Effects of tDCS on motor learning and memory formation: A consensus and critical position paper

被引:242
作者
Buch, Ethan R. [1 ]
Santarnecchi, Emiliano [2 ]
Antal, Andrea [3 ]
Born, Jan [4 ,5 ]
Celnik, Pablo A. [6 ,7 ]
Classen, Joseph [8 ]
Gerloff, Christian [9 ]
Hallett, Mark [10 ]
Hummel, Friedhelm C. [9 ]
Nitsche, Michael A. [11 ]
Pascual-Leone, Alvaro [2 ]
Paulus, Walter J. [3 ]
Reis, Janine [12 ]
Robertson, Edwin M. [13 ]
Rothwell, John C. [14 ]
Sandrini, Marco [15 ]
Schambra, Heidi M. [16 ]
Wassermann, Eric M. [17 ]
Ziemann, Ulf [18 ]
Cohen, Leonardo G. [1 ]
机构
[1] Natl Inst Hlth, Natl Inst Neurol Disorders & Stroke, Human Cort Physiol & Neurorehabilitat Sect, BG 10 RM 7D54 MSC 1428,10 Ctr, Bethesda, MD 20892 USA
[2] Harvard Med Sch, Beth Israel Med Ctr, Dept Neurol, Div Cognit Neurol,Berenson Allen Ctr Non Invas, Boston, MA USA
[3] Georg August Univ, Univ Med Ctr, Dept Clin Neurophysiol, Gottingen, Germany
[4] Univ Tubingen, Inst Med Psychol, Behav Neurobiol, Tubingen, Germany
[5] Univ Tubingen, Ctr Integrat Neurosci, Tubingen, Germany
[6] Johns Hopkins Med Inst, Dept Phys Med & Rehabil, Baltimore, MD USA
[7] Johns Hopkins Med Inst, Dept Neurosci, Baltimore, MD USA
[8] Univ Leipzig, Dept Neurol, Leipzig, Germany
[9] Univ Med Ctr Hamburg Eppendorf, Dept Neurol, Brain Imaging & NeuroStimulat BINS Lab, Hamburg, Germany
[10] Natl Inst Neurol Disorders & Stroke, Human Motor Control Sect, Bethesda, MD USA
[11] Dept Psychol & Neurosci, Leibniz Res Ctr Working Environm & Human Factors, Dortmund, Germany
[12] Albert Ludwigs Univ, Dept Neurol, Freiburg, Germany
[13] Univ Glasgow, Inst Neurosci & Psychol, Glasgow, Lanark, Scotland
[14] UCL Inst Neurol, Queen Sq, London, England
[15] Univ Roehampton, Dept Psychol, London, England
[16] Columbia Univ, Dept Rehabil & Regenerat Med, New York, NY USA
[17] Natl Inst Hlth, Natl Inst Neurol Disorders & Stroke, Behav Neurol Unit, Bethesda, MD USA
[18] Eberhard Karls Univ Tubingen, Hertie Inst Clin Brain Res, Dept Neurol Stroke, Tubingen, Germany
关键词
tDCS; Non-invasive brain stimulation; Motor; Learning; Memory; Open Science; Effect-size; Guidelines; DIRECT-CURRENT STIMULATION; TRANSCRANIAL MAGNETIC STIMULATION; NONINVASIVE BRAIN-STIMULATION; MEP AMPLITUDE-MODULATION; INDUCED MOVEMENT THERAPY; HEALTHY-HUMAN SUBJECTS; PREMOTOR CORTEX; CHRONIC STROKE; CORTICAL EXCITABILITY; SKILL ACQUISITION;
D O I
10.1016/j.clinph.2017.01.004
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Motor skills are required for activities of daily living. Transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS) applied in association with motor skill learning has been investigated as a tool for enhancing training effects in health and disease. Here, we review the published literature investigating whether tDCS can facilitate the acquisition, retention or adaptation of motor skills. Work in multiple laboratories is under-way to develop a mechanistic understanding of tDCS effects on different forms of learning and to optimize stimulation protocols. Efforts are required to improve reproducibility and standardization. Overall, reproducibility remains to be fully tested, effect sizes with present techniques vary over a wide range, and the basis of observed inter-individual variability in tDCS effects is incompletely understood. It is recommended that future studies explicitly state in the Methods the exploratory (hypothesis-generating) or hypothesis-driven (confirmatory) nature of the experimental designs. General research practices could be improved with prospective pre-registration of hypothesis-based investigations, more emphasis on the detailed description of methods (including all pertinent details to enable future modeling of induced current and experimental replication), and use of post-publication open data repositories. A checklist is proposed for reporting tDCS investigations in a way that can improve efforts to assess reproducibility. (C) 2017 Published by Elsevier Ireland Ltd on behalf of International Federation of Clinical Neurophysiology.
引用
收藏
页码:589 / 603
页数:15
相关论文
共 171 条
[1]   Reward Improves Long-Term Retention of a Motor Memory through Induction of Offline Memory Gains [J].
Abe, Mitsunari ;
Schambra, Heidi ;
Wassermann, Eric M. ;
Luckenbaugh, Dave ;
Schweighofer, Nicolas ;
Cohen, Leonardo G. .
CURRENT BIOLOGY, 2011, 21 (07) :557-562
[2]   The Homeostatic Interaction Between Anodal Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation and Motor Learning in Humans is Related to GABAA Activity [J].
Amadi, Ugwechi ;
Allman, Claire ;
Johansen-Berg, Heidi ;
Stagg, Charlotte J. .
BRAIN STIMULATION, 2015, 8 (05) :898-905
[3]   Monitoring transcranial direct current stimulation induced changes in cortical excitability during the serial reaction time task [J].
Ambrus, Geza Gergely ;
Chaieb, Leila ;
Stilling, Roman ;
Rothkegel, Holger ;
Antal, Andrea ;
Paulus, Walter .
NEUROSCIENCE LETTERS, 2016, 616 :98-104
[4]   Response to Comment on "Estimating the reproducibility of psychological science" [J].
Anderson, Christopher J. ;
Bahnik, Stepan ;
Barnett-Cowan, Michael ;
Bosco, Frank A. ;
Chandler, Jesse ;
Chartier, Christopher R. ;
Cheung, Felix ;
Christopherson, Cody D. ;
Cordes, Andreas ;
Cremata, Edward J. ;
Della Penna, Nicolas ;
Estel, Vivien ;
Fedor, Anna ;
Fitneva, Stanka A. ;
Frank, Michael C. ;
Grange, James A. ;
Hartshorne, Joshua K. ;
Hasselman, Fred ;
Henninger, Felix ;
van der Hulst, Marije ;
Jonas, Kai J. ;
Lai, Calvin K. ;
Levitan, Carmel A. ;
Miller, Jeremy K. ;
Moore, Katherine S. ;
Meixner, Johannes M. ;
Munafo, Marcus R. ;
Neijenhuijs, Koen I. ;
Nilsonne, Gustav ;
Nosek, Brian A. ;
Plessow, Franziska ;
Prenoveau, Jason M. ;
Ricker, Ashley A. ;
Schmidt, Kathleen ;
Spies, Jeffrey R. ;
Stieger, Stefan ;
Strohminger, Nina ;
Sullivan, Gavin B. ;
van Aert, Robbie C. M. ;
van Assen, Marcel A. L. M. ;
Vanpaemel, Wolf ;
Vianello, Michelangelo ;
Voracek, Martin ;
Zuni, Kellylynn .
SCIENCE, 2016, 351 (6277)
[5]   Conceptual and Procedural Shortcomings of the Systematic Review "Evidence That Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation (tDCS) Generates Little-to-no Reliable Neurophysiologic Effect Beyond MEP Amplitude Modulation in Healthy Human Subjects: A Systematic Review" by Horvath and Co-workers [J].
Antal, A. ;
Keeser, D. ;
Priori, A. ;
Padberg, F. ;
Nitsche, M. A. .
BRAIN STIMULATION, 2015, 8 (04) :846-849
[6]   Facilitation of visuo-motor learning by transcranial direct current stimulation of the motor and extrastriate visual areas in humans [J].
Antal, A ;
Nitsche, MA ;
Kincses, TZ ;
Kruse, W ;
Hoffmann, KP ;
Paulus, W .
EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF NEUROSCIENCE, 2004, 19 (10) :2888-2892
[7]   Prior state of cortical activity influences subsequent practicing of a visuomotor coordination task [J].
Antal, Andrea ;
Begemeier, Silva ;
Nitsche, Michael A. ;
Paulus, Walter .
NEUROPSYCHOLOGIA, 2008, 46 (13) :3157-3161
[8]   Cerebellar Transcranial Direct Current Stimulation Effects on Saccade Adaptation [J].
Avila, Eric ;
van der Geest, Jos N. ;
Kamga, Sandra Kengne ;
Verhage, M. Claire ;
Donchin, Opher ;
Frens, Maarten A. .
NEURAL PLASTICITY, 2015, 2015
[9]   Modulation of GABA and resting state functional connectivity by transcranial direct current stimulation [J].
Bachtiar, Velicia ;
Near, Jamie ;
Johansen-Berg, Heidi ;
Stagg, Charlotte J. .
ELIFE, 2015, 4
[10]   Within-session repeated a-tDCS: The effects of repetition rate and inter-stimulus interval on corticospinal excitability and motor performance [J].
Bastani, A. ;
Jaberzadeh, S. .
CLINICAL NEUROPHYSIOLOGY, 2014, 125 (09) :1809-1818