Math Disabilities and Reading Disabilities Can They Be Separated?

This article synthesizes some of the published literature that selectively compares the cognitive functioning of children with math disabilities (MDs) with average-achieving children and poor readers (children with reading disabilities [RDs] or comorbid disabilities [RDs + MDs]). All studies in the synthesis report reading, IQ, and math scores for children with MDs and poor readers. A random coefficients model of effect sizes (ESs) show that (a) ESs between MD and normal achievers were moderated by variations in working memory and literacy, (b) ESs between MD- and RD-only children were moderated by working memory and problem solving, and (c) ESs between MD and MD + RD children were moderated by long-term memory and IQ scores. No support was found for the notion that the differentiation between MD children and poor readers (RD and MD + RD) was related to variations in reading across the reviewed studies.