Are ergonomically designed road signs more easily learned?

被引:14
作者
Ben-Bassat, Tamar [1 ]
机构
[1] SCE, Dept Ind Engn & Management, 84 Jabotinski St, IL-77245 Ashdod, Israel
关键词
Traffic signs; Ergonomic principles; Compatibility; Recognition-recall; Learnability; SYMBOL COMPREHENSION; FAMILIARITY;
D O I
10.1016/j.apergo.2019.02.009
中图分类号
T [工业技术];
学科分类号
08 ;
摘要
Traffic signs are used to control and regulate traffic and create a safe environment for road users. Therefore, it is of great importance to ensure that road signs are easily understood and easily learned, especially by drivers. The current study, conducted in Israel, focused on the ability to learn unfamiliar road signs and on the effect of the compliance of those signs with principles of physical and conceptual compatibility (ergonomic principles for symbol design). A preliminary experiment tested the extent to which each of 30 signs, not used in Israel, complied with the compatibility principle. Based on this evaluation, the signs were divided into two distinctive groups "ergonomic" signs and "non-ergonomic" signs. In the second part of the study, we tested the differences between the two groups of signs in terms of comprehension and learnability, conducting recognition-recall tests among 33 teenagers without a driving license. Results showed a significant design main effect, with a higher comprehension level associated with the ergonomic signs compared to the non-ergonomic signs. A significant leamability main effect was also found, with comprehension levels in the recall test significantly higher than in the recognition test for both groups of signs. In addition, the probability for improvement in comprehension based on learning the meanings of the signs was higher among the ergonomic group of signs. These findings demonstrate the importance of ergonomic design in shaping the understandability and leamability of road signs. The implications of the current results can be most relevant to tourists, as well as novice drivers.
引用
收藏
页码:137 / 147
页数:11
相关论文
共 21 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], 2013, P INT MULTICONFERENC
[2]   Working memory [J].
Baddeley, Alan .
CURRENT BIOLOGY, 2010, 20 (04) :R136-R140
[3]   Ergonomic guidelines for traffic sign design increase sign comprehension [J].
Ben-Bassat, T ;
Shinar, D .
HUMAN FACTORS, 2006, 48 (01) :182-195
[4]   COMMUNICATION EFFECTIVENESS OF SYMBOLIC SAFETY SIGNS WITH DIFFERENT USER GROUPS [J].
CAIRNEY, P ;
SLESS, D .
APPLIED ERGONOMICS, 1982, 13 (02) :91-97
[5]  
Cooper B. R, 1989, COMPREHENSION TRAFFI
[6]  
Dewar R.E., 1994, Transp. Res. Rec., V1456, P1
[7]   A Double-Structure Structural Equation Model for Three-Mode Data [J].
Gonzalez, Jorge ;
De Boeck, Paul ;
Tuerlinckx, Francis .
PSYCHOLOGICAL METHODS, 2008, 13 (04) :337-353
[8]   EVALUATING PICTOGRAPHIC SYMBOLS - AUTOMOTIVE APPLICATION [J].
GREEN, P ;
PEW, RW .
HUMAN FACTORS, 1978, 20 (01) :103-114
[9]   EMERGENCE AND RECOVERY OF INITIALLY UNAVAILABLE PERCEPTUAL MATERIAL [J].
HABER, RN ;
ERDELYI, MH .
JOURNAL OF VERBAL LEARNING AND VERBAL BEHAVIOR, 1967, 6 (04) :618-&
[10]   Safety symbol comprehension: Effects of symbol type, familiarity, and age [J].
Hancock, HE ;
Rogers, WA ;
Schroeder, D ;
Fisk, AD .
HUMAN FACTORS, 2004, 46 (02) :183-195