A Comparison of RNA-Seq Results from Paired Formalin-Fixed Paraffin-Embedded and FreshFrozen Glioblastoma Tissue Samples

被引:90
作者
Esteve-Codina, Anna [1 ]
Arpi, Oriol [2 ]
Martinez-Garcia, Maria [3 ]
Pineda, Estela [4 ]
Mallo, Mar [5 ]
Gut, Marta [6 ]
Carrato, Cristina [7 ]
Rovira, Anna [2 ]
Lopez, Raquel [8 ]
Tortosa, Avelina [9 ]
Dabad, Marc [1 ]
Del Barco, Sonia [10 ]
Heath, Simon [1 ]
Bague, Silvia [11 ]
Ribalta, Teresa [12 ]
Alameda, Francesc [13 ]
de la Iglesia, Nuria [14 ]
Balana, Carmen [15 ]
机构
[1] Univ Pompeu Fabra, Inst Sci & Technol BIST, CNAG, CRG, Barcelona, Spain
[2] Inst Hosp Mar Invest Med IMIM, Canc Res Program, Barcelona, Spain
[3] Hosp Mar, Med Oncol, Barcelona, Spain
[4] Hosp Clin Barcelona, Med Oncol, Barcelona, Spain
[5] Inst Recerca Leucemia Josep Carreras, Barcelona, Spain
[6] Univ Pompeu Fabra, Barcelona Inst Sci & Technol BIST, Sequencing Unit, CNAG,CRG, Barcelona, Spain
[7] Hosp Badalona Germans Trias & Pujol, Dept Pathol, Barcelona, Spain
[8] Hosp Josep Trueta, Dept Pathol, Girona, Spain
[9] Univ Barcelona, Fac Med & Ciencies Salut, Inst Invest Biomed Bellvitge IDIBELL, Lab Quimioresistencia & Canc,Dept Infermeria Fona, Barcelona, Spain
[10] Hosp Josep Trueta, ICO, Med Oncol, Girona, Spain
[11] Hosp Santa Creu & Sant Pau, Dept Pathol, Barcelona, Spain
[12] Hosp Clin Barcelona, Pathol Dept Neuropathol, Barcelona, Spain
[13] Hosp Mar, Dept Pathol, Barcelona, Spain
[14] August Pi & Sunyer Biomed Res Inst IDIBAPS, Translat Genom & Targeted Therapeut Solid Tumors, Glioma & Neural Stem Cell Grp, Barcelona, Spain
[15] Hosp Badalona Germans Trias & Pujol, Med Oncol Serv, Inst Catala Oncol, Badalona, Spain
关键词
GENE-EXPRESSION; IDENTIFICATION; CARCINOMA; PATHS; DNA;
D O I
10.1371/journal.pone.0170632
中图分类号
O [数理科学和化学]; P [天文学、地球科学]; Q [生物科学]; N [自然科学总论];
学科分类号
07 ; 0710 ; 09 ;
摘要
The molecular classification of glioblastoma (GBM) based on gene expression might better explain outcome and response to treatment than clinical factors. Whole transcriptome sequencing using next-generation sequencing platforms is rapidly becoming accepted as a tool for measuring gene expression for both research and clinical use. Fresh frozen (FF) tissue specimens of GBM are difficult to obtain since tumor tissue obtained at surgery is often scarce and necrotic and diagnosis is prioritized over freezing. After diagnosis, leftover tissue is usually stored as formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissue. However, RNA from FFPE tissues is usually degraded, which could hamper gene expression analysis. We compared RNA-Seq data obtained from matched pairs of FF and FFPE GBM specimens. Only three FFPE out of eleven FFPE-FF matched samples yielded informative results. Several quality-control measurements showed that RNA from FFPE samples was highly degraded but maintained transcriptomic similarities to RNA from FF samples. Certain issues regarding mutation analysis and subtype prediction were detected. Nevertheless, our results suggest that RNA-Seq of FFPE GBM specimens provides reliable gene expression data that can be used in molecular studies of GBM if the RNA is sufficiently preserved.
引用
收藏
页数:18
相关论文
共 38 条
[1]   Comparative analysis of RNA sequencing methods for degraded or low-input samples [J].
Adiconis, Xian ;
Borges-Rivera, Diego ;
Satija, Rahul ;
DeLuca, David S. ;
Busby, Michele A. ;
Berlin, Aaron M. ;
Sivachenko, Andrey ;
Thompson, Dawn Anne ;
Wysoker, Alec ;
Fennell, Timothy ;
Gnirke, Andreas ;
Pochet, Nathalie ;
Regev, Aviv ;
Levin, Joshua Z. .
NATURE METHODS, 2013, 10 (07) :623-+
[2]   From the core to beyond the margin: a genomic picture of glioblastoma intratumor heterogeneity [J].
Aubry, Marc ;
de Tayrac, Marie ;
Etcheverry, Amandine ;
Clavreul, Anne ;
Saikali, Stephan ;
Menei, Philippe ;
Mosser, Jean .
ONCOTARGET, 2015, 6 (14) :12094-12109
[3]   RNA-Seq-based toxicogenomic assessment of fresh frozen and formalin-fixed tissues yields similar mechanistic insights [J].
Auerbach, Scott S. ;
Phadke, Dhiral P. ;
Mav, Deepak ;
Holmgren, Stephanie ;
Gao, Yuan ;
Xie, Bin ;
Shin, Joo Heon ;
Shah, Ruchir R. ;
Merrick, B. Alex ;
Tice, Raymond R. .
JOURNAL OF APPLIED TOXICOLOGY, 2015, 35 (07) :766-780
[4]   The Somatic Genomic Landscape of Glioblastoma [J].
Brennan, Cameron W. ;
Verhaak, Roel G. W. ;
McKenna, Aaron ;
Campos, Benito ;
Noushmehr, Houtan ;
Salama, Sofie R. ;
Zheng, Siyuan ;
Chakravarty, Debyani ;
Sanborn, J. Zachary ;
Berman, Samuel H. ;
Beroukhim, Rameen ;
Bernard, Brady ;
Wu, Chang-Jiun ;
Genovese, Giannicola ;
Shmulevich, Ilya ;
Barnholtz-Sloan, Jill ;
Zou, Lihua ;
Vegesna, Rahulsimham ;
Shukla, Sachet A. ;
Ciriello, Giovanni ;
Yung, W. K. ;
Zhang, Wei ;
Sougnez, Carrie ;
Mikkelsen, Tom ;
Aldape, Kenneth ;
Bigner, Darell D. ;
Van Meir, Erwin G. ;
Prados, Michael ;
Sloan, Andrew ;
Black, Keith L. ;
Eschbacher, Jennifer ;
Finocchiaro, Gaetano ;
Friedman, William ;
Andrews, David W. ;
Guha, Abhijit ;
Iacocca, Mary ;
O'Neill, Brian P. ;
Foltz, Greg ;
Myers, Jerome ;
Weisenberger, Daniel J. ;
Penny, Robert ;
Kucherlapati, Raju ;
Perou, Charles M. ;
Hayes, D. Neil ;
Gibbs, Richard ;
Marra, Marco ;
Mills, Gordon B. ;
Lander, Eric ;
Spellman, Paul ;
Wilson, Richard .
CELL, 2013, 155 (02) :462-477
[5]   STAR: ultrafast universal RNA-seq aligner [J].
Dobin, Alexander ;
Davis, Carrie A. ;
Schlesinger, Felix ;
Drenkow, Jorg ;
Zaleski, Chris ;
Jha, Sonali ;
Batut, Philippe ;
Chaisson, Mark ;
Gingeras, Thomas R. .
BIOINFORMATICS, 2013, 29 (01) :15-21
[6]   Current Challenges in Glioblastoma: Intratumour Heterogeneity, Residual Disease, and Models to Predict Disease Recurrence [J].
Ellis, Hayley P. ;
Greenslade, Mark ;
Powell, Ben ;
Spiteri, Inmaculada ;
Sottoriva, Andrea ;
Kurian, Kathreena M. .
FRONTIERS IN ONCOLOGY, 2015, 5
[7]   Identification of Patients with Recurrent Glioblastoma Who May Benefit from Combined Bevacizumab and CCNU Therapy: A Report from the BELOB Trial [J].
Erdem-Eraslan, Lale ;
van den Bent, Martin J. ;
Hoogstrate, Youri ;
Naz-Khan, Hina ;
Stubbs, Andrew ;
van der Spek, Peter ;
Bottcher, Rene ;
Gao, Ya ;
de Wit, Maurice ;
Taal, Walter ;
Oosterkamp, Hendrika M. ;
Walenkamp, Annemiek ;
Beerepoot, Laurens V. ;
Hanse, Monique C. J. ;
Buter, Jan ;
Honkoop, Aafke H. ;
van der Holt, Bronno ;
Vernhout, Rene M. ;
Smitt, Peter A. E. Sillevis ;
Kros, Johan M. ;
French, Pim J. .
CANCER RESEARCH, 2016, 76 (03) :525-534
[8]   Regularization Paths for Generalized Linear Models via Coordinate Descent [J].
Friedman, Jerome ;
Hastie, Trevor ;
Tibshirani, Rob .
JOURNAL OF STATISTICAL SOFTWARE, 2010, 33 (01) :1-22
[9]   Comparison of Two Methods of RNA Extraction from Formalin-Fixed Paraffin-Embedded Tissue Specimens [J].
Gouveia, Gisele Rodrigues ;
Ferreira, Suzete Cleusa ;
Ferreira, Jerenice Esdras ;
Coelho Siqueira, Sheila Aparecida ;
Pereira, Juliana .
BIOMED RESEARCH INTERNATIONAL, 2014, 2014
[10]   Patterns of care and outcome for patients with glioblastoma diagnosed during 20082010 in Spain [J].
Graus, Francesc ;
Bruna, Jordi ;
Pardo, Javier ;
Escudero, Domingo ;
Vilas, Dolores ;
Barcelo, Ines ;
Brell, Marta ;
Pascual, Carmen ;
Crespo, Jose A. ;
Erro, Elena ;
Garcia-Romero, Juan C. ;
Estela, Jordi ;
Martino, Juan ;
Garcia-Castano, Almudena ;
Mata, Elena ;
Lema, Manuela ;
Gelabert, Miguel ;
Fuentes, Rafel ;
Perez, Pedro ;
Manzano, Arancha ;
Aguas, Jesus ;
Belenguer, Antonio ;
Simon, Ana ;
Henriquez, Ivan ;
Murcia, Mauricio ;
Vivanco, Rosa ;
Rojas-Marcos, Inigo ;
Munoz-Carmona, David ;
Navas, Inmaculada ;
de Andres, Pablo ;
Mas, Gemma ;
Gil, Miguel ;
Verger, Eugenia .
NEURO-ONCOLOGY, 2013, 15 (06) :797-805