Development of symptoms caused by Erwinia carotovora ssp atroseptica under field conditions and their effects on the yield of individual potato plants

Infection of seed tubers by pectinolytic Erwinia species can lead to the development of various symptoms during vegetative growth of potato crops, including non-emergence of plants, chlorosis, wilting, haulm desiccation and typical blackleg. The relationships between types of symptoms and yield are poorly documented, and are investigated by following the development of symptoms in potato plants grown under field conditions from seed tubers artificially inoculated with E. carotovora ssp. atroseptica (Eca), and measuring the yield of each plant. Symptoms were classified into five main types (non-emergence, wilting/chlorosis, blackleg, haulm desiccation and plant death). Each plant was scored for types of symptom on four successive dates; plants without visible symptoms were scored as healthy. The method of inoculation and inoculum concentration proved major factors for the subsequent development of symptoms. Disease development was more severe after vacuum infiltration of bacteria into seed tubers than after shaking tubers in contaminated sand. Disease usually progressed from chlorosis and/or wilting to partial or total desiccation on a given plant. Yield losses varied according to symptom type, but the relationship between symptoms recorded and yield also depended on scoring dates. The data suggest that the beginning of tuber growth might be the most suitable stage for predicting yield losses from symptom observations. In both cultivars studied (Bintje, highly susceptible, and Desiree, moderately resistant), the yield of symptomless plants growing from inoculated seed tubers was significantly less than that of control plants, indicating that the presence of bacteria on the seed tuber was detrimental, even in the absence of visible symptoms. Differences in symptom expression in the field between cultivars matched the level of visible infection of tubers at harvest, as Bintje tubers showed a higher incidence of rot than Desiree tubers.