Kantian Constructivism and the Moral Problem

被引:10
作者
Bagnoli, Carla [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Modena, Dept Linguist Studies & Cultures, Modena, Italy
[2] Univ Oslo, Dept Philosophy Class Hist Art & Ideas, Oslo, Norway
关键词
Constructivism; Kantian constructivism; Metaethics; Justification; Realism; Moral reasons; Reasoning;
D O I
10.1007/s11406-016-9745-4
中图分类号
B [哲学、宗教];
学科分类号
01 ; 0101 ;
摘要
According to the standard objection, Kantian constructivism implicitly commits to value realism or fails to warrant objective validity of normative propositions. This paper argues that this objection gains some force from the special case of moral obligations. The case largely rests on the assumption that the moral domain is an eminent domain of special objects. But for constructivism there is no moral domain of objects prior to and independently of reasoning. The argument attempts to make some progress in the debate by defending a robust conception of construction, which names a distinctive view of practical reasoning as transformative.
引用
收藏
页码:1229 / 1246
页数:18
相关论文
共 50 条
[41]   Extending the Conversation on Moral Judgement Development: Relations Between Social Intuitionism, Constructivism and Cultural Psychology [J].
Barreiro, Alicia ;
Castorina, Jose Antonio .
REVISTA DE HUMANIDADES DE VALPARAISO-RHV, 2022, (19) :181-202
[42]   CONSTRUCTIVISM VERSUS REALISM, OR CONSTRUCTIVISM AND REALISM [J].
HOFFMAN, RR .
JOURNAL OF EXPERIMENTAL & THEORETICAL ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE, 1994, 6 (04) :431-435
[43]   Idea of Reality and Epistemological Constructivism [J].
Przhilensky, V. I. .
VOPROSY FILOSOFII, 2010, (11) :105-113
[44]   Constructivism, Intersubjectivity, Provability, and Triviality [J].
Guardo, Andrea .
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES, 2019, 27 (04) :515-527
[45]   Towards a semantics for metanormative constructivism [J].
Jeremy M. Schwartz ;
Joel D. Velasco .
Philosophical Studies, 2019, 176 :3061-3076
[46]   On the possibility of a realist pedagogical constructivism [J].
Bellomo, Santiago Tomas .
SOPHIA-COLECCION DE FILOSOFIA DE LA EDUCACION, 2023, (35) :187-209
[47]   Towards a semantics for metanormative constructivism [J].
Schwartz, Jeremy M. ;
Velasco, Joel D. .
PHILOSOPHICAL STUDIES, 2019, 176 (11) :3061-3076
[48]   Coherent constructivism - A response to Mackay [J].
Raskin, JD ;
Neimeyer, RA .
THEORY & PSYCHOLOGY, 2003, 13 (03) :397-409
[49]   Constructivism and Southeast Asian security [J].
Busse, N .
PACIFIC REVIEW, 1999, 12 (01) :39-60
[50]   COMPLEMENTARITY OF CONSTRUCTIVISM AND REALISM IN EPISTEMOLOGY [J].
Nevvazhay, Igor .
EPISTEMOLOGY & PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE-EPISTEMOLOGIYA I FILOSOFIYA NAUKI, 2015, 43 (01) :83-97