The Effects of Regular Cold-Water Immersion Use on Training-Induced Changes in Strength and Endurance Performance: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis

被引:33
作者
Malta, Elvis S. [1 ]
Dutra, Yago M. [1 ]
Broatch, James R. [2 ,3 ]
Bishop, David J. [2 ]
Zagatto, Alessandro M. [1 ]
机构
[1] Sao Paulo State Univ UNESP, Dept Phys Educ, Lab Physiol & Sport Performance LAFIDE, Postgrad Program Movement Sci,Sch Sci, Av Eng Luiz Edmundo Coube 14-01, BR-17033360 Bauru, SP, Brazil
[2] Victoria Univ, Inst Hlth & Sport iHeS, Footscray, Vic, Australia
[3] Australia Inst Sport, Bruce, ACT, Australia
基金
巴西圣保罗研究基金会;
关键词
CUTANEOUS BLOOD-FLOW; MUSCLE DAMAGE; EXERCISE PERFORMANCE; RUNNING PERFORMANCE; MUSCULAR STRENGTH; RECOVERY; ADAPTATIONS; EXPRESSION; DETERMINANTS; TEMPERATURE;
D O I
10.1007/s40279-020-01362-0
中图分类号
G8 [体育];
学科分类号
04 ; 0403 ;
摘要
Background Cold-water immersion (CWI) is one of the main recovery methods used in sports, and is commonly utilized as a means to expedite the recovery of performance during periods of exercise training. In recent decades, there have been indications that regular CWI use is potentially harmful to resistance training adaptations, and, conversely, potentially beneficial to endurance training adaptations. The current meta-analysis was conducted to assess the effects of the regular CWI use during exercise training on resistance (i.e., strength) and endurance (i.e., aerobic exercise) performance alterations. Methods A computerized literature search was conducted, ending on November 25, 2019. The databases searched were MEDLINE, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and SPORTDiscus. The selected studies investigated the effects of chronic CWI interventions associated with resistance and endurance training sessions on exercise performance improvements. The criteria for inclusion of studies were: (1) being a controlled investigation; (2) conducted with humans; (3) CWI performed at <= 15 degrees C; (4) being associated with a regular training program; and (5) having performed baseline and post-training assessments. Results Eight articles were included before the review process. A harmful effect of CWI associated with resistance training was verified for one-repetition maximum, maximum isometric strength, and strength endurance performance (overall standardized mean difference [SMD] = - 0.60; Confidence interval of 95% [CI95%] = - 0.87, - 0.33; p < 0.0001), as well as for Ballistic efforts performance (overall SMD = - 0.61; CI95% = - 1.11, - 0.11; p = 0.02). On the other hand, selected studies verified no effect of CWI associated with endurance training on time-trial (mean power), maximal aerobic power in graded exercise test performance (overall SMD = - 0.07; CI95% = - 0.54, 0.53; p = 0.71), or time-trial performance (duration) (overall SMD = 0.00; CI95% = - 0.58, 0.58; p = 1.00). Conclusions The regular use of CWI associated with exercise programs has a deleterious effect on resistance training adaptations but does not appear to affect aerobic exercise performance. Background Cold-water immersion (CWI) is one of the main recovery methods used in sports, and is commonly utilized as a means to expedite the recovery of performance during periods of exercise training. In recent decades, there have been indications that regular CWI use is potentially harmful to resistance training adaptations, and, conversely, potentially beneficial to endurance training adaptations. The current meta-analysis was conducted to assess the effects of the regular CWI use during exercise training on resistance (i.e., strength) and endurance (i.e., aerobic exercise) performance alterations. Methods A computerized literature search was conducted, ending on November 25, 2019. The databases searched were MEDLINE, Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, and SPORTDiscus. The selected studies investigated the effects of chronic CWI interventions associated with resistance and endurance training sessions on exercise performance improvements. The criteria for inclusion of studies were: (1) being a controlled investigation; (2) conducted with humans; (3) CWI performed at <= 15 degrees C; (4) being associated with a regular training program; and (5) having performed baseline and post-training assessments. Results Eight articles were included before the review process.A harmful effect of CWI associated with resistance training was verified for one-repetition maximum, maximum isometric strength, and strength endurance performance (overall standardized mean difference [SMD] = - 0.60; Confidence interval of 95% [CI95%] = - 0.87, - 0.33; p < 0.0001), as well as for Ballistic efforts performance (overall SMD = - 0.61; CI95% = - 1.11, - 0.11; p = 0.02). On the other hand, selected studies verified no effect of CWI associated with endurance training on time-trial (mean power), maximal aerobic power in graded exercise test performance (overall SMD = - 0.07; CI95% = - 0.54, 0.53; p = 0.71), or time-trial performance (duration) (overall SMD = 0.00; CI95% = - 0.58, 0.58; p = 1.00). Conclusions The regular use of CWI associated with exercise programs has a deleterious effect on resistance training adaptations but does not appear to affect aerobic exercise performance. [GRAPHICS]
引用
收藏
页码:161 / 174
页数:14
相关论文
共 66 条
[1]   Recovery From Exercise-Induced Muscle Damage: Cold-Water Immersion Versus Whole-Body Cryotherapy [J].
Abaidia, Abd-Elbasset ;
Lamblin, Julien ;
Delecroix, Barthelemy ;
Leduc, Cedric ;
McCall, Alan ;
Nedelec, Mathieu ;
Dawson, Brian ;
Baquet, Georges ;
Dupont, Gregory .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SPORTS PHYSIOLOGY AND PERFORMANCE, 2017, 12 (03) :402-409
[2]   Post-exercise cold water immersion does not alter high intensity interval training-induced exercise performance and Hsp72 responses, but enhances mitochondrial markers [J].
Aguiar, Paula Fernandes ;
Magalhaes, Silvia Mourao ;
Teixeira Fonseca, Ivana Alice ;
da Costa Santos, Vanessa Batista ;
de Matos, Mariana Aguiar ;
Dias Peixoto, Marco Fabricio ;
Nakamura, Fabio Yuzo ;
Crandall, Craig ;
Araujo, Hygor Nunes ;
Silveira, Leonardo Reis ;
Rocha-Vieira, Etel ;
Magalhaes, Flavio de Castro ;
Amorim, Fabiano Trigueiro .
CELL STRESS & CHAPERONES, 2016, 21 (05) :793-804
[3]   Postexercise cold water immersion modulates skeletal muscle PGC-1α mRNA expression in immersed and nonimmersed limbs: evidence of systemic regulation [J].
Allan, Robert ;
Sharples, Adam P. ;
Close, Graeme L. ;
Drust, Barry ;
Shepherd, Sam O. ;
Dutton, John ;
Morton, James P. ;
Gregson, Warren .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSIOLOGY, 2017, 123 (02) :451-459
[4]   Effects of cold water immersion on the recovery of physical performance and muscle damage following a one-off soccer match [J].
Ascensao, Antonio ;
Leite, Marco ;
Rebelo, Antonio N. ;
Magalhaees, Sergio ;
Magalhaees, Jose .
JOURNAL OF SPORTS SCIENCES, 2011, 29 (03) :217-225
[5]   Limiting factors for maximum oxygen uptake and determinants of endurance performance [J].
Bassett, DR ;
Howley, ET .
MEDICINE AND SCIENCE IN SPORTS AND EXERCISE, 2000, 32 (01) :70-84
[6]   The Influence of Post-Exercise Cold-Water Immersion on Adaptive Responses to Exercise: A Review of the Literature [J].
Broatch, James R. ;
Petersen, Aaron ;
Bishop, David J. .
SPORTS MEDICINE, 2018, 48 (06) :1369-1387
[7]   Cold-water immersion following sprint interval training does not alter endurance signaling pathways or training adaptations in human skeletal muscle [J].
Broatch, James R. ;
Petersen, Aaron ;
Bishop, David J. .
AMERICAN JOURNAL OF PHYSIOLOGY-REGULATORY INTEGRATIVE AND COMPARATIVE PHYSIOLOGY, 2017, 313 (04) :R372-R384
[8]   Postexercise Cold Water Immersion Benefits Are Not Greater than the Placebo Effect [J].
Broatch, James R. ;
Petersen, Aaron ;
Bishop, David J. .
MEDICINE AND SCIENCE IN SPORTS AND EXERCISE, 2014, 46 (11) :2139-2147
[9]  
Brophy-Williams N, 2011, J SPORT SCI MED, V10, P665
[10]   THE PROBLEM OF MUSCLE HYPERTROPHY: REVISITED [J].
Buckner, Samuel L. ;
Dankel, Scott J. ;
Mattocks, Kevin T. ;
Jessee, Matthew B. ;
Mouser, J. Grant ;
Counts, Brittany R. ;
Loenneke, Jeremy P. .
MUSCLE & NERVE, 2016, 54 (06) :1012-1014