAST) [J].
Adams, HP ;
Davis, PH ;
Leira, EC ;
Chang, KC ;
Bendixen, BH ;
Clarke, WR ;
Woolson, RF ;
Hansen, MD .
NEUROLOGY, 1999, 53 (01) :126-131
[2]  
Alqahtani SA, 2017, CUREUS J MED SCIENCE, V9, DOI 10.7759/cureus.1355
[3]   Patterns and Outcomes of Endovascular Therapy in Mild Stroke: A Florida-Puerto Rico Collaboration [J].
Asdaghi, Negar ;
Yavagal, Dileep R. ;
Wang, Kefeng ;
Mueller-Kronast, Nils ;
Bhatt, Nirav ;
Gardener, Hannah E. ;
Gutierrez, Carolina M. ;
Marulanda-Londono, Erika ;
Koch, Sebastian ;
Dong, Chuanhui ;
Oluwole, Sophia A. ;
Hanel, Ricardo ;
Mehta, Brijesh ;
Robichaux, Mary ;
Nobo, Ulises ;
Zevallos, Juan C. ;
Rundek, Tatjana ;
Sacco, Ralph L. ;
Romano, Jose G. .
STROKE, 2019, 50 (08) :2101-2107
[4]   Why are stroke patients excluded from TPA therapy? An analysis of patient eligibility [J].
Barber, PA ;
Zhang, J ;
Demchuk, AM ;
Hill, MD ;
Buchan, AM .
NEUROLOGY, 2001, 56 (08) :1015-1020
[5]   Mechanical thrombectomy in patients with M1 occlusion and NIHSS score ≤5: a single-centre experience [J].
Bhogal, P. ;
Buecke, P. ;
Ganslandt, O. ;
Baezner, H. ;
Henkes, H. ;
Perez, M. Aguilar .
STROKE AND VASCULAR NEUROLOGY, 2016, 1 (04) :165-171
[6]   Clinical and Imaging Outcomes of Endovascular Therapy in Patients with Acute Large Vessel Occlusion Stroke and Mild Clinical Symptoms [J].
Bowen, Meredith T. ;
Rebello, Leticia C. ;
Bouslama, Mehdi ;
Haussen, Diogo C. ;
Grossberg, Jonathan A. ;
Bianchi, Nicolas A. ;
Belagaje, Samir ;
Anderson, Aaron ;
Frankel, Michael R. ;
Nogueira, Raul G. .
INTERVENTIONAL NEUROLOGY, 2018, 7 (1-2) :91-98
[7]   Endovascular Therapy after Intravenous t-PA versus t-PA Alone for Stroke [J].
Broderick, Joseph P. ;
Palesch, Yuko Y. ;
Demchuk, Andrew M. ;
Yeatts, Sharon D. ;
Khatri, Pooja ;
Hill, Michael D. ;
Jauch, Edward C. ;
Jovin, Tudor G. ;
Yan, Bernard ;
Silver, Frank L. ;
von Kummer, Ruediger ;
Molina, Carlos A. ;
Demaerschalk, Bart M. ;
Budzik, Ronald ;
Clark, Wayne M. ;
Zaidat, Osama O. ;
Malisch, Tim W. ;
Goyal, Mayank ;
Schonewille, Wouter J. ;
Mazighi, Mikael ;
Engelter, Stefan T. ;
Anderson, Craig ;
Spilker, Judith ;
Carrozzella, Janice ;
Ryckborst, Karla J. ;
Janis, L. Scott ;
Martin, Renee H. ;
Foster, Lydia D. ;
Tomsick, Thomas A. .
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE, 2013, 368 (10) :893-903
[8]   Recombinant tissue plasminogen activator for minor strokes: The National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke rt-PA Stroke Study Experience [J].
Broderick, JP ;
Brott, T ;
DeGraba, T ;
Fagan, SC ;
Frankel, MR ;
Grotta, JC ;
Haley, EC ;
Hamilton, S ;
Kwiatkowski, T ;
Levine, SR ;
Lewandowski, CA ;
Lin, Y ;
Libman, R ;
Lu, M ;
Lyden, P ;
Marler, JR ;
Morgenstern, L ;
Patel, S ;
Sanders, C ;
Tilley, BC .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2005, 46 (03) :243-252
[9]   Mechanical Thrombectomy for Minor and Mild Stroke Patients Harboring Large Vessel Occlusion in the Anterior Circulation A Multicenter Cohort Study [J].
Dargazanli, Cyril ;
Arquizan, Caroline ;
Gory, Benjamin ;
Consoli, Arturo ;
Labreuche, Julien ;
Redjem, Hocine ;
Eker, Omer ;
Decroix, Jean-Pierre ;
Corlobe, Astrid ;
Mourand, Isabelle ;
Gaillard, Nicolas ;
Ayrignac, Xavier ;
Charif, Mahmoud ;
Duhamel, Alain ;
Labeyrie, Paul-Emile ;
Riquelme, Carlos ;
Ciccio, Gabriele ;
Smajda, Stanislas ;
Desilles, Jean-Philippe ;
Gascou, Gregory ;
Lefevre, Pierre-Henri ;
Mantilla-Garcia, Daniel ;
Cagnazzo, Federico ;
Coskun, Oguzhan ;
Mazighi, Mikael ;
Riva, Roberto ;
Bourdain, Frederic ;
Labauge, Pierre ;
Rodesch, Georges ;
Obadia, Michael ;
Bonafe, Alain ;
Turjman, Francis ;
Costalat, Vincent ;
Piotin, Michel ;
Blanc, Raphael ;
Lapergue, Bertrand .
STROKE, 2017, 48 (12) :3274-3281
[10]   Is Reperfusion Useful in Ischaemic Stroke Patients Presenting with a Low National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale and a Proximal Large Vessel Occlusion of the Anterior Circulation (vol 43, pg 305, 2017) [J].
Dargazanli, Cyril ;
Consoli, Arturo ;
Gory, Benjamin ;
Blanc, Raphael ;
Labreuche, Julien ;
Preda, Cristian ;
Bourdain, Frederic ;
Decroix, Jean-Pierre ;
Redjem, Hocine ;
Ciccio, Gabriele ;
Mazighi, Mikael ;
Smajda, Stanislas ;
Desilles, Jean-Philippe ;
Riva, Roberto ;
Labeyrie, Paul-Emile ;
Coskun, Oguzhan ;
Rodesch, Georges ;
Turjman, Francis ;
Piotin, Michel ;
Lapergue, Bertrand .
CEREBROVASCULAR DISEASES, 2017, 43 (5-6) :313-313