Concurrent Validity of Wearable Activity Trackers Under Free-Living Conditions

被引:52
|
作者
Brooke, Skyler M. [1 ]
An, Hyun-Sung [1 ]
Kang, Seoung-Ki [2 ]
Noble, John M. [1 ]
Berg, Kris E. [1 ]
Lee, Jung-Min [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Nebraska, Sch Hlth Phys Educ & Recreat, Omaha, NE 68182 USA
[2] Yong In Univ, Grad Sch Educ, Yongin, South Korea
关键词
sleep period time; energy expenditure; physical activity assessment; PHYSICAL-ACTIVITY; ACTIVITY MONITORS; ENERGY-EXPENDITURE; HEALTHY-ADULTS; SLEEP; CHILDREN; ADOLESCENTS; VALIDATION; CONSUMER; POLYSOMNOGRAPHY;
D O I
10.1519/JSC.0000000000001571
中图分类号
G8 [体育];
学科分类号
04 ; 0403 ;
摘要
Brooke, SM, An, H-S, Kang, S-K, Noble, JM, Berg, KE, and Lee, J-M. Concurrent validity of wearable activity trackers under free-living conditions. J Strength Cond Res 31(4): 1097-1106, 2017The purpose of this study is to evaluate the concurrent validity of wearable activity trackers in energy expenditure (EE) and sleep period time (SPT) under free-living conditions. Ninety-five (28.5 +/- 9.8 years) healthy men (n = 34) and women (n = 61) participated in this study. The total EE and SPT were measured using 8 monitors: Nike+ FuelBand SE (NFB), Garmin VivoFit (VF), Misfit Shine (MF), Fitbit Flex (FF), Jawbone UP (JU), Polar Loop (PL), Fitbit Charge HR (FC), and SenseWear Armband Mini (SWA) (criterion measures: SWA for EE and a sleep log for SPT). The mean absolute percent error (MAPE) for EE was 13.0, 15.2, 15.5, 16.1, 16.2, 22.8, and 24.5% for PL, MF, FF, NFB, FC, JU, and VF, respectively. Mean absolute percent errors were calculated for SPT to be 4.0, 8.8, 10.2, 11.5, 12.9, 13.6, 17.5, and 21.61% for VF, FF, JU, FC, MF, SWA laying down, PL, and SWA, respectively. Concurrent validity was examined using equivalence testing on EE (equivalence zone: 2,889.7-3,531.9 kcal); 2 trackers fell short of falling in the zone: PL (2,714.4-3,164.8 kcal) and FC (2,473.8-3,066.5 kcal). For SPT (equivalence zone: 420.6-514.0 minutes), several monitors fell in the zone: PL (448.3-485.6 minutes), MS (442.8-492.2 minutes), and FF (427.7-486.7 minutes). This study suggests that the PL and FC provide a reasonable estimate of EE under free-living conditions. The PL, FC, and MF were the most valid monitors used for measuring SPT.
引用
收藏
页码:1097 / 1106
页数:10
相关论文
共 50 条
  • [1] Concurrent validity of Nokia Go activity tracker in walking and free-living conditions
    Lebleu, Julien
    Detrembleur, Christine
    Guebels, Camille
    Hamblenne, Pauline
    Valet, Maxime
    JOURNAL OF EVALUATION IN CLINICAL PRACTICE, 2020, 26 (01) : 223 - 228
  • [2] Wrist-Worn Activity Trackers in Laboratory and Free-Living Settings for Patients With Chronic Pain: Criterion Validity Study
    Sjoberg, Veronica
    Westergren, Jens
    Monnier, Andreas
    Lo Martire, Riccardo
    Hagstromer, Maria
    Ang, Bjorn Olov
    Vixner, Linda
    JMIR MHEALTH AND UHEALTH, 2021, 9 (01):
  • [3] Validity of the Actical for estimating free-living physical activity
    Crouter, Scott E.
    DellaValle, Diane M.
    Horton, Magdalene
    Haas, Jere D.
    Frongillo, Edward A.
    Bassett, David R., Jr.
    EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF APPLIED PHYSIOLOGY, 2011, 111 (07) : 1381 - 1389
  • [4] Systematic review of the validity and reliability of consumer-wearable activity trackers
    Evenson, Kelly R.
    Goto, Michelle M.
    Furberg, Robert D.
    INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF BEHAVIORAL NUTRITION AND PHYSICAL ACTIVITY, 2015, 12
  • [5] Evaluating the Consistency of Current Mainstream Wearable Devices in Health Monitoring: A Comparison Under Free-Living Conditions
    Wen, Dong
    Zhang, Xingting
    Liu, Xingyu
    Lei, Jianbo
    JOURNAL OF MEDICAL INTERNET RESEARCH, 2017, 19 (03)
  • [6] Validity of activity monitors worn at multiple nontraditional locations under controlled and free-living conditions in young adult women
    Kumahara, Hideaki
    Ayabe, Makoto
    Ichibakase, Misato
    Tashima, Akari
    Chiwata, Maiko
    Takashi, Tomomi
    APPLIED PHYSIOLOGY NUTRITION AND METABOLISM, 2015, 40 (05) : 448 - 456
  • [7] Validation of Smartphones and Different Low-Cost Activity Trackers for Step Counting Under Free-Living Conditions
    Goh, Claire Marie Jie Lin
    Wang, Nan Xin
    Mueller, Andre Matthias
    Yap, Rowena
    Edney, Sarah
    Mueller-Riemenschneider, Falk
    JOURNAL FOR THE MEASUREMENT OF PHYSICAL BEHAVIOUR, 2023, 6 (01) : 79 - 87
  • [8] Validity of Consumer Activity Wristbands and Wearable EEG for Measuring Overall Sleep Parameters and Sleep Structure in Free-Living Conditions
    Liang Z.
    Chapa Martell M.A.
    Journal of Healthcare Informatics Research, 2018, 2 (1-2) : 152 - 178
  • [9] Validity, Reliability and Sensitivity to Change of Three Consumer-Grade Activity Trackers in Controlled and Free-Living Conditions among Older Adults
    Kastelic, Kaja
    Dobnik, Marina
    Lofler, Stefan
    Hofer, Christian
    Sarabon, Nejc
    SENSORS, 2021, 21 (18)
  • [10] COMPARATIVE INTERINSTRUMENT RELIABILITY OF UNIAXIAL AND TRIAXIAL ACCELEROMETERS IN FREE-LIVING CONDITIONS
    Vanhelst, Jeremy
    Baquet, Georges
    Gottrand, Frederic
    Beghin, Laurent
    PERCEPTUAL AND MOTOR SKILLS, 2012, 114 (02) : 584 - 594