A new interpretation of chlorine leaving group kinetic isotope effects; A theoretical approach

The chlorine leaving group kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) for the S(N)2 reactions between methyl chloride and a wide range of anionic, neutral, and radical anion nucleophiles were calculated in the gas phase and, in several cases, using a continuum solvent model. In contrast to the expected linear dependence of the chlorine KIEs on the C-alpha-Cl bond order in the transition state, the KIEs fell in a very small range (1.0056-1.0091), even though the C-alpha-Cl transition state bond orders varied widely from approximately 0.32 to 0.78, a range from reactant-like to very product-like. This renders chlorine KIEs, and possibly other leaving-group KIEs, less useful for studies of reaction mechanisms than commonly assumed. A partial explanation for this unexpected relationship between the C-alpha-Cl transition state bond order and the magnitude of the chlorine KIE is presented.