Interruptions during general practice consultations: negative impact on physicians, and patients' indifference

被引:4
作者
Santos, Catarina Neves [1 ,2 ]
Pedrosa, Bruno Ferreira [1 ]
Martins, Marilia [1 ]
Gouveia, Fabio [1 ]
Franco, Fatima [1 ]
Vardasca, Margarida Joao [1 ]
Pedro, Bernardo [1 ]
Nogueira, Jorge Domingues [1 ]
机构
[1] USF Ramada, ACeS Loures Odivelas ARSLVT, Lisbon, Portugal
[2] USF Ramada, ACeS Loures Odivelas ARSLVT, Rua 25 Agosto, P-2620257 Ramada, Portugal
关键词
efficiency; organizational; general practitioners; patient safety; patient satisfaction; physician-patient relations; physicians; primary care; primary health care; referral and consultation; risk management; time management; WORKFLOW INTERRUPTIONS; CARE; ERRORS; HOSPITALS; SAFETY;
D O I
10.1093/fampra/cmac129
中图分类号
R1 [预防医学、卫生学];
学科分类号
1004 ; 120402 ;
摘要
Background Interruptions can impact consultation duration, doctors and patients' satisfaction, and quality of care provided. Although most of them seem to have a negative impact, affecting doctor-patient relationship and interfering with clinical reasoning, which increases the risk of error, there is still no evidence on their global impact on consultations. Objectives To evaluate the number and duration of interruptions during general practice consultations. To compare physicians and patients' perceptions of their urgency and impact, as well as the overall satisfaction with the consultation. Methods Cross-sectional study of a representative sample of annual face-to-face general practice consultations at a Health Centre. Between January and March 2022, anonymous questionnaires were given to physicians and patients after consultation. We performed a descriptive and inferential statistical analysis. Results A total of 403 consultations were included. Physicians reported more interruptions than patients (108 vs. 87, P < 0.001). From patients' perspective those interruptions were more urgent (34.5%) compared with physicians' perspective (20.6%; P = 0.029). Patients undervalued their impact on consultations (7.1% of interruptions with a negative impact among patients vs. 24.7% among doctors; P < 0.001). Interruptions did not interfere with patients' satisfaction with consultation (P = 0.135) but were associated with lower physicians' satisfaction with consultation (P = 0.003). Conclusion Physicians are more critical regarding consultations interruptions, being more aware of their incidence and reporting more often a negative impact, which translates into lower satisfaction with interrupted consultations. Patients devalue the occurrence of interruptions, showing no concern about their impact on security or privacy, and their satisfaction is not affected by them. Lay Summary Interruptions during consultations can impact their duration, doctors and patients' satisfaction, and the quality of care provided. This study aims to evaluate the number and duration of consultation interruptions, to compare physicians and patients' perceptions of their urgency and impact, as well as the overall satisfaction with the consultation. For that, 403 face-to-face general practice consultations were analysed through anonymous questionnaires given to doctors and patients after each consultation. Physicians were more critical regarding the consultation's interruptions, being more aware of their incidence and reporting more often a negative impact. This translated into a lower satisfaction with the consultation where an interruption occurred. Therefore, interruptions seemed to increase physicians stress and dissatisfaction, which may represent a risk factor for burnout and jeopardize patient safety. On the other hand, patients seemed not to be aware of the possible impact of interruptions during consultations. They not only devalued their occurrence, showing no concern about possible impact on their security or privacy, but also their satisfaction with the consultation was not affected by them.
引用
收藏
页码:494 / 500
页数:7
相关论文
共 27 条
[1]   Interruptions in emergency department work: an observational and interview study [J].
Berg, Lena M. ;
Kallberg, Ann-Sofie ;
Goransson, Katarina E. ;
Ostergren, Jan ;
Florin, Jan ;
Ehrenberg, Anna .
BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY, 2013, 22 (08) :656-663
[2]   PHYSICIAN, INTERRUPTED: WORKFLOW INTERRUPTIONS AND PATIENT CARE IN THE EMERGENCY DEPARTMENT [J].
Blocker, Renaldo C. ;
Heaton, Heather A. ;
Forsyth, Katherine L. ;
Hawthorne, Hunter J. ;
El-Sherif, Nibras ;
Bellolio, M. Fernanda ;
Nestler, David M. ;
Hellmich, Thomas R. ;
Pasupathy, Kalyan S. ;
Hallbeck, M. Susan .
JOURNAL OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2017, 53 (06) :798-804
[3]   Work interrupted: A comparison of workplace interruptions in emergency departments and primary care offices [J].
Chisholm, CD ;
Dornfeld, AM ;
Nelson, DR ;
Cordell, WH .
ANNALS OF EMERGENCY MEDICINE, 2001, 38 (02) :146-151
[4]   The impact of interruptions on the duration of nursing interventions: a direct observation study in an academic emergency department [J].
Cole, Gai ;
Stefanus, Dicky ;
Gardner, Heather ;
Levy, Matthew J. ;
Klein, Eili Y. .
BMJ QUALITY & SAFETY, 2016, 25 (06) :457-465
[5]   Interruptions during general practice consultations - The patients' view [J].
Dearden, A ;
Smithers, M ;
Thapar, A .
FAMILY PRACTICE, 1996, 13 (02) :166-169
[6]   Interruptions in healthcare: Theoretical views [J].
Grundgeiger, Tobias ;
Sanderson, Penelope .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INFORMATICS, 2009, 78 (05) :293-307
[7]   Interruptions and Pediatric Patient Safety [J].
Hall, Linda McGillis ;
Pedersen, Cheryl ;
Hubley, Pam ;
Ptack, Elana ;
Hemingway, Aislinn ;
Watson, Carolyn ;
Keatings, Margaret .
JOURNAL OF PEDIATRIC NURSING-NURSING CARE OF CHILDREN & FAMILIES, 2010, 25 (03) :167-175
[8]   Going blank: factors contributing to interruptions to nurses' work and related outcomes [J].
Hall, Linda McGillis ;
Ferguson-Pare, Mary ;
Peter, Elizabeth ;
White, Debbie ;
Besner, Jeanne ;
Chisholm, Anne ;
Ferris, Ella ;
Fryers, Marla ;
Macleod, Martha ;
Mildon, Barb ;
Pedersen, Cheryl ;
Hemingway, Aislinn .
JOURNAL OF NURSING MANAGEMENT, 2010, 18 (08) :1040-1047
[9]   Losing the Moment Understanding Interruptions to Nurses' Work [J].
Hall, Linda McGillis ;
Pedersen, Cheryl ;
Fairley, Laura .
JOURNAL OF NURSING ADMINISTRATION, 2010, 40 (04) :169-176
[10]   International variations in primary care physician consultation time: a systematic review of 67 countries [J].
Irving, Greg ;
Neves, Ana Luisa ;
Dambha-Miller, Hajira ;
Oishi, Ai ;
Tagashira, Hiroko ;
Verho, Anastasiya ;
Holden, John .
BMJ OPEN, 2017, 7 (10)