Metal control of selectivity in acetate-assisted C-H bond activation: an experimental and computational study of heterocyclic, vinylic and phenylic C(sp2)-H bonds at Ir and Rh

Acetate-assisted C(sp(2))-H bond activation at [MCl2Cp*](2) (M Ir, Rh) has been studied for a series of N-alkyl imines, (PrN)-Pr-i] CHR, (R N-methyl-2-pyrrolyl, H-L-1; 2-furanyl, H-L-2; 2-thiophenyl, H-L-3a; C2H2Ph, H-L-4; and Ph, H-L-5) as well as phenylpyridine (H-L-6) by both experimental and computational means. Competition experiments reveal significant variation in the relative reactivity of these substrates and highlight changes in selectivity between Ir (H-L-4 approximate to H-L-2 < H-L-3a approximate to H-L-5 < H-L-1 approximate to H-L-6) and Rh (H-L-2 approximate to H-L-1 < H-L-3a approximate to H-L-4 < H-L-5 < H-L-6). Comparison of H-L-3a with its N-xylyl analogue, H-L-3b, gives a further case of metal-based selectivity, H-L-3a being more reactive at Ir, while H-L-3b is preferred at Rh. H/D exchange experiments suggest that the selectivity of C-H activation at Ir is determined by kinetic factors while that at Rh is determined by the product thermodynamic stability. This is confirmed by computational studies which also successfully model the order of substrate reactivity seen experimentally at each metal. To achieve the good level of agreement between experiment and computation required the inclusion of dispersion effects, use of large basis sets and an appropriate solvent correction.