The looking/not looking dilemma

被引:17
作者
Moller, Frank
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1017/S0260210509990180
中图分类号
D81 [国际关系];
学科分类号
030207 ;
摘要
When confronted with images of war and other forms of human suffering, not looking is not an option, not only because we are permanently exposed to images but also because it would not seem to be a morally tenable position. However, looking at images of human suffering is often said to prolong this very suffering and to fix human subjects as victims. Especially when acts of violence have been committed ill order to produce images of these very acts the relationship between viewing the images and participating in the acts of violence qua viewer appears to be uncomfortably close indeed. Thus, looking is not an option, either. This article, in the first part, engages with standard criticisms of photography, especially with accusations according to which photographs aestheticise that which they depict and desensitise their viewers. In the second part it discusses Alfredo Jaar's and Jeff Wall's work in order to show possible ways to circumvent the looking/not looking dilemma.
引用
收藏
页码:781 / 794
页数:14
相关论文
共 31 条
[11]  
GEYER M, 1997, NEW GERMAN CRITIQUE, V71, P7
[12]  
GOUREVITCH, STANDARD OPERATING P, P112
[13]  
GOUREVITCH P, 2008, STANDARD OPERATING P, P195
[14]  
Gourevitch P., 1998, WE WISH INFORM YOU T
[15]  
Hagopian Patrick, 2006, LOCATING MEMORY PHOT, P208
[16]  
Hariman Robert, 2007, NO CAPTION NEEDED IC, P42
[17]  
HIRSCH M, 1997, FAMILY FRAMES PHOTOG, P71
[18]  
HOLMES OW, 1862, NY TIMES 1020
[19]  
JONES J, 2007, GUARDIAN 1129
[20]  
MICHAELS M, 1994, TIME 0806