Cartilage tympanoplasty for management of tympanic membrane atelectasis: Is ventilatory tube necessary?

Objectives: Cartilage/perichondrium composite graft with concomitant placement of a ventilation tube is a common practice among otologists to reverse atelectasis and to repneumatize the middle ear. We conducted this study to investigate the necessity of a ventilation tube primarily incorporated into the perichondrium/cartilage graft for reconstruction of the atelectatic tympanic membrane (TM). Study Design: Prospective clinical trial. Methods: Forty-six patients with TM atelectasis and intact ossicular chain were randomized to 2 groups. In Group 1, 23 patients underwent reconstruction of the TM with perichondrium/cartilage graft and intraoperative T-tube insertion and in Group 11, 23 patients underwent reconstruction of the TM with perichondrium/cartilage graft without ventilation tube insertion. Outcome measures were as follows: graft success, improvement of hearing, and postoperative complications. Analysis of the results was performed by Student's paired t test. The level of significance was set at 5%. Results: Significant postoperative improvement of pure-tone air-conduction threshold averages and air-bone gap averages were reported in the 2 studied groups (p < 0.001). The postoperative air-bone gap averages showed no statistically significant difference between Groups I and II (p > 0.05). Conductive hearing loss requiring revision developed in 2 patients (8.69%) in Group I and in 3 patients (13%) in Group II. Conclusion: In the atelectatic ear, cartilage allowed reconstruction of the TM with good anatomical and functional results. Primary insertion of a ventilation tube into the graft is not necessary.