MDS evidence-based review of treatments for essential tremor

被引:127
作者
Ferreira, Joaquim J. [1 ,2 ]
Mestre, Tiago A. [3 ]
Lyons, Kelly E. [4 ]
Benito-Leon, Julian [5 ,6 ]
Tan, Eng-King [7 ]
Abbruzzese, Giovanni [8 ]
Hallett, Mark [9 ]
Haubenberger, Dietrich [10 ]
Elble, Rodger [11 ]
Deuschl, Guenther [12 ]
机构
[1] Univ Lisbon, Fac Med, Inst Med Mol, Lisbon, Portugal
[2] CNS, Campus Neurol Sr, Torres Vedras, Portugal
[3] Univ Ottawa, Ottawa Hosp Res Inst, Brain & Mind Res Inst,Dept Med, Parkinsons Dis & Movement Disorders Ctr,Div Neuro, Ottawa, ON, Canada
[4] Univ Kansas, Med Ctr, Parkinsons Dis & Movement Disorder Ctr, Kansas City, KS 66103 USA
[5] Univ Complutense Madrid, Dept Neurol, Univ Hosp Octubre 12, Madrid, Spain
[6] Univ Complutense Madrid, Ctr Biomed Network Res Neurodegenerat Dis CIBERNE, Dept Med, Fac Med, Madrid, Spain
[7] Duke NUS Med Sch, Natl Neurosci Inst, Singapore, Singapore
[8] Univ Genoa, IRCCS Osped Policlin San Martino, Dept Neurosci Rehabil Ophthalmol Genet & Maternal, Genoa, Italy
[9] NINDS, Motor Control Sect, NIH, Bldg 36,Rm 4D04, Bethesda, MD 20892 USA
[10] NINDS, Clin Trials Unit, Off Clin Director, NIH, Bldg 36,Rm 4D04, Bethesda, MD 20892 USA
[11] Southern Illinois Univ, Sch Med, Dept Neurol, Springfield, IL USA
[12] Christian Albrechts Univ Kiel, Dept Neurol, Univ Klinikum Schleswig Holstein, Kiel Campus, Kiel, Germany
关键词
clinical trials; essential tremor; evidence-based medicine; systematic review; treatment; DEEP BRAIN-STIMULATION; PLACEBO-CONTROLLED TRIAL; TOXIN TYPE-A; DOUBLE-BLIND; PARKINSONS-DISEASE; THALAMIC-STIMULATION; MOVEMENT-DISORDERS; TASK-FORCE; PROPRANOLOL; PRIMIDONE;
D O I
10.1002/mds.27700
中图分类号
R74 [神经病学与精神病学];
学科分类号
摘要
Background Essential tremor is one of the most prevalent movement disorders. Many treatments for essential tremor have been reported in clinical practice, but it is uncertain which options have the most robust evidence. The International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society commissioned a task force on tremor to review clinical studies of treatments for essential tremor. Objectives To conduct an evidence-based review of current pharmacological and surgical treatments for essential tremor, using standardized criteria defined a priori by the International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society. Methods We followed the recommendations of the International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society Evidence Based Medicine Committee. Results Sixty-four studies of pharmacological and surgical interventions were included in the review. Propranolol and primidone were classified as clinically useful, similar to Topiramate, but only for doses higher than 200 mg/day. Alprazolam and botulinum toxin type A were classified as possibly useful. Unilateral Ventralis intermedius thalamic DBS, radiofrequency thalamotomy, and MRI-guided focused ultrasound thalamotomy were considered possibly useful. All the above recommendations were made for limb tremor in essential tremor. There was insufficient evidence for voice and head tremor as well as for the remaining interventions. Conclusion Propranolol, primidone, and topiramate (>200 mg/day) are the pharmacological interventions in which the data reviewed robustly supported efficacy. Their safety profile and patient preference may guide the prioritization of these interventions in clinical practice. MRI-guided focused ultrasound thalamotomy was, for the first time, assessed and was considered to be possibly useful. There is a need to improve study design in essential tremor and overcome the limitation of small sample sizes, cross-over studies, short-term follow-up studies, and use of nonvalidated clinical scales. (c) 2019 International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society
引用
收藏
页码:950 / 958
页数:9
相关论文
共 64 条
[1]  
[Anonymous], 2002, Mov Disord, V17 Suppl 4, pS1
[2]   PHENOBARBITAL AND PROPRANOLOL IN ESSENTIAL TREMOR - A DOUBLE-BLIND CONTROLLED CLINICAL-TRIAL [J].
BARUZZI, A ;
PROCACCIANTI, G ;
MARTINELLI, P ;
RIVA, R ;
DENOTH, F ;
MONTANARO, N ;
LUGARESI, E .
NEUROLOGY, 1983, 33 (03) :296-300
[3]   Consensus Statement on the Classification of Tremors. From the Task Force on Tremor of the International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society [J].
Bhatia, Kailash P. ;
Bain, Peter ;
Bajaj, Nin ;
Elble, Rodger J. ;
Hallett, Mark ;
Louis, Elan D. ;
Raethjen, Jan ;
Stamelou, Maria ;
Testa, Claudia M. ;
Deuschl, Guenther .
MOVEMENT DISORDERS, 2018, 33 (01) :75-87
[4]   Deep brain stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus versus the zona incerta in the treatment of essential tremor [J].
Blomstedt, Patric ;
Sandvik, Ulrika ;
Linder, Jan ;
Fredricks, Anna ;
Forsgren, Lars ;
Hariz, Marwan I. .
ACTA NEUROCHIRURGICA, 2011, 153 (12) :2329-2335
[5]   A randomized, double masked, controlled trial of botulinum toxin type A in essential hand tremor [J].
Brin, MF ;
Lyons, KE ;
Doucette, J ;
Adler, CH ;
Caviness, JN ;
Comella, CL ;
Dubinsky, RM ;
Friedman, JH ;
Manyam, BV ;
Matsumoto, JY ;
Pullman, SL ;
Rajput, AH ;
Sethi, KD ;
Tanner, C ;
Koller, WC .
NEUROLOGY, 2001, 56 (11) :1523-1528
[6]   Pilot trial of 1-octanol in essential tremor [J].
Bushara, KO ;
Goldstein, SR ;
Grimes, GJ ;
Burstein, AH ;
Hallett, M .
NEUROLOGY, 2004, 62 (01) :122-124
[7]   THE RESPONSE OF ESSENTIAL TREMOR TO PROPRANOLOL - EVALUATION OF CLINICAL-VARIABLES GOVERNING ITS EFFICACY ON PROLONGED ADMINISTRATION [J].
CALZETTI, S ;
FINDLEY, LJ ;
PERUCCA, E ;
RICHENS, A .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 1983, 46 (05) :393-398
[8]   CONTROLLED-STUDY OF METOPROLOL AND PROPRANOLOL DURING PROLONGED ADMINISTRATION IN PATIENTS WITH ESSENTIAL TREMOR [J].
CALZETTI, S ;
FINDLEY, LJ ;
PERUCCA, E ;
RICHENS, A .
JOURNAL OF NEUROLOGY NEUROSURGERY AND PSYCHIATRY, 1982, 45 (10) :893-897
[9]   PARKINSONISM, TREMOR, AND DEPRESSION INDUCED BY CINNARIZINE AND FLUNARIZINE [J].
CAPELLA, D ;
LAPORTE, JR ;
CASTEL, JM ;
TRISTAN, C ;
COS, A ;
MORALESOLIVAS, FJ .
BRITISH MEDICAL JOURNAL, 1988, 297 (6650) :722-723
[10]  
CHOUZA C, 1986, LANCET, V1, P1303