Trevo versus Solitaire a Head- to- Head Comparison Between Two Heavy Weights of Clot Retrieval

被引:37
作者
Mendonca, Nuno [1 ]
Flores, Alan [2 ]
Pagola, Jorge [2 ]
Rubiera, Marta [2 ]
Rodriguez-Luna, David [2 ]
De Miquel, M. Angels [3 ]
Cardona, Pere [4 ]
Quesada, Helena [4 ]
Mora, Paloma [2 ,3 ]
Alvarez-Sabin, Jose [2 ]
Molina, Carlos [2 ]
Ribo, Marc [2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Hosp Coimbra, Dept Neurol, Coimbra, Portugal
[2] Univ Autonoma Barcelona, Dept Neurosci, Hosp Univ Vall dHebron, Dept Med,Stroke Unit, Barcelona 08035, Spain
[3] Hosp Univ Bellvitge, Barcelona, Spain
[4] Hosp Univ Bellvitge, Serv Neurol, Barcelona, Spain
关键词
Acute embolectomy; interventional neuroradiology; reperfusion; stroke; thrombectomy; ACUTE ISCHEMIC-STROKE; MECHANICAL THROMBECTOMY; RECANALIZATION; DEVICE; OCCLUSIONS;
D O I
10.1111/j.1552-6569.2012.00730.x
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSERecent reports have indicated that mechanical thrombectomy may have potential to treat acute ischemic stroke. However, few comparative studies of neurothrombectomy devices are reported. This study aims to compare the safety and effectiveness of two retrievable stent systems in acute ischemic stroke patients. METHODSA prospective study comparing the clinical, radiological, and functional outcome of 33 patients with an angiographically verified occlusion of the anterior cerebral circulation. Patients were treated either with Trevo Retriever(TM) or Solitaire Stent(TM) according to the neurointerventionalist preference. Successful recanalization was defined as TICI grade 2a to 3. Good outcome was defined as a modified Rankin Scale score 2 at 3 months. RESULTSRevascularization was achieved in 10 patients (77%) in the Trevo group and in 12 (60%) of the Solitaire group (P = .456). Rate of symptomatic ICH was 0% for Trevo versus 15% for Solitaire (P = .261). Four patients (30%) died during the 3-month follow-up period in the Trevo versus 5 patients (25%) in the solitaire group (P = 1.000). Rate of good outcome was 38% and 40% for Trevo and Solitaire respectively (P = .435). CONCLUSIONSOur study showed no significant differences between both stentrievers. Moderately high recanalization rates are possible with both, however larger series may depict safety-related variations.
引用
收藏
页码:167 / 170
页数:4
相关论文
共 15 条
[1]   High rate of complete recanalization and dramatic clinical recovery during tPA infusion when continuously monitored with 2-MHz transcranial Doppler monitoring [J].
Alexandrov, AV ;
Demchuk, AM ;
Felberg, RA ;
Christou, I ;
Barber, PA ;
Burgin, WS ;
Malkoff, M ;
Wojner, AW ;
Grotta, JC .
STROKE, 2000, 31 (03) :610-614
[2]   Intracerebral hemorrhage after intravenous t-PA therapy for ischemic stroke [J].
Brott, T ;
Broderick, J ;
Kothari, R ;
ODonoghue, M ;
Barsan, W ;
Tomsick, T ;
Spilker, J ;
Miller, R ;
Sauerbeck, L ;
Farrell, J ;
Kelly, J ;
Perkins, T ;
Miller, R ;
McDonald, T ;
Rorick, M ;
Hickey, C ;
Armitage, J ;
Perry, C ;
Thalinger, K ;
Rhude, R ;
Schill, J ;
Becker, PS ;
Heath, RS ;
Adams, D ;
Reed, R ;
Klei, M ;
Hughes, A ;
Anthony, J ;
Baudendistel, D ;
Zadicoff, C ;
Rymer, M ;
Bettinger, I ;
Laubinger, P ;
Schmerler, M ;
Meiros, G ;
Lyden, P ;
Dunford, J ;
Zivin, J ;
Rapp, K ;
Babcock, T ;
Daum, P ;
Persona, D ;
Brody, M ;
Jackson, C ;
Lewis, S ;
Liss, J ;
Mahdavi, Z ;
Rothrock, J ;
Tom, T ;
Zweifler, R .
STROKE, 1997, 28 (11) :2109-2118
[3]   Mechanical Thrombectomy With the Solitaire AB Device in Large Artery Occlusions of the Anterior Circulation A Pilot Study [J].
Castano, Carlos ;
Dorado, Laura ;
Guerrero, Cristina ;
Millan, Monica ;
Gomis, Meritxell ;
Perez de la Ossa, Natalia ;
Castellanos, Mar ;
Rosa Garcia, M. ;
Domenech, Sira ;
Davalos, Antoni .
STROKE, 2010, 41 (08) :1836-1840
[4]   A novel microcatheter-delivered, highly-flexible and fully-retrievable stent, specifically designed for intracranial use - Technical note [J].
Henkes, H ;
Flesser, A ;
Brew, S ;
Miloslavski, E ;
Doerfler, A ;
Felber, S ;
Monstadt, H ;
Kuehne, D .
INTERVENTIONAL NEURORADIOLOGY, 2003, 9 (04) :391-393
[5]   Trial design and reporting standards for intra-arterial cerebral thrombolysis for acute ischemic stroke [J].
Higashida, RT ;
Furlan, AJ .
STROKE, 2003, 34 (08) :E109-E137
[6]  
Jeffrey L, 2012, INT STROKE CONG, P2012
[7]   Good clinical outcome after ischemic stroke with successful revascularization is time-dependent [J].
Khatri, P. ;
Abruzzo, T. ;
Yeatts, S. D. ;
Nichols, C. ;
Broderick, J. P. ;
Tomsick, T. A. .
NEUROLOGY, 2009, 73 (13) :1066-1072
[8]   Early recanalization rates and clinical outcomes in patients with tandem internal carotid artery/middle cerebral artery occlusion and isolated middle cerebral artery occlusion [J].
Kim, YS ;
Garami, Z ;
Mikulik, R ;
Molina, CA ;
Alexandrov, AV .
STROKE, 2005, 36 (04) :869-871
[9]   Penumbra System: A Novel Mechanical Thrombectomy Device for Large-Vessel Occlusions in Acute Stroke [J].
Kulcsar, Z. ;
Bonvin, C. ;
Pereira, V. M. ;
Altrichter, S. ;
Yilmaz, H. ;
Loevblad, K. O. ;
Sztajzel, R. ;
Ruefenacht, D. A. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF NEURORADIOLOGY, 2010, 31 (04) :628-633
[10]   The Penumbra Pivotal Stroke Trial Safety and Effectiveness of a New Generation of Mechanical Devices for Clot Removal in Intracranial Large Vessel Occlusive Disease [J].
Langer, David ;
Alexander, Michael ;
Janardhan, Vallabh ;
Hartmann, Marius ;
Jansen, Olav ;
Sit, Siu Po ;
Yavagal, Dileep ;
Stingele, Robert ;
DeMuth, George ;
Bose, Arani ;
Clark, Wayne ;
Lutsep, Helmi ;
Barnwell, Stanley ;
Nesbit, Gary ;
Egan, Robert ;
North, Elizabeth ;
Yanase, Lisa ;
Lowenkopf, Ted ;
Petersen, Bryan ;
Grunwald, Iris Quasar ;
Mayer, Thomas ;
Doerfler, Arnd ;
Struffert, Tobias ;
Engelhorn, Tobias ;
Richter, Gregor ;
Grunwald, Iris Quasar ;
Reith, Wolfgang ;
Berkefeld, Joachim ;
Madison, Michael ;
Myers, Mark ;
Goddard, James ;
Lassig, Jeffrey ;
Lopes, Demetrius ;
Shownkeen, Harish ;
Echiverri, Henry ;
Nour, Fred ;
Mazumdar, Avi ;
Budzik, Ronald ;
Pema, Peter ;
Frei, Don ;
Huddle, Daniel ;
Bellon, Richard ;
Heck, Donald ;
Ferguson, Robert ;
McDougall, Cameron ;
Flaster, Murray ;
Frey, James ;
Albuquerque, Felipe ;
Malkoff, Marc ;
Zaidat, Osama .
STROKE, 2009, 40 (08) :2761-2768