Metamorphic evolution, mineral chemistry and thermobarometry of schists and orthogneisses hosting ultra-high pressure eclogites in the Dabieshan of central China

As is typical of ultra-high pressure (UHP) terrains, the regional extent of the UHP terrain in the Dabieshan of central China is highly speculative, since the volume of eclogites and paragneisses preserving unequivocal evidence of coesite and/or diamond stability is very small. By contrast, the common garnet (X-Mn = 0.18-0.45)-phengite (Si = 3.2-3.35)-zoned epidote (Ps(38-97))-biotite-titanite-two feldspars-quartz assemblages in the more extensive orthogneisses have been previously thought to have formed under low P-T conditions of ca. 400 +/- 50 degrees C at 4 kbar, However, certain orthogneiss samples preserve garnets with X-Ca up to 0.50, rutile inclusions within titanite or epidote and relict phengite inclusions within epidote with Si contents p.f.u. of up to 3.49 - overlapping with the highest values (3.49-3.62) recorded for phengites in samples of undoubted UHP schists. These and other mineral composition features (such as A-site deficiencies in the highest Si phengites, Na in garnets linked to Y + Yb substitution and Al F Ti-1 O-1 substitution in titanites) are taken to be pointers towards the orthogneisses having experienced a similar metamorphic evolution to the associated UHP schists and eclogites. Re-evaluated garnet-phengite and garnet-biotite Fe/Mg exchange thermometry and calculated 5 rutile + 3 grossular + 2SiO(2) + H2O = 5 titanite + 2 zoisite equilibria indicate that the orthogneisses may indeed have followed a common subduction-related clockwise P-T path with the UHP paragneisses and eclogites through conditions of P-max at ca. 690 degrees C-715 degrees C and 36 kbar to T-max at ca. 710 degrees C-755 degrees C and 18 kbar, prior to extensive re-crystallisation and re-equilibration of these ductile orthogneisses at ca. 400 degrees C-450 degrees C and 6 kbar. The consequential conclusion, that it is no longer necessary to resort to models of tectonic juxtapositioning to explain the spatial association of these Dabieshan orthogneisses with undoubted UHP lithologies. has far-reaching implications for the interpretation of controversial gneiss-eclogite relationships in other UHP metamorphic terrains. (C) 2000 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.