Molecular dynamics ensemble refinement of the heterogeneous native state of NCBD using chemical shifts and NOEs

Many proteins display complex dynamical properties that are often intimately linked to their biological functions. As the native state of a protein is best described as an ensemble of conformations, it is important to be able to generate models of native state ensembles with high accuracy. Due to limitations in sampling efficiency and force field accuracy it is, however, challenging to obtain accurate ensembles of protein conformations by the use of molecular simulations alone. Here we show that dynamic ensemble refinement, which combines an accurate atomistic force field with commonly available nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) chemical shifts and NOEs, can provide a detailed and accurate description of the conformational ensemble of the native state of a highly dynamic protein. As both NOEs and chemical shifts are averaged on timescales up to milliseconds, the resulting ensembles reflect the structural heterogeneity that goes beyond that probed, e.g., by NMR relaxation order parameters. We selected the small protein domain NCBD as object of our study since this protein, which has been characterized experimentally in substantial detail, displays a rich and complex dynamical behaviour. In particular, the protein has been described as having a molten-globule like structure, but with a relatively rigid core. Our approach allowed us to describe the conformational dynamics of NCBD in solution, and to probe the structural heterogeneity resulting from both short-and long-time scale dynamics by the calculation of order parameters on different time scales. These results illustrate the usefulness of our approach since they show that NCBD is rather rigid on the nanosecond timescale, but interconverts within a broader ensemble on longer timescales, thus enabling the derivation of a coherent set of conclusions from various NMR experiments on this protein, which could otherwise appear in contradiction with each other.