"Pregnancy Is Not a Disease" Conscientious Refusal and the Argument from Concepts

被引:2
作者
Brudney, Daniel [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637 USA
关键词
INTERNAL MORALITY; MEDICINE;
D O I
10.1002/hast.357
中图分类号
B82 [伦理学(道德学)];
学科分类号
摘要
In many American states, a health care worker has a legal right to immunity from employer sanction if she refuses to perform actions at odds with her conscience: she has a legal right to accommodation of her conscientious beliefs. A number of arguments have been advanced to defend or reject this right. These have tended to focus on the possibly conflicting interests of the health care worker and the patient. Recently, however, a new argument has been proposed to justify immunity from employer sanction. This argument rests on the premise that the scope of the very concepts of medicine and disease circumscribes the scope of proper medical practice. Procedures and activities that fall outside the scope of medicine and disease are not properly within the brief of health care personnel.This argument is important because, in principle, it stands outside the balancing of interests. Its central claim is nonsectariannamely, that a person ought to do her job but need not do what is not her job. This claim avoids taking any stand in the culture wars. It is merely a claim about the logic of the concept professional. The medical professional who refuses to perform a procedure is not asking for special treatment. On the contrary, she is asking to be treated normallyin accordance with the normal contours of her job.Of course, other arguments also seek to justify health care providers' immunity from employer sanction. Ultimately, these different arguments need to be prized apart and scrutinized one by one. This essay focuses on the argument from the concepts of medicine and disease, as a down payment on that larger project.
引用
收藏
页码:43 / 49
页数:7
相关论文
共 20 条
  • [11] Lyons D., 1965, FORMS AND LIMITS OF
  • [12] The internal morality of medicine: An evolutionary perspective
    Miller, FG
    Brody, H
    [J]. JOURNAL OF MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY, 2001, 26 (06): : 581 - 599
  • [13] Morice-Brubaker S., PREGNANCY IS NOT A D
  • [14] Murphy D., THE STANFORD ENCYCLO
  • [15] The internal morality of clinical medicine: A paradigm for the ethics of the helping and healing professions
    Pellegrino, ED
    [J]. JOURNAL OF MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY, 2001, 26 (06): : 559 - 579
  • [16] Rawls J., 1971, THEORY JUSTICE, DOI DOI 10.4159/9780674042605
  • [17] Sawicki Nadia., 2012, Cardozo Law Review, V33, P1389
  • [18] SMART JJC, 1973, UTILITARIANISM FOR A
  • [19] What is conscience and why is respect for it so important?
    Sulmasy, Daniel P.
    [J]. THEORETICAL MEDICINE AND BIOETHICS, 2008, 29 (03) : 135 - 149
  • [20] Wicclair M. R., 2011, CONSCIENTIOUS OBJECT, P13