An act 'soe fowle and grievous': contextualizing rape in the 1641 rebellion

被引:3
作者
Robinson, Morgan T. P.
机构
关键词
D O I
10.1017/ihs.2015.27
中图分类号
K [历史、地理];
学科分类号
06 ;
摘要
This study aims to critically re-evaluate existing explanations for the scale and significance of rape during the 1641 Rebellion in Ireland, using a contextual analysis of the legal testimonies of English Protestant settlers, known collectively as the `1641 Depositions', analysing as far as possible the veracity of reports of rape, the circumstances in which rape occurred, and the identities of - and relationships between - victims and perpetrators. This study considers how women reported rape, comparing the Depositions to similar processes of legal testimony in early modern England. Rape perpetrated by combatants in contemporaneous conflicts is also considered, and the existence of - and adherence to - ad hoc codes of military conduct in Irish rebel ranks is investigated. Most reports of rape during the Rebellion appear highly credible, and almost all perpetrators were known to their victims as members of the same communities. There is a multiplicity of possible motivations for these crimes, with no clear pattern other than opportunism within situations where standards of ethical and military conduct were collectively ignored by rebel soldiers.
引用
收藏
页码:595 / 619
页数:25
相关论文
共 49 条
  • [31] McAreavey Naomi, 2010, J NO RENAISSANCE, Vii, P74
  • [32] McConnell James, 1951, FASTI IRISH PRESBYTE, P11
  • [33] Mendelson Sara, 1998, WOMEN EARLY MODERN E, P213
  • [34] Mortimer Geoff, 2004, EYEWITNESS ACCOUNTS, p[34, 70, 162, 170]
  • [35] O'HARA David., 2006, ENGLISH NEWSBOOKS IR
  • [36] O'Neill Phelim, 1641, PETITION DECLARATION, P4
  • [37] OGORMAN T, 1999, THESIS U COLL DUBLIN
  • [38] Porter Roy, 1986, RAPE, P229
  • [39] Raymond Joad, 1993, MAKING NEWS ANTHOLOG, P128
  • [40] Raymond Joad., 1995, INVENTION NEWSPAPER