The Influence of Mode-of-Injury on Psychological Readiness for Return-To-Sport Following Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Matched-Controlled Study

Background Self-efficacy and fear of re-injury have been documented as factors related to an athlete's ability to return-to-sport after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. The purpose of this study was to compare psychological readiness between athletes injured in their primary mode of sport versus those injured outside of their primary sport following ACL reconstruction. Hypothesis Athletes sustaining 'in-sport' injuries will demonstrate poorer psychological readiness when compared their matched counterparts injured outside of their primary sport. Study Design Case-Control Study Methods A single-surgeon database of 638 patients following ACL reconstruction was used to conduct a matched case-control analysis. Psychological readiness was examined 16-weeks postoperatively using the ACL-Return to Sport after Injury (ACL-RSI) questionnaire with subgroup analyses for the 'emotional', 'confidence' and 'injury-risk' subscales. Subject matching was performed for baseline patient and surgical demographics. All statistical comparisons were performed using a one-way (group) analysis variance (ANOVA) at a significance level of alpha = .05. Results Ninety-two matched patients (49 'in-sport' injuries, 43 'out-of-sport' injuries) were included in the final analysis. The 'in-sport' group exhibited significantly lower total ACL-RSI scores (55.3 +/- 12.9 versus 60.8 +/- 11.6, t = 2.747, P < .001) when compared to the 'out-of-sport' group. Subscale comparisons indicated lower 'emotional' (P < .016) and higher 'injury risk' (P < .001) psychological constructs for 'in-sport' athletes versus 'out-of-sport' athletes. No differences were found between groups for the 'confidence' subscale (P = .987). Conclusions Athletes sustaining 'in-sport' ACL injuries demonstrated poorer psychological readiness when compared to athletes injured outside their primary sport when in preparation for return-to-sport activities following ACL reconstruction.