Lower bounds for the weak pigeonhole principle and random formulas beyond resolution

被引:22
作者
Atserias, A [1 ]
Bonet, ML [1 ]
Esteban, JL [1 ]
机构
[1] Univ Politecn Cataluna, Dept Llenguatges & Sistemes Informat, E-08034 Barcelona, Spain
关键词
proof complexity; resolution; lower bounds; random restrictions; martingales; monotone interpolation;
D O I
10.1006/inco.2002.3114
中图分类号
TP301 [理论、方法];
学科分类号
081202 ;
摘要
We work with an extension of Resolution, called Res(2). that allows clauses with conjunctions of two literals. In this system there are rules to introduce and eliminate such conjunctions. We prove that the weak pigeonhole principle PHP(n)(cn) and random unsatistiable CNF formulas require exponential-size proofs in this system. This is the strongest system beyond Resolution for which such lower bounds are known. As a consequence to the result about the weak pigeonhole principle, Res(log) is exponentially more powerful than Res(2). Also we prove that Resolution cannot polynomially simulate Res(2) and that Res(2) does not have feasible monotone interpolation solving an open problem posed by Krajicek. (C) 2002 Elsevier Science (USA).
引用
收藏
页码:136 / 152
页数:17
相关论文
共 19 条
[1]   THE MONOTONE CIRCUIT COMPLEXITY OF BOOLEAN FUNCTIONS [J].
ALON, N ;
BOPPANA, RB .
COMBINATORICA, 1987, 7 (01) :1-22
[2]   The efficiency of resolution and Davis-Putnam procedures [J].
Beame, P ;
Karp, R ;
Pitassi, T ;
Saks, M .
SIAM JOURNAL ON COMPUTING, 2002, 31 (04) :1048-1075
[3]   Simplified and improved resolution lower bounds [J].
Beame, P ;
Pitassi, T .
37TH ANNUAL SYMPOSIUM ON FOUNDATIONS OF COMPUTER SCIENCE, PROCEEDINGS, 1996, :274-282
[4]  
BEAME P, 1992, 24TH P ANN ACM S THE, P200
[5]   Short proofs are narrow - Resolution made simple [J].
Ben-Sasson, E ;
Wigderson, A .
JOURNAL OF THE ACM, 2001, 48 (02) :149-169
[6]   Lower bounds for cutting planes proofs with small coefficients [J].
Bonet, M ;
Pitassi, T ;
Raz, R .
JOURNAL OF SYMBOLIC LOGIC, 1997, 62 (03) :708-728
[7]  
BUSS S, 1997, LECT NOTES COMPUTER, V1414, P149
[8]   RESOLUTION PROOFS OF GENERALIZED PIGEONHOLE PRINCIPLES [J].
BUSS, SR ;
TURAN, G .
THEORETICAL COMPUTER SCIENCE, 1988, 62 (03) :311-317
[9]   POLYNOMIAL SIZE PROOFS OF THE PROPOSITIONAL PIGEONHOLE PRINCIPLE [J].
BUSS, SR .
JOURNAL OF SYMBOLIC LOGIC, 1987, 52 (04) :916-927
[10]   MANY HARD EXAMPLES FOR RESOLUTION [J].
CHVATAL, V ;
SZEMEREDI, E .
JOURNAL OF THE ACM, 1988, 35 (04) :759-768