Testing large-scale (an)isotropy of ultra-high energy cosmic rays

被引:35
作者
Koers, Hylke B. J. [1 ]
Tinyakov, Peter [1 ,2 ]
机构
[1] Univ Libre Bruxelles, Serv Phys Theor, B-1050 Brussels, Belgium
[2] Inst Nucl Res, Moscow 117312, Russia
来源
JOURNAL OF COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS | 2009年 / 04期
关键词
ultra high energy cosmic rays; cosmic rays; superclusters and voids; NEARBY EXTRAGALACTIC OBJECTS; KOLMOGOROV-SMIRNOV TEST; ANISOTROPY; GALAXIES; CATALOG; NUMBER;
D O I
10.1088/1475-7516/2009/04/003
中图分类号
P1 [天文学];
学科分类号
0704 ;
摘要
We present a simple yet powerful method to test models of cosmic-ray (CR) origin using the distribution of CR arrival directions. The method is statistically unambiguous in the sense that it is binless and does not invoke scanning over unknown parameters, and general in the sense that it can be applied to any model that predicts a continuous distribution of CRs over the sky. We show that it provides a powerful discrimination between an isotropic distribution and predictions from the "matter tracer" model, a benchmark model that assumes small CR deflections and a continuous distribution of sources tracing the distribution of matter in the Universe. Our method is competitive or superior in statistical power to existing methods, and is especially sensitive in the case of relatively few high-energy events. Applying the method to the present data we find that neither an isotropic distribution nor the matter tracer model can be excluded. Based on estimates of its statistical power, we expect that the proposed test will lead to meaningful constraints on models of CR origin with the data that will be accumulated within the next few years by the Pierre Auger Observatory and the Telescope Array.
引用
收藏
页数:28
相关论文
共 43 条
[1]   First observation of the Greisen-Zatsepin-Kuzmin suppression [J].
Abbasi, R. U. ;
Abu-Zayyad, T. ;
Allen, M. ;
Amman, J. F. ;
Archbold, G. ;
Belov, K. ;
Belz, J. W. ;
Ben Zvi, S. Y. ;
Bergman, D. R. ;
Blake, S. A. ;
Brusova, O. A. ;
Burt, G. W. ;
Cannon, C. ;
Cao, Z. ;
Connolly, B. C. ;
Deng, W. ;
Fedorova, Y. ;
Finley, C. B. ;
Gray, R. C. ;
Hanlon, W. F. ;
Hoffman, C. M. ;
Holzscheiter, M. H. ;
Hughes, G. ;
Huentemeyer, P. ;
Jones, B. F. ;
Jui, C. C. H. ;
Kim, K. ;
Kirn, M. A. ;
Loh, E. C. ;
Maestas, M. M. ;
Manago, N. ;
Marek, L. J. ;
Martens, K. ;
Matthews, J. A. J. ;
Matthews, J. N. ;
Moore, S. A. ;
O'Neill, A. ;
Painter, C. A. ;
Perera, L. ;
Reil, K. ;
Riehle, R. ;
Roberts, M. ;
Rodriguez, D. ;
Sasaki, N. ;
Schnetzer, S. R. ;
Scott, L. M. ;
Sinnis, G. ;
Smith, J. D. ;
Sokolsky, P. ;
Song, C. .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 2008, 100 (10)
[2]   A study of the composition of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays using the high-resolution fly's eye [J].
Abbasi, RU ;
Abu-Zayyad, T ;
Archbold, G ;
Atkins, R ;
Bellido, J ;
Belov, K ;
Belz, JW ;
BenZvi, S ;
Bergman, DR ;
Boyer, J ;
Burt, GW ;
Cao, Z ;
Clay, R ;
Connolly, BM ;
Dawson, B ;
Deng, W ;
Fedorova, Y ;
Findlay, J ;
Finley, CB ;
Hanlon, WF ;
Hughes, GA ;
Huntemeyer, P ;
Jui, CCH ;
Kim, K ;
Kim, MA ;
Knapp, B ;
Loh, EC ;
Maetas, MM ;
Martens, K ;
Martin, G ;
Manago, N ;
Mannel, EJ ;
Matthews, JAJ ;
Matthews, JN ;
O'Neill, A ;
Perera, L ;
Reil, K ;
Riehle, R ;
Roberts, MD ;
Sasaki, M ;
Seman, M ;
Schnetzer, SR ;
Simpson, K ;
Smith, JD ;
Snow, R ;
Sokolsky, P ;
Song, C ;
Springer, RW ;
Stokes, BT ;
Thomas, JR .
ASTROPHYSICAL JOURNAL, 2005, 622 (02) :910-926
[3]   Correlation of the highest-energy cosmic rays with the positions of nearby active galactic nuclei [J].
Abraham, J. ;
Abreu, P. ;
Aglietta, M. ;
Aguirre, C. ;
Allard, D. ;
Allekotte, I. ;
Allen, J. ;
Allison, P. ;
Alvarez-Muniz, J. ;
Ambrosio, M. ;
Anchordoqui, L. ;
Andringa, S. ;
Anzalone, A. ;
Aramo, C. ;
Argiro, S. ;
Arisaka, K. ;
Armengaud, E. ;
Arneodo, F. ;
Arqueros, F. ;
Asch, T. ;
Asorey, H. ;
Assis, P. ;
Atulugama, B. S. ;
Aublin, J. ;
Ave, M. ;
Avila, G. ;
Baecker, T. ;
Badagnani, D. ;
Barbosa, A. F. ;
Barnhill, D. ;
Barroso, S. L. C. ;
Bauleo, P. ;
Beatty, J. J. ;
Beau, T. ;
Becker, B. R. ;
Becker, K. H. ;
Bellido, J. A. ;
BenZvi, S. ;
Berat, C. ;
Bergmann, T. ;
Bernardini, P. ;
Bertou, X. ;
Biermann, P. L. ;
Billoir, P. ;
Blanch-Bigas, O. ;
Blanco, F. ;
Blasi, P. ;
Bleve, C. ;
Bluemer, H. ;
Bohacova, M. .
ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS, 2008, 29 (03) :188-204
[4]   Correlation of the highest-energy cosmic rays with nearby extragalactic objects [J].
Abraham, J. ;
Abreu, P. ;
Aglietta, M. ;
Aguirre, C. ;
Allard, D. ;
Allekotte, I. ;
Allen, J. ;
Allison, P. ;
Alvarez, C. ;
Alvarez-Muniz, J. ;
Ambrosio, M. ;
Anchordoqui, L. ;
Andringa, S. ;
Anzalone, A. ;
Aramo, C. ;
Argiro, S. ;
Arisaka, K. ;
Armengaud, E. ;
Arneodo, F. ;
Arqueros, F. ;
Asch, T. ;
Asorey, H. ;
Assis, P. ;
Atulugama, B. S. ;
Aublin, J. ;
Ave, M. ;
Avila, G. ;
Baecker, T. ;
Badagnani, D. ;
Barbosa, A. F. ;
Barnhill, D. ;
Barroso, S. L. C. ;
Bauleo, P. ;
Beatty, J. ;
Beau, T. ;
Becker, B. R. ;
Becker, K. H. ;
Bellido, J. A. ;
BenZvi, S. ;
Berat, C. ;
Bergmann, T. ;
Bernardini, P. ;
Bertou, X. ;
Biermann, P. L. ;
Billoir, P. ;
Blanch-Bigas, O. ;
Blanco, F. ;
Blasi, P. ;
Bleve, C. ;
Bluemer, H. .
SCIENCE, 2007, 318 (5852) :938-943
[5]   Observation of the suppression of the flux of cosmic rays above 4x1019 eV [J].
Abraham, J. ;
Abreu, P. ;
Aglietta, M. ;
Aguirre, C. ;
Allard, D. ;
Allekotte, I. ;
Allen, J. ;
Allison, P. ;
Alvarez-Muniz, J. ;
Ambrosio, M. ;
Anchordoqui, L. ;
Andringa, S. ;
Anzalone, A. ;
Aramo, C. ;
Argiro, S. ;
Arisaka, K. ;
Armengaud, E. ;
Arneodo, F. ;
Arqueros, F. ;
Asch, T. ;
Asorey, H. ;
Assis, P. ;
Atulugama, B. S. ;
Aublin, J. ;
Ave, M. ;
Avila, G. ;
Backer, T. ;
Badagnani, D. ;
Barbosa, A. F. ;
Barnhill, D. ;
Barroso, S. L. C. ;
Baughman, B. ;
Bauleo, P. ;
Beatty, J. J. ;
Beau, T. ;
Becker, B. R. ;
Becker, K. H. ;
Bellido, J. A. ;
BenZvi, S. ;
Berat, C. ;
Bergmann, T. ;
Bernardini, P. ;
Bertou, X. ;
Biermann, P. L. ;
Billoir, P. ;
Blanch-Bigas, O. ;
Blanco, F. ;
Blasi, P. ;
Bleve, C. ;
Mer, H. Blu .
PHYSICAL REVIEW LETTERS, 2008, 101 (06)
[6]  
Berezinsky V., 2006, Phys. Rev. D, V74, p043005 August
[7]  
Boyle BJ, 1998, MON NOT R ASTRON SOC, V293, pL49, DOI 10.1046/j.1365-8711.1998.01264.x
[8]   The footprint of large scale cosmic structure on the ultrahigh energy [J].
Cuoco, A ;
D'Abrusco, R ;
Longo, G ;
Miele, G ;
Serpico, PD .
JOURNAL OF COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS, 2006, (01)
[9]  
DERMER CD, ARXIV08111160SPIRES
[10]   Constrained simulations of the magnetic field in the local Universe and the propagation of ultrahigh energy cosmic rays [J].
Dolag, K ;
Grasso, D ;
Springel, V ;
Tkachev, I .
JOURNAL OF COSMOLOGY AND ASTROPARTICLE PHYSICS, 2005, (01) :113-149