Effectiveness of Botulinum Toxin Treatment for Upper Limb Spasticity Poststroke Over Different ICF Domains: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

被引:77
作者
Andringa, Aukje [1 ]
van de Port, Ingrid [2 ]
van Wegen, Erwin [1 ]
Ket, Johannes [3 ]
Meskers, Carel [1 ,4 ]
Kwakkel, Gert [1 ,4 ,5 ]
机构
[1] Vrije Univ Amsterdam, Amsterdam Univ Med Ctr, Dept Rehabil Med, Amsterdam Movement Sci,Amsterdam Neurosci, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[2] Revant Rehabil Ctr Breda, Breda, Netherlands
[3] Vrije Univ Amsterdam, Med Lib, Amsterdam, Netherlands
[4] Northwestern Univ, Dept Phys Therapy & Human Movement Sci, Chicago, IL 60611 USA
[5] Amsterdam Rehabil Res Ctr, Dept Neurorehabil, Reade, Amsterdam, Netherlands
来源
ARCHIVES OF PHYSICAL MEDICINE AND REHABILITATION | 2019年 / 100卷 / 09期
基金
欧洲研究理事会;
关键词
Botulinum toxins; Meta-analysis; Muscle spasticity; Rehabilitation; Stroke; TRAUMATIC BRAIN-INJURY; RANDOMIZED CONTROLLED-TRIAL; HEMIPLEGIC SHOULDER PAIN; QUALITY-OF-LIFE; DOUBLE-BLIND; UPPER-EXTREMITY; POST STROKE; CLINICAL-TRIALS; ADULT PATIENTS; PEDRO SCALE;
D O I
10.1016/j.apmr.2019.01.016
中图分类号
R49 [康复医学];
学科分类号
100215 ;
摘要
Objective: To provide a comprehensive overview of reported effects and scientific robustness of botulinum toxin (BoNT) treatment regarding the main clinical goals related to poststroke upper limb spasticity, using the International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health. Data Sources: Embase, PubMed, Wiley/Cochrane Library, and Ebsco/CINAHL were searched from inception up to May 16, 2018. Study Selection: We included randomized controlled trials comparing upper limb BoNT injections with a control intervention in patients with a history of stroke. A total of 1212 unique records were screened by 2 independent reviewers. Forty trials were identified, including 2718 patients with history of stroke. Data Extraction: Outcome data were pooled according to assessment timing (ie, 4-8wk and 12wk after injection), and categorized into 6 main clinical goals (ie, spasticity-related pain, involuntary movements, passive joint motion, care ability, arm and hand use, and standing and walking performance). Sensitivity analyses were performed for the influence of study and intervention characteristics, involvement of pharmaceutical industry, and publication bias. Data Synthesis: Robust evidence is shown for the effectiveness of BoNT in reducing resistance to passive movement, as measured with the (Modified) Ashworth Score, and improving self-care ability for the affected hand and arm after intervention (P<.005) and at follow-up (P<.005). In addition, robust evidence is shown for the absence of effect on arm-hand capacity at follow-up. BoNT was found to significantly reduce involuntary movements, spasticity-related pain, and caregiver burden, and improve passive range of motion, while no evidence was found for arm and hand use after intervention. Conclusions: In view of the robustness of current evidence, no further trials are needed to investigate BoNT for its favorable effects on resistance to passive movement of the spastic wrist and fingers, and on self-care. No trials are needed to further confirm the lack of effects of BoNT on arm-hand capacity, whereas additional trials are needed to establish the suggested favorable effects of BoNT on other body functions, which may result in clinically meaningful outcomes at activity and participation levels. (C) 2019 by the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine
引用
收藏
页码:1703 / 1725
页数:23
相关论文
共 82 条
[21]   Shoulder pain and external rotation in spastic hemiplegia do not improve by injection of botulinum toxin A into the subscapular muscle [J].
de Boer, K. S. ;
Arwert, H. J. ;
de Groot, J. H. ;
Meskers, C. G. M. ;
Mishre, A. D. Rambaran ;
Arendzen, J. H. .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 2008, 79 (05) :581-583
[22]   Estimation of tissue stiffness, reflex activity, optimal muscle length and slack length in stroke patients using an electromyography driven antagonistic wrist model [J].
de Gooijer-van de Groep, Karin L. ;
de Vlugt, Erwin ;
van der Krogt, Hanneke J. ;
Helgadottir, Arora ;
Arendzen, J. Hans ;
Meskers, Carel G. M. ;
de Groot, Jurriaan H. .
CLINICAL BIOMECHANICS, 2016, 35 :93-101
[23]   The PEDro scale is a valid measure of the methodological quality of clinical trials: a demographic study [J].
de Morton, Natalie A. .
AUSTRALIAN JOURNAL OF PHYSIOTHERAPY, 2009, 55 (02) :129-133
[24]   The relation between neuromechanical parameters and Ashworth score in stroke patients [J].
de Vlugt, Erwin ;
de Groot, Jurriaan H. ;
Schenkeveld, Kim E. ;
Arendzen, J. Hans ;
van der Helm, Frans C. T. ;
Meskers, Carel G. M. .
JOURNAL OF NEUROENGINEERING AND REHABILITATION, 2010, 7
[25]   Multidisciplinary rehabilitation following botulinum toxin and other focal intramuscular treatment for post-stroke spasticity [J].
Demetrios, Marina ;
Khan, Fary ;
Turner-Stokes, Lynne ;
Brand, Caroline ;
McSweeney, Shane .
COCHRANE DATABASE OF SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS, 2013, (06)
[26]   Spastic movement disorder: impaired reflex function and altered muscle mechanics [J].
Dietz, Volker ;
Sinkjaer, Thomas .
LANCET NEUROLOGY, 2007, 6 (08) :725-733
[27]   Efficacy and safety of botulinum toxin type A for upper limb spasticity after stroke or traumatic brain injury: a systematic review with meta-analysis and trial sequential analysis [J].
Dong, Yan ;
Wu, Tao ;
Hu, Xiaohua ;
Wang, Tong .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF PHYSICAL AND REHABILITATION MEDICINE, 2017, 53 (02) :256-+
[28]   Botulinum Neurotoxins for Post-Stroke Spasticity in Adults: A Systematic Review [J].
Elia, Antonio Emanuele ;
Filippini, Graziella ;
Calandrella, Daniela ;
Albanese, Alberto .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2009, 24 (06) :801-812
[29]   RANDOMIZED, PLACEBO-CONTROLLED TRIAL OF INCOBOTULINUMTOXINA FOR UPPER-LIMB POST-STROKE SPASTICITY [J].
Elovic, Elie Paul ;
Munin, Michael C. ;
Kanovsky, Petr ;
Hanschmann, Angelika ;
Hiersemenzel, Reinhard ;
Marciniak, Christina .
MUSCLE & NERVE, 2016, 53 (03) :415-421
[30]   Evidence-based review and assessment of botulinum neurotoxin for the treatment of adult spasticity in the upper motor neuron syndrome [J].
Esquenazi, Alberto ;
Albanese, Alberto ;
Chancellor, Michael B. ;
Elovic, Elie ;
Segal, Karen R. ;
Simpson, David M. ;
Smith, Christopher P. ;
Ward, Anthony B. .
TOXICON, 2013, 67 :115-128