Assessment of asymmetrical rheological behavior of cementitious material for 3D printing application

Among the multiplicity of construction methods based on digital concrete technologies, the most common one remains the extrusion-based process. Two opposed strategies have been developed in order to print a concrete structure using extrusion: the first one emphasizes the ease-of-pumping of material which is massively accelerated to ensure the stability of the structure, when leaving the extruder; the second one uses a firm mortar able to sustain the own weight of the structure during the printing, without requiring any accelerator. Both methods have their pros and cons and don't imply the same rheological requirements. Most of the recent literature assumes that both types of material (fluid and firm) follow the same trend of behavior and obey to the Von Mises plasticity criterion, while it has been demonstrated that firm cement-based materials can exhibit a pressure dependent behavior. Moreover, rheological study is mainly based on shear rheometry, while the extrusion-based printing process requires a description of the rheological behavior in compression to predict the global stability of the structure, and in tension to prevent cracks formation. This paper investigates the fresh behavior of cement paste and mortar under different solicitations (shear, compression, tension) for different water to cement ratios. The analysis of these results allows to describe the transition between a ductile fluid material (symmetrical in tension and compression) that obeys to a Von Mises plasticity criterion, and a brittle and firm material (asymmetrical in tension and compression) that requires a pressure dependent plasticity criterion in order to predict its strength under a given solicitation.