Cost-effectiveness of caries preventive interventions - a systematic review

被引:16
作者
Davidson, Thomas [1 ,2 ]
Blomma, Caroline [1 ,3 ]
Bagesund, Mats [4 ,5 ]
Krevers, Barbro [1 ]
Vall, Martina [6 ]
Warnberg Gerdin, Elisabeth [7 ,8 ]
Tranaeus, Sofia [2 ,9 ]
机构
[1] Linkoping Univ, Dept Hlth Med & Caring Sci, Linkoping, Sweden
[2] Malmo Univ, Fac Odontol, Hlth Technol Assessment Odontol HTA O, Malmo, Sweden
[3] Linkoping Univ, Publ Dent Serv Ostergotland, Linkoping, Sweden
[4] Ctr Orthodont & Pediat Dent, Norrkoping, Sweden
[5] Linkoping Univ, Dept Biomed & Clin Sci, Linkoping, Sweden
[6] Malmo Univ, Malmo Univ Lib, Malmo, Sweden
[7] Publ Dent Hlth Serv, Odontol Res Unit, Orebro, Region Orebro, Sweden
[8] Orebro Univ, Sch Hlth & Med Sci, Orebro, Sweden
[9] Karolinska Inst, Dept Dent Med, Stockholm, Sweden
基金
瑞典研究理事会;
关键词
Caries; cost-effectiveness; economics; prevention; systematic review; DENTAL-CARIES; WATER-FLUORIDATION; PROGRAMS; SEALANTS; UTILITY;
D O I
10.1080/00016357.2020.1862293
中图分类号
R78 [口腔科学];
学科分类号
1003 ;
摘要
Objective The primary purpose of this study was to assess the cost-effectiveness of caries preventive interventions. Material and methods A systematic review was conducted, following the PRISMA Statement. Four electronic databases were searched (final search 16 March 2020). Studies fulfilling the inclusion criteria were independently critically appraised, by two reviewers in parallel. Data from each included study were extracted and tabulated: the analysis used a narrative approach to present the results of the estimated cost-effectiveness. Results and conclusions Twenty-six publications fulfilled the inclusion criteria and were of low or moderate risk of bias. Ten publications were economic evaluations, directly based on empirical studies, and the other 16 were modelling studies. Most of the studies concerned interventions for children and the most common were analyses of fluoride varnish and risk-based programs. Some of the studies showed both reduced cost and improved outcomes, but most studies reported that the improved outcome came with an additional cost. The results disclosed several cost-effectiveness evaluations of caries preventive interventions in the literature, but these target primarily children at high risk. There is a scarcity of studies specifically targeting adults and especially the elderly.
引用
收藏
页码:309 / 320
页数:12
相关论文
共 54 条
[1]   Economic evaluation of an expanded caries-preventive program targeting toddlers in high-risk areas in Sweden [J].
Anderson, Maria ;
Davidson, Thomas ;
Dahllof, Goran ;
Grindefjord, Margaret .
ACTA ODONTOLOGICA SCANDINAVICA, 2019, 77 (04) :303-309
[2]   SYSTEMATIC REVIEWS OF ECONOMIC EVALUATIONS: UTILITY OR FUTILITY? [J].
Anderson, Rob .
HEALTH ECONOMICS, 2010, 19 (03) :350-364
[3]  
Andre Kramer A., 2018, DENT CARIES SOCIOECO
[4]   Cost-Effectiveness through the Dental-Health FRAMM Guideline for Caries Prevention among 12-to 15-Year-Olds in Sweden [J].
Bergstrom, Eva-Karin ;
Davidson, Thomas ;
Skold, Ulla Moberg .
CARIES RESEARCH, 2019, 53 (03) :339-346
[5]   Cost-effectiveness simulation of a universal publicly funded sealants application program [J].
Bertrand, Elise ;
Mallis, Majid ;
Bui, Nguyen Minh ;
Reinharz, Daniel .
JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH DENTISTRY, 2011, 71 (01) :38-45
[6]   Seal or Varnish? A randomised controlled trial to determine the relative cost and effectiveness of pit and fissure sealant and fluoride varnish in preventing dental decay [J].
Chestnutt, Ivor Gordon ;
Hutchings, Simon ;
Playle, Rebecca ;
Morgan-Trimmer, Sarah ;
Fitzsimmons, Deborah ;
Aawar, Nadine ;
Angel, Lianna ;
Derrick, Sharron ;
Drew, Cheney ;
Hoddell, Ceri ;
Hood, Kerenza ;
Humphreys, Ioan ;
Kirby, Nigel ;
Lau, Tin Man Mandy ;
Lisles, Catherine ;
Morgan, Maria Zeta ;
Murphy, Simon ;
Nuttall, Jacqueline ;
Onishchenko, Kateryna ;
Phillips, Ceri ;
Pickles, Timothy ;
Scoble, Charlotte ;
Townson, Julia ;
Withers, Beverley ;
Chadwick, Barbara Lesley .
HEALTH TECHNOLOGY ASSESSMENT, 2017, 21 (21) :1-+
[7]   Cost-Effectiveness of Pit-and-Fissure Sealants on Primary Molars in Medicaid-Enrolled Children [J].
Chi, Donald L. ;
van der Goes, David N. ;
Ney, John P. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH, 2014, 104 (03) :555-561
[8]   A Systematic Review of Socioeconomic Indicators and Dental Caries in Adults [J].
Costa, Simone M. ;
Martins, Carolina C. ;
Bonfim, Maria de Lourdes C. ;
Zina, Livia G. ;
Paiva, Saul M. ;
Pordeus, Isabela A. ;
Abreu, Mauro H. N. G. .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL RESEARCH AND PUBLIC HEALTH, 2012, 9 (10) :3540-3574
[9]  
Drummond MF, 2015, Methods for the Economic Evaluation of Health Care Programmes
[10]   What evidence do economic evaluations in dental care provide? A scoping review [J].
Eow, J. ;
Duane, B. ;
Solaiman, A. ;
Hussain, U. ;
Lemasney, N. ;
Ang, R. ;
O'Kelly-Lynch, N. ;
Girgis, G. ;
Collazo, L. ;
Johnston, B. .
COMMUNITY DENTAL HEALTH, 2019, 36 (02) :118-+